Lar­val Set­tle­ment

by Roberto

An­i­mals orig­i­nate, evolve, and un­dergo de­vel­op­ment in a mi­cro­bial world. This point was ele­gantly brought home as the "new im­per­a­tive" for bi­ol­ogy in an in­flu­en­tial per­spec­tive by Mc­Fall-Ngai et al. in 2013 (high­lighted by Elio here️‍). The fact that ubiq­ui­tous bac­te­r­ial-an­i­mal in­ter­ac­tions are me­di­ated by the ex­change of mol­e­cules, i.e., chem­i­cal ecol­ogy, was re­viewed soon there­after by Cant­ley and Clardy. A beau­ti­ful ex­am­ple of how an­i­mal de­vel­opment is guided by bac­te­r­ial chem­i­cal cues is the meta­mor­pho­sis of the bot­tom-dwelling ma­rine worm Hy­droides el­e­gans.

Fig. 1. Adult and lar­val stages of Hy­droides el­e­gans. (a) Ag­gre­ga­tions of adult H. el­e­gans on ex­truded plas­tic mesh. Sev­eral in­di­vid­u­als have their crowns of ten­ta­cles ex­tended for feed­ing. (b) Meta­mor­phi­cally com­petent larva of H. el­e­gans. Ar­row points to api­cal cilia that are prob­a­bly used to sense in­duc­tive cues on biofilm bac­te­ria. Source. Fron­tispiece: Adult Hy­droides el­e­gans. Source

Lar­vae of ma­rine in­ver­te­brates only sur­vive and meta­mor­pho­size into ju­ve­niles (and even­tu­ally adults) when they set­tle on the "right spots " at the bot­tom of the sea. Yet they do not set­tle ran­domly. How do the lar­vae find these spots? In­vari­ably, these are sur­faces cov­ered with mi­cro­bial biofilms. The process of sub­merged sur­face col­o­niza­tion, first by bac­te­ria and then by seden­tary an­i­mals such as bar­na­cles, is of­ten re­ferred to as bio­foul­ing. (As an aside, I of­fer my very per­sonal opin­ion on this term, which I find hor­ri­bly an­thro­pocen­tric. What gets fouled? The in­va­sive sur­faces that hu­mans in­sist on keep­ing pris­tine for eco­nomic rea­sons, e.g. hulls of ships. Rather than bio­foul­ing, I see beau­ti­ful ecol­ogy.)

H. el­e­gans is a won­der­ful model sys­tem for the study of lar­val set­tle­ment. Thanks in large part to the work car­ried out by Michael Had­field and col­leagues in Hawaii since 1990, the life cy­cle of this worm, par­tic­u­larly the set­tle­ment on bac­te­r­ial biofilm, is now un­der­stood in de­tail. They were able to cul­ti­vate the an­i­mal in the lab and thus ma­nip­u­late its environ­ment. In the process they were able to iso­late and char­ac­ter­ize strains of bac­te­ria that were par­tic­u­larly good at in­duc­ing lar­val set­tle­ment. Among these were iso­lates of Pseudoal­teromonas lu­teovi­o­lacea.

Fig. 2. Top: Elec­tron mi­cro­graphs of sev­eral func­tional states of the con­trac­tile struc­tures. Scale­bar = 100 nm. Bot­tom: Schematic of the func­tional states.  For full leg­end of fig­ure see source.

The power of ge­net­ics led to the dis­cov­ery of a mech­a­nism through which P. lu­teovi­o­lacea sig­nals the larva to set­tle on top of the biofilm and ini­ti­ate de­vel­op­ment. First came the isola­tion of bac­te­r­ial mu­tants that no longer re­cruited the lar­vae to the biofilm and thus failed to meta­mor­pho­size. Se­quence analy­ses of the in­ter­rupted genes in­di­cated that their prod­ucts were sim­i­lar to tai­locins, phage tail-like bac­te­ri­ocins. This in­sight led to mi­cro­scopic analy­ses show­ing that con­trac­tile struc­tures of the bac­te­ria were in­deed in­volved in lar­val set­tle­ment and meta­mor­pho­sis (Fig. 2). Sub­se­quent re­sults iden­ti­fied a pro­tein (metamor­phosis in­duc­ing fac­tor 1 or Mif1) that was in­jected into the lar­vae through the con­trac­tile struc­ture and which ini­ti­ated the de­vel­op­men­tal trans­for­ma­tion by in­creas­ing di­a­cyl­glyc­erol, thus trig­ger­ing a phospho­trans­ferase sig­nal­ing cas­cade. This set of beau­ti­ful re­sults might lead one to be­lieve that there is a uni­ver­sal mol­e­c­u­lar mech­a­nism through which lar­vae from ma­rine in­ver­te­brates can iden­tify good spots for set­tle­ment and meta­mor­pho­sis. Ex­cept... there's more than one way to skim a biofilm.

In the ini­tial search for bac­te­r­ial strains that in­duced lar­val set­tle­ment and meta­mor­pho­sis, Cel­lu­lophaga lyt­ica also came up. Yet, its genome does not en­code any phage tail-like struc­tures. The hunt was on for an­other mol­e­cule re­sponsible for the in­duc­ing ac­tiv­ity. Through a rig­or­ous (and la­bo­ri­ous) ac­tiv­ity-guided frac­tion­a­tion, the au­thors of a re­cent study pu­ri­fied the in­duc­ing mol­e­cule. It was the lipopolysac­cha­ride (LPS) of C. lyt­ica's outer mem­brane.

Fig. 3. The gen­eral struc­ture of the lipopolysac­cha­rides (LPS) of Gram (-) bac­te­ria. LPS is the main com­po­nent of the outer layer of the outer mem­brane. Adapted from source.

For the unini­ti­ated, the LPS is the un­usual lipid that makes up the outer leaflet of the outer mem­brane of Gram-neg­a­tive bac­te­ria. LPS can be di­vided into three com­po­nents. Lipid A is highly im­muno­genic and is rec­og­nized through the TLR4 re­cep­tor of the in­nate im­mune sys­tem. Lipid A is con­nected to the core oligosac­cha­ride which in turn is con­nected to a highly vari­able poly­sac­cha­ride known as the O‑side chain. Its vari­abil­ity is both in the com­po­si­tion and num­ber of the re­peat­ing oligosac­cha­ride units. When Gram-neg­a­tive bac­te­ria in­fect a mam­malian host, an­ti­bod­ies are of­ten gen­er­ated against the O‑side chain. Thus its other name, the O‑antigen. The vari­abil­ity in O‑antigen struc­ture can form the ba­sis for serotyp­ing of bac­te­r­ial strains (e.g., the path­o­genic E. coli O157). The part of the LPS from C. lyt­ica that in­duces H. el­e­gans to set­tle and meta­mor­pho­size turned out to be the O‑antigen. Not sur­prisingly, not all C. lyt­ica strains in­duce de­vel­op­ment be­cause O‑antigens are highly vari­able. I find this high de­gree of se­lec­tiv­ity by the lar­vae fas­ci­nat­ing and, to me at least, in­dica­tive of co­or­di­na­tion be­tween bac­te­ria and an­i­mal that is more than just the recog­ni­tion of a good spot to set­tle on. Are there any other steps in the life of the an­i­mal that are guided by its as­sociation with biofilm bac­te­ria? Has there been some co-evo­lu­tion of bac­te­ria and an­i­mal? We'll just have to wait and see. I think there's great po­ten­tial for dis­cov­ery in study­ing this fas­ci­nat­ing an­i­mal-bac­te­r­ial in­ter­ac­tion. 

 
 

Do you want to com­ment on this post? We would be happy about it! Please send us an email, or com­ment on Mastodon or Bluesky.

Other Posts

  • Fine Lit­er­a­ture: Shed­ding Light on Bac­te­ria

    by Elio — Why some bac­te­ria are bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent is a topic that just won't go away. In an ear­lier post, we men­tioned a pro­posal for a role of light in the re­pair of UV-in­duced DNA dam­age. In 2005, Eric Stabb wrote a re­view in 'Mi­crobe' that pleas­antly helps in for­mu­lat­ing the is­sues and clar­i­fy­ing the na­ture...

  • On Bac­te­ria Get­ting Fat

    by Roberto — In bac­te­ria and ar­chaea, lipids seem to be found mainly in the cell mem­brane. Can you think of pos­si­ble func­tions for lipids else­where in bac­te­r­ial and/or ar­chaeal cells? On first in­spec­tion, these two open­ing sen­tences have the mak­ings of an STC Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion. Ex­cept for the fact that in­tra­cel­lu­lar fat ac­cu­mu­la­tion or, more pre­cisely, cy­to­plas­mic li­pidic in­clu­sions...

  • Gifts from Above

    by Elio — Crea­tures liv­ing at the bot­tom of the sea get much of their food from those that lived above and died. This bi­o­log­i­cal de­tri­tus slowly de­scends to the sea floor. In the lan­guage of the trade, "pelagic or­gan­isms are a trophic re­source for ben­thic ones" Ma­rine sci­en­tists Dell'Anno and Danovaro...

  • Could We Have Started Out as Mag­ne­to­tac­tic Bac­te­ria?

    by Elio — There are bac­te­ria that have small mag­nets within them. Mag­ne­to­tac­tic bac­te­ria. The mag­nets con­sist of iron-con­tain­ing crys­tals lined up in a row along the long axis of the cells, which en­dows the cells with the equiv­a­lent of a mag­netic nee­dle. These bac­te­ria thus can sense the earth's mag­netic field, which...

  • Let Smell Guide You

    by Roberto — Anos­mia: the loss of the sense of smell. Un­til re­cently, I was clue­less about anos­mia. That changed March 22nd when my good friend Hera Vla­makis alerted me to a NYT ar­ti­cle de­scrib­ing anos­mia as a pos­si­ble symp­tom of COVID-19. My self-eval­u­a­tion rou­tine changed hence­forth to in­clude a test of my ca­pac­ity to smell. Now, dur­ing...