Black Death Mys­ter­ies

by Me­chas

The Black Death was one of the dead­liest pan­demics in hu­man his­tory. It re­sulted in the death of nearly half the pop­u­la­tion in me­dieval Eu­rope and had long-term so­cial im­pacts. But ex­actly how did Yersinia pestis, the causal agent of the bubonic plague, man­age to spread so suc­cess­fully and cause such large-scale dev­as­ta­tion? A re­cent pub­li­ca­tion of­fers a re­fresh­ing per­spec­tive.

Y. pestis per­sists in var­i­ous nat­ural ro­dent reser­voirs, from which it is usu­ally trans­mit­ted to hu­mans via flea bites. De­spite be­ing oc­ca­sional, these zoonotic spillover events have been re­spon­si­ble for three re­ported pan­demics in the cur­rent era: The Jus­tin­ian Plague that started circa 541, the Black Death that started in Asia around 1338 and spread to Eu­rope, and the third pan­demic in the 1770s in China. Un­der­stand­ing the dis­ease, pan­demics, and Yersinia path­o­genic­ity has been the fo­cus of many stud­ies and are top­ics that fas­ci­nate us here at STC.

Ar­chae­o­log­i­cal, his­tor­i­cal, and an­cient ge­nomic data in­di­cate that the sec­ond pan­demic bac­terium re­spon­si­ble for the Black Death most likely orig­i­nated in what is now Kyr­gyzs­tan. How­ever, many de­tails re­gard­ing its in­tro­duc­tion into Eu­rope and its suc­cess­ful and dev­as­tat­ing spread are un­clear. In a re­cently pub­lished study, re­searchers tackle this ques­tion via an in­ter­dis­ci­pli­nary ap­proach. By com­bin­ing data on cli­mate, ecol­ogy, and so­ci­ety, they pro­pose novel ex­pla­na­tions to clar­ify the rapid spread that made the sec­ond plague pan­demic so deadly. 

The au­thors use in­for­ma­tion on cli­mate, tree-ring data from across Eu­rope, and signs of vol­canic erup­tions to pro­pose that a large-scale erup­tion oc­curred around 1345 CE. The en­su­ing changes in cli­mate con­di­tions then im­pacted agri­cul­tural pro­duc­tiv­ity in dif­fer­ent parts of Eu­rope. These en­vi­ron­men­tal events co­in­cided with the rise of self-gov­ern­ing city-states in Eu­rope, such as Venice, many of which es­tab­lished sys­tems to en­sure food se­cu­rity given their lim­ited pro­duc­tion ca­pac­ity and grow­ing pop­u­la­tion. Many ur­ban cen­ters in Italy, there­fore, re­lied on the im­port of grain from dis­tant lo­ca­tions to stave off star­va­tion. But in wel­com­ing much-needed grain sup­plies, they in­ad­ver­tently opened their doors to Y. pestis. 

Grain trade and plague dis­per­sal. Main as­pects of the Venet­ian, Ge­noese and Pisan grain trade net­work that pre­vented much of Italy from star­va­tion in 1347 CE but also brought the plague bac­terium Yersinia pestis to Venice and other Mediter­ranean har­bours dur­ing the sec­ond half of 1347 CE, from where it spread rapidly. Lo­ca­tion of the tree ring-based cli­mate re­con­struc­tions is in­di­cated (with two sites in Scan­di­navia not shown). Map is an equal-area, pseudo-cylin­dri­cal Moll­weide pro­jec­tion with greyscale re­fer­ring to el­e­va­tions above sea level. Source

The au­thors pro­pose that the sever­ity of this sec­ond pan­demic plague was a con­se­quence of a con­flu­ence of un­for­tu­nate events, likely cat­alyzed by en­vi­ron­men­tal change. The cold and wet cli­mate around 1345 and 1346, pos­si­bly due to a vol­canic erup­tion, re­sulted in food short­ages that re­quired the im­port of grain that ar­rived in ships that also car­ried the plague pathogen. From here, the plague spread to nearby cities and re­gions in the Mediter­ranean. In sum, the very sys­tems set in place to pre­vent star­va­tion in ma­jor Ital­ian cities also fa­cil­i­tated the en­try of the bubonic plague into Eu­rope. 

The au­thors stress that it is dif­fi­cult to es­tab­lish di­rect links across large ge­o­graph­i­cal dis­tances and to fully un­cover events in de­tail based on his­tor­i­cal data. How­ever, this study ex­em­pli­fies the in­ter­con­nected na­ture of hu­man so­ci­eties and how we sub­sist thanks to so many, of­ten over­looked, con­nec­tions. But this same con­nec­tiv­ity also be­comes a vul­ner­a­bil­ity. This was made ev­i­dent dur­ing the re­cent COVID-19 pan­demic. Not to men­tion the prob­lems aris­ing from un­re­solved con­flict in the Per­sian Gulf.  

 


We'd be de­lighted to hear from you! You can com­ment be­low, send us an email or reach us via Bluesky or Mastodon. Please sub­scribe to get email no­ti­fi­ca­tions of our new posts.

Other Posts

  • Ice Ice Maybe

    by Janie — The abil­ity to trig­ger ice for­ma­tion is a prop­erty shared by cer­tain par­ti­cles both or­ganic and in­or­ganic, in­clud­ing bac­te­ria, viruses, phy­to­plank­ton, pollen, soot, dust. These lit­tle par­ti­cles help wa­ter mol­e­cules come to­gether and form ice at warmer tem­per­a­tures than freez­ing point...

  • Plant Pathogen Si­lences Host's Im­mune Genes

    by S. Mar­vin Fried­man — As more and more in­for­ma­tion be­comes avail­able, one mar­vels (and also frets) at the so­phis­ti­cated strate­gies that pathogens have evolved in or­der to evade their hosts' de­fense mech­a­nisms. Many pathogens of plants and an­i­mals de­liver ef­fec­tors into their hosts in or­der to sup­press im­mune re­sponses. To date, the vast ma­jor­ity of…

  • It Takes Three to Tango

    by Merry Youle — Glassy-winged sharp­shoot­ers, long no­to­ri­ous in wine coun­try as an in­sect vec­tor for Pierce's dis­ease in grapes, have re­cently achieved no­tice for em­ploy­ing not one but two bac­te­r­ial en­dosym­bionts to pro­vide es­sen­tial nu­tri­ents. One...

  • How Much Does Bi­ol­ogy Weigh?

    by Elio — The very last thing that hap­pened to me at the June 2018 ASM's At­lanta meet­ing (Mi­crobe 2018) was a par­tic­u­larly re­ward­ing co­in­ci­dence. As I was ready to step on an es­ca­la­tor at the con­ven­tion cen­ter, ready to go to the air­port, a young man stopped me and asked to talk to me. It was...

Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
5 months ago

Roland Hatzen­pich­ler (@environmicrobio.bsky.social) wrote on Bluesky:

This new pro­posal doesn't solve the rid­dle how the plague could spread many dozens of kilo­me­ters in a sin­gle day or two as re­ported for cen­tral eu­rope. Y. pestis is not air­borne and re­lies on rodents/fleas to spread, which can­not travel that fast. Even hu­mans at that time couldn't travel that fast.

To the best of my knowl­edge, most ex­perts doubt that the great plague/great mortality/black plague was caused by (just) Y. pestis. Re­ports on symp­toms and the quick spread don't add up. I rec­om­mend this three-part (2h 30m) se­ries on it: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-102-what-caused-the-black-death-part‑i/id1021703062?i=1000504440115

Last edited 5 months ago by STC
Mechas
5 months ago

Thanks for the com­ment. In­deed, this is an on­go­ing dilemma and any in­for­ma­tion that can add to what we know is more than wel­come. Thanks for the link to the pod­cast.