Sci­ence in Sta­tion­ary Phase

by Roberto

This is the last post I will write for STC...

... be­fore our cus­tom­ary midyear break. I plan to re­turn circa July 20. That will give me a two-month break. Not be­cause I don't want to write. I'll be do­ing plenty of that. No, it's be­cause the topic I'm broach­ing to­day, I feel pas­sion­ate about, but I also know that it will pos­si­bly (likely) pro­voke some strong neg­a­tive re­ac­tions among many of my peers. I say so from prior ex­pe­ri­ence; I could name some for­mer friends but, of course, I will not. I am hop­ing that those two months will al­low any read­ers who re­act neg­a­tively to my ideas to let them per­co­late in their minds. Con­struc­tive crit­i­cism, rather than vis­ceral re­ac­tions, will hope­fully arise.

Last year, I ded­i­cated six Mon­day posts to the un­sus­tain­abil­ity of ex­po­nen­tial growth, whether it be an E. coli cul­ture or the hu­man pop­u­la­tion. Just two weeks ago, I hinted at today's post by prais­ing small sci­ence. Now I face the topic head on, the fact that sci­ence is in sta­tion­ary phase. It's been there for a while. 

My aim with this post is to con­vey a mes­sage of hope to re­place what I per­ceive as a gen­eral sense of de­spair among many sci­en­tists. Where do I see hope? In study­ing what oth­ers be­fore me have said about the growth dy­nam­ics of sci­ence. And be­cause I see great things com­ing from small sci­ence.

Most cer­tainly, I am by no means the first to speak of this. I first was at­tracted to the sub­ject when I read Arthur Kornberg's clas­sic 1995 ed­i­to­r­ial in the jour­nal Sci­ence: "Sci­ence in the Sta­tion­ary Phase." That es­say prompted me to look back at prior think­ing on the sub­ject. I came across two of Derek de Solla's writ­ings from the early 1960s: "Sci­ence Since Baby­lon" and "Lit­tle Sci­ence, Big Sci­ence." All these writ­ings are avail­able on­line and I highly rec­om­mend read­ing them. But, since today's ac­cel­er­ated pace of life leaves most peo­ple with very lit­tle free time, I will share here what I con­sider "gems" taken di­rectly from those writ­ings. Know­ing that these go back thirty and more than sixty years they should give you great per­spec­tive on the cur­rent sit­u­a­tion. 

The fol­low­ing graph, taken from de Solla, shows sci­ence growth (as mea­sured by num­ber of sci­en­tific jour­nals). Based on nearly three hun­dred years of ex­po­nen­tial growth he pro­jected a mil­lion sci­en­tific jour­nals by the year 2000. Mer­ci­fully, we en­tered sta­tion­ary phase. In­stead, the num­ber of such jour­nals at the turn of the cen­tury was around 40,000. Since then, and de­spite the ob­scene spread of preda­tory jour­nals, there's been lit­tle growth; cur­rent es­ti­mates point to 45,000 to 50,000 sci­en­tific jour­nals world­wide. Sta­tion­ary phase.

Num­ber of sci­en­tific jour­nals as a func­tion of time, as pre­sented by Derek de Solla in Sci­ence Since Baby­lon, 1961.

Here are two quotes from de Solla com­ment­ing on the size of sci­ence that par­tic­u­larly res­onated with me:

"Roughly speak­ing, every dou­bling of the pop­u­la­tion has pro­duced at least three dou­blings of the num­ber of sci­en­tists, so that the size of sci­ence is eight times what it was and the num­ber of sci­en­tists per mil­lion pop­u­la­tion has mul­ti­plied by four. Mankind's per capita in­volve­ment with sci­ence has thus been grow­ing much more rapidly than the pop­u­la­tion."

"It is clear that we can­not go up an­other two or­ders of mag­ni­tude as we have climbed the last five [or­ders of mag­ni­tude]. If we did, we should have two sci­en­tists for every man, woman, child, and dog in the pop­u­la­tion, and we should spend on them twice as much money as we had. Sci­en­tific dooms­day is there­fore less than a cen­tury dis­tant."

For­tu­nately, sci­ence en­tered sta­tion­ary phase.

If sci­ence has been in sta­tion­ary phase for decades now, why do we get a greater sense of de­spair to­day vis-à-vis the cur­rent state of sci­ence fund­ing? In his 1995 ed­i­to­r­ial Ko­rn­berg of­fers a re­mark­ably pre­scient ex­pla­na­tion. So much so that it feels as if he had writ­ten it to­day:

"... as more dras­tic re­duc­tions in sup­port for the re­search en­ter­prise have been made, U.S. sci­ence has en­tered its sta­tion­ary phase. With suf­fi­cient ef­fort, we may pro­duce brief bursts of growth here or there, as mi­cro­bial cul­tures do. But to en­sure the con­tin­ued sur­vival of sci­ence, we must be re­source­ful in adapt­ing to the strin­gen­cies of the sta­tion­ary phase."

What we are liv­ing through now is the af­ter­math of one of those "brief bursts of growth." Many of us will re­mem­ber the in­cred­i­ble five-year pe­riod (1998–2003) when the NIH bud­get was dou­bled from $13.6 bil­lion to $27 bil­lion (dic­tated by poli­cies dur­ing the Clin­ton ad­min­is­tra­tion). That was a brief burst of growth. Since then, and ad­justed for in­fla­tion, the pur­chas­ing power of the NIH bud­get has re­mained ba­si­cally flat. Sta­tion­ary phase.

So why the wide­spread malaise among some in­ves­ti­ga­tors? Here is where I get into trou­ble. But sorry, this is true. Bio­med­ical sci­en­tists have not adapted "to the strin­gen­cies of the sta­tion­ary phase." Take the fol­low­ing num­bers with a grain of salt but... Es­ti­mates are that the num­ber of new PhDs awarded in the bi­o­log­i­cal and bio­med­ical sci­ences rose from about 6000 in 2003 to about 10,000 in 2023. Yes, there have been large in­creases in hir­ing of PhDs in biotech and pharma. But those too, will cease. We need to adapt by em­brac­ing small.

Cur­rently, sci­ence is un­der at­tack world­wide. I am a firm be­liever that sci­ence and sci­en­tific train­ing must con­tinue. But the growth dy­nam­ics of the sci­en­tific com­mu­nity must re­flect the fact that we are in sta­tion­ary phase. Is this bad? Not at all! de Solla, in 1962 pro­vided great hope:

The new era shows all the fa­mil­iar syn­dromes of sat­u­ra­tion. This, I must add, is a coun­sel of hope rather than de­spair. Sat­u­ra­tion sel­dom im­plies death, but rather that we have the be­gin­ning of new and ex­cit­ing tac­tics for sci­ence, op­er­at­ing with quite new ground rules.

From where those new ground rules? Here's Kornberg's ad­vice, which I nat­u­rally love:

"Much of what we know about the mech­a­nisms of catal­y­sis and the reg­u­la­tion of bio­chem­i­cal processes has been learned from study of the growth and sur­vival of mi­crobes. Af­ter an in­ter­val of rapid growth, mi­cro­bial cul­tures re­spond to im­pend­ing strin­gen­cies in the en­vi­ron­ment. They sense that the feast­ing is over and that a ma­jor re­order­ing of pri­or­i­ties is needed to sur­vive in what is called the sta­tion­ary phase. Hun­dreds of genes are turned on and oth­ers off, which, along with adap­tive mu­ta­tions, en­sures the sur­vival of the colony dur­ing the sta­tion­ary phase and the colony's reemer­gence un­der more fa­vor­able con­di­tions. What we learn from mi­crobes in the sta­tion­ary phase will, it seems to me, have pro­found sig­nif­i­cance for how we as sci­en­tists cope with di­min­ished sup­port for sci­ence."

Lichens, small, ex­tremely slow-grow­ing, ex­tremely long-lived. © Roberto Kolter

To me, the key is that the cop­ing mech­a­nisms must come from sci­en­tists them­selves and not, as is cur­rently hap­pen­ing, im­posed by anti-sci­ence gov­ern­ments. We must see the cur­rent sit­u­a­tion as a golden op­por­tu­nity to em­brace small. Ko­rn­berg again:

"...back in 1943... ...there were no grants then, lab­o­ra­tory re­sources were mea­ger, and aca­d­e­mic jobs were al­most nonex­is­tent. Those were not the good old days. But rich or poor, sci­ence is great!"

We must learn to rec­og­nize that small sci­ence is not only beau­ti­ful, but also the way to in­sure its sur­vival dur­ing sta­tion­ary phase.

 


We'd be de­lighted to hear from you! You can com­ment be­low, send us an email or reach us via Bluesky or Mastodon. Please sub­scribe to get email no­ti­fi­ca­tions of our new posts.

Other Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Jen Herman
5 months ago

Con­sid­ered we should do more lab com­bin­ing. Con­sol­i­date resources/share more. PIs at bench more. Yes, fewer trainees, grants, & ended ca­reers com­ing. Oc what is hap­pen­ing last 2 yrs is sup­port go­ing mostly to the est & in many cases end of ca­reer peo­ple. Not ex­actly nat­ural se­lec­tion, or maybe it is

Admin
STC
5 months ago
Reply to  Jen Herman

Thank for your com­ment Jen. I like your ideas of con­sol­i­da­tion and shar­ing, as adap­ta­tion to the ces­sa­tion of growth. As for sup­port in the US cur­rently go­ing to "end of ca­reer peo­ple"... This is a point I have raised in my writ­ing be­fore. It's an in­di­vid­ual choice, but I ad­vo­cate shift­ing from "PI" to ac­tive roles with­out use of lim­it­ing re­sources. From per­sonal ex­pe­ri­ence, there's lots that can be done in our "end of ca­reer" stage. I put "end of ca­reer" in quotes be­cause, re­ally, re­tire­ment need not in any way re­quire we end our par­tic­i­pa­tion. –Roberto

bks
5 months ago

The link to Sci­ence Since Baby­lon doesn't work.

Admin
STC
5 months ago
Reply to  bks

You can try this link.

bks
5 months ago
Reply to  STC

Works!

bks
5 months ago
Admin
STC
5 months ago
Reply to  bks

Thanks for shar­ing that link. It is in­deed the ar­gu­ment I was build­ing in my "ex­po­nen­tial growth" se­ries, par­tic­u­larly in "The Great De­cel­er­a­tion" (https://smallthingsconsidered.blog/schaechter/2025/08/the-great-deceleration/) As I have tried to ar­gue, this will be a great chal­lenge but also the great­est op­por­tu­nity hu­man­ity will have! Prob­lem is, most cov­er­age sees that as a "prob­lem" or "cri­sis"... Just have to plant the seeds for chang­ing the mind­set that economies nec­es­sar­ily de­pend on growth. The most in­no­v­a­tive strate­gies come dur­ing sta­tion­ary phase. ‑Roberto