2 Comments

The Two Faces of Col­ibactin

Note­wor­thy

Two decades ago, col­ibactin – a geno­toxic nat­ural prod­uct – broke into the scene with bad news. Its abil­ity to break apart DNA from eu­kary­otic cells, cou­pled to its pro­duc­tion by strains of the in­testi­nal res­i­dent E. coli raised the specter of a pos­si­ble in­volve­ment in colon can­cer.

Then, in 2022, came a find­ing that seemed to re­deem the mol­e­cule. Its geno­toxic ac­tiv­ity in­duced the SOS re­sponse in nu­mer­ous bac­te­ria. Con­se­quently, col­ibactin pro­duc­ers play an im­por­tant role in shap­ing the com­po­si­tion of the mi­cro­bial com­mu­ni­ties where they re­side. There­fore, view­ing col­ibactin in the hu­man gut pri­mar­ily as a car­cino­gen is not the whole story. As Roberto wrote in a post de­scrib­ing the chem­i­cal ecol­ogy of col­ibactin, think­ing of this nat­ural prod­uct as hav­ing evolved to at­tack eu­kary­otic hosts is "bark­ing up the wrong ecological/evolutionary tree."

But the bad news on col­ibactin re-emerged just last year. Re­sults from a large study pointed to an as­so­ci­a­tion be­tween the type of mu­ta­tions caused by col­ibactin and early-on­set colon can­cer. It seems that the wor­ri­some in­crease of the dis­ease over the last twenty years among those un­der fifty may be linked to ex­po­sure to col­ibactin dur­ing the first few years of life. 

How­ever, there may still be a good side to this mol­e­cule. A re­cent and note­wor­thy study of col­ibactin pro­duc­tion shows con­vinc­ingly that the mol­e­cule has a ben­e­fi­cial role; it de­fends a host against a pathogen. At least in hon­ey­bees.

The hon­ey­bee Apis mel­lif­era. ©Roberto Kolter

The hon­ey­bee gut mi­cro­biome is much less com­plex than that of hu­mans, mak­ing it a great model to de­fine the eco­log­i­cal roles of in­di­vid­ual bac­te­r­ial strains or even mol­e­cules. The hon­ey­bee has a rel­a­tively sim­ple gut mi­cro­biota dom­i­nated by five bac­te­r­ial taxa: Snod­gras­sella, Gilliamella, Bom­bi­lac­to­bacil­lus, Lac­to­bacil­lus and Bi­fi­dobac­terium. With mem­bers of these taxa present in their gut, hon­ey­bees do well. Un­til they be­come in­fected by Ser­ra­tia marcescens. How­ever, if they also har­bor a strain of Frischella per­rara that makes col­ibactin, hon­ey­bees re­sist the pathogen. The eco­log­i­cal con­text clearly mat­ters; ax­enic bees col­o­nized with only the col­ibactin pro­ducer lose fit­ness. But when the col­ibactin pro­duc­ers are part of the com­plete mi­cro­biota (whose mem­bers are col­ibactin re­sis­tant), col­ibactin pro­tects from the pathogen.

Now, back to col­ibactin-pro­duc­ing strains in the hu­man gut and some spec­u­la­tion. It is pos­si­ble that hu­mans har­bored such strains for mil­len­nia and that they con­tributed to colon can­cer all along but at a low fre­quency. But, per­haps, these strains also of­fered some pro­tec­tion from pathogens. Then, some ma­jor change in the nat­ural his­tory of our species changed about sev­enty years ago that led to changes in the com­po­si­tion of early-life gut mi­cro­biota. Think: an­tibi­otic overuse and abuse. This change could have led to an in­crease in abun­dance of col­ibactin pro­duc­ers in the guts of count­less chil­dren from then on­wards. And then, start­ing two decades ago, the neg­a­tive con­se­quences be­gin to emerge... Just some thoughts to con­sider.

 

We'd be de­lighted to hear from you! You can com­ment be­low, send us an email or reach us via Bluesky or Mastodon. Please sub­scribe to get email no­ti­fi­ca­tions of our new posts.

Other Posts

  • The Se­cret Un­der the Ice

    by Manuel Sánchez — There is an old sci­ence fic­tion story called 'Who Goes There' that was twice made into a movie. It dealt with a sci­en­tific ex­pe­di­tion to the North Pole which, un­der the ice, found an ex­trater­res­trial space­ship car­ry­ing alien forms of life. Well, now a real sci­en­tific ex­pe­di­tion to the Antarc­tic found a com­plete ecosys­tem that was trapped...

  • Ex­tremely Slow Growth in the Seabed

    by Roberto — Es­ti­mates are that, at the global scale, there are more mi­cro­bial cells – maybe 5 x 10^29 – in the seabed than in the wa­ter col­umn above. These cells are not just near the seafloor, many of them lie buried deep in the sed­i­ment. Very deep in­deed, as deep as 2.5 kilo­me­ters. And they've been there for a long time, even mil­lions of years.

  • Go­ing Next Door With­out Get­ting Your Feet Wet

    by Elio — In­tra­cel­lu­lar life has its perks. In­side host cells, bac­te­ria are pro­tected from neu­trophils, com­ple­ment, an­ti­bod­ies, some an­tibi­otics, and the other un­pleas­ant things float­ing around in tis­sue flu­ids. In ad­di­tion, here they have ac­cess to am­ple food. But there is a catch, namely how to in­fect other cells and other hosts…

  • The Great Epi­demic

    by Merry Youle — When you read the ti­tle – 'The Great Epi­demic' – what came to mind? The Black Death (Yersinia pestis) that in two years killed 20 mil­lion peo­ple in Eu­rope – ap­prox­i­mately 30–60% of the pop­u­la­tion? The 1918 flu pan­demic with its tally of 50 mil­lion dead in three years? AIDS, with a death toll...

  • Of Aer­obes and Anaer­obes

    Note­wor­thy — When first in­tro­duced to mi­crobes, we quickly learn to di­vide them into aer­obes and anaer­obes. Then we qual­ify those ti­tles with mod­i­fiers to yield such classes as fac­ul­ta­tive anaer­obes, ob­lig­ate aer­obes and strict anaer­obes.

  • Tit-for-Tat: A Bac­te­r­ial Coun­ter­at­tack Sys­tem

    by Spencer Scott & John De Friel — Mi­cro­bial ecol­ogy may be a young field but it is well un­der­stood al­ready that there is a broad spec­trum of in­ter­ac­tions be­tween bac­te­r­ial species, rang­ing from co­op­er­a­tive to com­pet­i­tive. In a re­cent pa­per re­searchers from John Mekalanos' lab fur­ther char­ac­ter­ized a re­cently dis­cov­ered mech­a­nism for in­ter-cell com­mu­ni­ca­tion. This sys­tem, called…

Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Author
STC
1 month ago

George O'Toole com­mented on bluesky:

And a role in CF:
https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/jb.00190–26

Last edited 1 month ago by STC
0
Reply
Author
STC
29 days ago
Reply to  STC

Thanks for bring­ing this to our at­ten­tion George! The Col­ibactin story keeps get­ting more and more in­ter­est­ing. We were al­ready con­sid­er­ing point­ing out your pa­per in a fol­low-up Note­wor­thy! – the STC team.

0
Reply