Black Death Mysteries
by Mechas
The Black Death was one of the deadliest pandemics in human history. It resulted in the death of nearly half the population in medieval Europe and had long-term social impacts. But exactly how did Yersinia pestis, the causal agent of the bubonic plague, manage to spread so successfully and cause such large-scale devastation? A recent publication offers a refreshing perspective.
Y. pestis persists in various natural rodent reservoirs, from which it is usually transmitted to humans via flea bites. Despite being occasional, these zoonotic spillover events have been responsible for three reported pandemics in the current era: The Justinian Plague that started circa 541, the Black Death that started in Asia around 1338 and spread to Europe, and the third pandemic in the 1770s in China. Understanding the disease, pandemics, and Yersinia pathogenicity has been the focus of many studies and are topics that fascinate us here at STC.
Archaeological, historical, and ancient genomic data indicate that the second pandemic bacterium responsible for the Black Death most likely originated in what is now Kyrgyzstan. However, many details regarding its introduction into Europe and its successful and devastating spread are unclear. In a recently published study, researchers tackle this question via an interdisciplinary approach. By combining data on climate, ecology, and society, they propose novel explanations to clarify the rapid spread that made the second plague pandemic so deadly.
The authors use information on climate, tree-ring data from across Europe, and signs of volcanic eruptions to propose that a large-scale eruption occurred around 1345 CE. The ensuing changes in climate conditions then impacted agricultural productivity in different parts of Europe. These environmental events coincided with the rise of self-governing city-states in Europe, such as Venice, many of which established systems to ensure food security given their limited production capacity and growing population. Many urban centers in Italy, therefore, relied on the import of grain from distant locations to stave off starvation. But in welcoming much-needed grain supplies, they inadvertently opened their doors to Y. pestis.

Grain trade and plague dispersal. Main aspects of the Venetian, Genoese and Pisan grain trade network that prevented much of Italy from starvation in 1347 CE but also brought the plague bacterium Yersinia pestis to Venice and other Mediterranean harbours during the second half of 1347 CE, from where it spread rapidly. Location of the tree ring-based climate reconstructions is indicated (with two sites in Scandinavia not shown). Map is an equal-area, pseudo-cylindrical Mollweide projection with greyscale referring to elevations above sea level. Source
The authors propose that the severity of this second pandemic plague was a consequence of a confluence of unfortunate events, likely catalyzed by environmental change. The cold and wet climate around 1345 and 1346, possibly due to a volcanic eruption, resulted in food shortages that required the import of grain that arrived in ships that also carried the plague pathogen. From here, the plague spread to nearby cities and regions in the Mediterranean. In sum, the very systems set in place to prevent starvation in major Italian cities also facilitated the entry of the bubonic plague into Europe.
The authors stress that it is difficult to establish direct links across large geographical distances and to fully uncover events in detail based on historical data. However, this study exemplifies the interconnected nature of human societies and how we subsist thanks to so many, often overlooked, connections. But this same connectivity also becomes a vulnerability. This was made evident during the recent COVID-19 pandemic. Not to mention the problems arising from unresolved conflict in the Persian Gulf.
We'd be delighted to hear from you! You can comment below, send us an email or reach us via Bluesky or Mastodon. Please subscribe to get email notifications of our new posts.

Roland Hatzenpichler (@environmicrobio.bsky.social) wrote on Bluesky:
This new proposal doesn't solve the riddle how the plague could spread many dozens of kilometers in a single day or two as reported for central europe. Y. pestis is not airborne and relies on rodents/fleas to spread, which cannot travel that fast. Even humans at that time couldn't travel that fast.
To the best of my knowledge, most experts doubt that the great plague/great mortality/black plague was caused by (just) Y. pestis. Reports on symptoms and the quick spread don't add up. I recommend this three-part (2h 30m) series on it: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-102-what-caused-the-black-death-part‑i/id1021703062?i=1000504440115
Thanks for the comment. Indeed, this is an ongoing dilemma and any information that can add to what we know is more than welcome. Thanks for the link to the podcast.