Science in Stationary Phase
by Roberto
This is the last post I will write for STC...
... before our customary midyear break. I plan to return circa July 20. That will give me a two-month break. Not because I don't want to write. I'll be doing plenty of that. No, it's because the topic I'm broaching today, I feel passionate about, but I also know that it will possibly (likely) provoke some strong negative reactions among many of my peers. I say so from prior experience; I could name some former friends but, of course, I will not. I am hoping that those two months will allow any readers who react negatively to my ideas to let them percolate in their minds. Constructive criticism, rather than visceral reactions, will hopefully arise.
Last year, I dedicated six Monday posts to the unsustainability of exponential growth, whether it be an E. coli culture or the human population. Just two weeks ago, I hinted at today's post by praising small science. Now I face the topic head on, the fact that science is in stationary phase. It's been there for a while.
My aim with this post is to convey a message of hope to replace what I perceive as a general sense of despair among many scientists. Where do I see hope? In studying what others before me have said about the growth dynamics of science. And because I see great things coming from small science.
Most certainly, I am by no means the first to speak of this. I first was attracted to the subject when I read Arthur Kornberg's classic 1995 editorial in the journal Science: "Science in the Stationary Phase." That essay prompted me to look back at prior thinking on the subject. I came across two of Derek de Solla's writings from the early 1960s: "Science Since Babylon" and "Little Science, Big Science." All these writings are available online and I highly recommend reading them. But, since today's accelerated pace of life leaves most people with very little free time, I will share here what I consider "gems" taken directly from those writings. Knowing that these go back thirty and more than sixty years they should give you great perspective on the current situation.
The following graph, taken from de Solla, shows science growth (as measured by number of scientific journals). Based on nearly three hundred years of exponential growth he projected a million scientific journals by the year 2000. Mercifully, we entered stationary phase. Instead, the number of such journals at the turn of the century was around 40,000. Since then, and despite the obscene spread of predatory journals, there's been little growth; current estimates point to 45,000 to 50,000 scientific journals worldwide. Stationary phase.

Number of scientific journals as a function of time, as presented by Derek de Solla in Science Since Babylon, 1961.
Here are two quotes from de Solla commenting on the size of science that particularly resonated with me:
"Roughly speaking, every doubling of the population has produced at least three doublings of the number of scientists, so that the size of science is eight times what it was and the number of scientists per million population has multiplied by four. Mankind's per capita involvement with science has thus been growing much more rapidly than the population."
"It is clear that we cannot go up another two orders of magnitude as we have climbed the last five [orders of magnitude]. If we did, we should have two scientists for every man, woman, child, and dog in the population, and we should spend on them twice as much money as we had. Scientific doomsday is therefore less than a century distant."
Fortunately, science entered stationary phase.
If science has been in stationary phase for decades now, why do we get a greater sense of despair today vis-à-vis the current state of science funding? In his 1995 editorial Kornberg offers a remarkably prescient explanation. So much so that it feels as if he had written it today:
"... as more drastic reductions in support for the research enterprise have been made, U.S. science has entered its stationary phase. With sufficient effort, we may produce brief bursts of growth here or there, as microbial cultures do. But to ensure the continued survival of science, we must be resourceful in adapting to the stringencies of the stationary phase."
What we are living through now is the aftermath of one of those "brief bursts of growth." Many of us will remember the incredible five-year period (1998–2003) when the NIH budget was doubled from $13.6 billion to $27 billion (dictated by policies during the Clinton administration). That was a brief burst of growth. Since then, and adjusted for inflation, the purchasing power of the NIH budget has remained basically flat. Stationary phase.
So why the widespread malaise among some investigators? Here is where I get into trouble. But sorry, this is true. Biomedical scientists have not adapted "to the stringencies of the stationary phase." Take the following numbers with a grain of salt but... Estimates are that the number of new PhDs awarded in the biological and biomedical sciences rose from about 6000 in 2003 to about 10,000 in 2023. Yes, there have been large increases in hiring of PhDs in biotech and pharma. But those too, will cease. We need to adapt by embracing small.
Currently, science is under attack worldwide. I am a firm believer that science and scientific training must continue. But the growth dynamics of the scientific community must reflect the fact that we are in stationary phase. Is this bad? Not at all! de Solla, in 1962 provided great hope:
The new era shows all the familiar syndromes of saturation. This, I must add, is a counsel of hope rather than despair. Saturation seldom implies death, but rather that we have the beginning of new and exciting tactics for science, operating with quite new ground rules.
From where those new ground rules? Here's Kornberg's advice, which I naturally love:
"Much of what we know about the mechanisms of catalysis and the regulation of biochemical processes has been learned from study of the growth and survival of microbes. After an interval of rapid growth, microbial cultures respond to impending stringencies in the environment. They sense that the feasting is over and that a major reordering of priorities is needed to survive in what is called the stationary phase. Hundreds of genes are turned on and others off, which, along with adaptive mutations, ensures the survival of the colony during the stationary phase and the colony's reemergence under more favorable conditions. What we learn from microbes in the stationary phase will, it seems to me, have profound significance for how we as scientists cope with diminished support for science."

Lichens, small, extremely slow-growing, extremely long-lived. © Roberto Kolter
To me, the key is that the coping mechanisms must come from scientists themselves and not, as is currently happening, imposed by anti-science governments. We must see the current situation as a golden opportunity to embrace small. Kornberg again:
"...back in 1943... ...there were no grants then, laboratory resources were meager, and academic jobs were almost nonexistent. Those were not the good old days. But rich or poor, science is great!"
We must learn to recognize that small science is not only beautiful, but also the way to insure its survival during stationary phase.
We'd be delighted to hear from you! You can comment below, send us an email or reach us via Bluesky or Mastodon. Please subscribe to get email notifications of our new posts.

Considered we should do more lab combining. Consolidate resources/share more. PIs at bench more. Yes, fewer trainees, grants, & ended careers coming. Oc what is happening last 2 yrs is support going mostly to the est & in many cases end of career people. Not exactly natural selection, or maybe it is
Thank for your comment Jen. I like your ideas of consolidation and sharing, as adaptation to the cessation of growth. As for support in the US currently going to "end of career people"... This is a point I have raised in my writing before. It's an individual choice, but I advocate shifting from "PI" to active roles without use of limiting resources. From personal experience, there's lots that can be done in our "end of career" stage. I put "end of career" in quotes because, really, retirement need not in any way require we end our participation. –Roberto
The link to Science Since Babylon doesn't work.
You can try this link.
Works!
Homo sapiens in stationary phase?
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/05/global-birthrate-decline/687297/
Thanks for sharing that link. It is indeed the argument I was building in my "exponential growth" series, particularly in "The Great Deceleration" (https://smallthingsconsidered.blog/schaechter/2025/08/the-great-deceleration/) As I have tried to argue, this will be a great challenge but also the greatest opportunity humanity will have! Problem is, most coverage sees that as a "problem" or "crisis"... Just have to plant the seeds for changing the mindset that economies necessarily depend on growth. The most innovative strategies come during stationary phase. ‑Roberto