When shat­tered glass art evokes a sci­en­tific pa­per?

by Janie

Re­cently I stum­bled across Si­mon Berger's shat­tered glass art­work, and was re­minded of RNA-seq and tran­scrip­tomics, of all things.

The Swiss artist's pieces each be­gin with a large pane of glass. He shat­ters the pane, some­times by heavy blows via ham­mer that gen­er­ate large frag­ments, some­times with more pre­cise taps that pro­duce con­cen­trated clus­ters of lac­er­a­tions, and yet other times by scor­ing the glass with a blade and then snap­ping it along that axis. Vary­ing the method of glass-shat­ter­ing serves as this artist's palette, from broad and lin­ear frac­tures to fine spi­der­web-like vein­ing. Some of his fin­ished works are sin­gle panes of glass, like his por­trait of Ka­mala Har­ris, while oth­ers are mul­ti­ple panes stacked on top of each other, like his "Shat­ter­ing Beauty" (Fig. 1).

FigureFig­ure 1. "Shat­ter­ing Beauty" by Si­mon Berger. Source

Sim­ply imag­in­ing rais­ing a ham­mer to again strike the glass pane of a work in progress, I feel anx­ious – such a fine line be­tween con­tin­u­ing to make art and need­ing to start over! What Berger does seems like such a del­i­cate bal­ance be­tween cre­ation and de­struc­tion, where many lit­tle lines make up the whole, so that the fi­nal "pic­ture" we see is our sub­jec­tive in­ter­pre­ta­tion of the amal­ga­ma­tion of those many data points. Sound like a tran­scrip­tome yet? (There is also the fact that Berger refers to his glass-shat­ter­ing art-mak­ing process as "mor­pho­gen­e­sis," a term that of course also refers broadly to bi­o­log­i­cal phe­nom­ena that have been the sub­ject of tran­scrip­tomic scrutiny across var­i­ous or­gan­isms.)

FigureFig. 2 In vivo RNA 3' end pro­files re­veal that the ma­jor­ity of tran­scripts are not full-length in E. coli). Φend in­di­cates the frac­tion of 3' end se­quenc­ing reads that map to the 3' end of the ma­ture tran­script (the lower this value, the more tran­script frag­ments there are). Left: the Φend cal­cu­lated for var­i­ous tran­scripts, as cor­re­la­ted be­tween two repli­cates. Right: the cor­re­la­tion be­tween the frac­tion of full-length tran­scripts as cal­cu­lated by 3' end-seq and by North­ern blot for a se­lect few tran­scripts. From Fig­ure 1 of Source.

It was Berger's piece "Shat­ter­ing Beauty" that re­minded me of a pa­per on tran­script frag­ments from a cou­ple years ago. In 2022, Herzel et al. re­ported that a sub­stan­tial por­tion of the E. coli tran­scrip­tome con­sists of par­tial tran­scripts aris­ing from mRNA de­cay. Around 60% of the tran­scripts stud­ied were trun­cated at the 3' end. These par­tial tran­scripts were not pri­mar­ily nascent RNAs, as in­di­cated by the very dif­fer­ent 3'-end-sequencing pro­files of to­tal RNA and of nascent RNA. The no­tion of the frag­ments aris­ing from de­cay was also sup­ported by cor­re­la­tions be­tween these in­ter­nal 3' end sites and two degra­da­tion sig­nat­ures – cleav­age sites for RNase E (the main en­donu­cle­ase in mRNA de­cay) and polyadeny­la­tion – in both wild type and a PN­Pase mu­tant (the main ex­onu­cle­ase in mRNA de­cay, which comes into play af­ter RNase E). What was most in­ter­est­ing, when think­ing about in­ter­pret­ing data as real bi­ol­ogy, was that the ma­jor­ity of trans­la­tion was oc­cur­ring on full-length and nascent tran­scripts, not on these de­graded and de­grad­ing frag­ments. In other words, the pretty pic­ture of a cell's in­ner work­ings painted by RNA-seq data might not nec­es­sar­ily be a very bi­o­log­i­cally rel­e­vant por­trait.

This is not to say that all RNA degra­da­tion is not bi­o­log­i­cally rel­e­vant. Some cases of mRNA de­cay are "strate­gic." The E. coli malEFG operon comes to mind. The 5' end of its tran­script, which har­bors the gene en­cod­ing the mal­tose-bind­ing pro­tein, is pro­tected against exo­nuclease ac­tiv­ity by REP se­quence hair­pins, while the un­pro­tected 3' end of the tran­script is more eas­ily de­graded. This dif­fer­en­tial degra­da­tion along the same tran­script re­sults in higher lev­els of that mal­tose-bind­ing pro­tein, which is, fit­tingly, re­quired in higher lev­els than the other pro­teins en­coded by the rest of the operon. Sim­i­lar prin­ci­ples ap­ply to poly­cistronic tran­scripts of other ABC trans­port sys­tems, on which hair­pin struc­tures con­fer re­sis­tance against PN­Pase ac­tiv­ity for up­stream genes.

It's also worth not­ing that the ori­gin of tran­script frag­ments also de­pends on the species. While the par­tial tran­scripts in Herzel et al.'s E. coli were pri­mar­ily a re­sult of mRNA de­cay, a re­cent pub­li­ca­tion by Ju et al. demon­strated that this is not the case in My­cobac­terium tub­er­culosis. In My­cobac­terium, the ma­jor­ity of par­tial tran­scripts are in fact nascent mR­NAs, as sug­gested by their fre­quent as­so­ci­a­tion with RNA poly­merases.

Why ex­actly this pa­per along with Herzel et al. jumped to mind upon see­ing Berger's "Shat­tering Beauty" is prob­a­bly some com­bi­na­tion of 1. Frag­ments of both RNA and glass; 2. A shared sense of "you see what you want to see": an as­sem­blage of glass frag­men­ta­tion pat­terns can look like a skull if you choose to look at it from one ori­en­ta­tion. This it­self smells of RNA-seq data in­ter­pre­ta­tion and the pit­falls thereof (hence the skull); 3. An un­conscious link­age of glass -> trans­par­ent -> wa­ter -> cell, and of skull -> death -> de­cay -> RNA degra­da­tion; 4. The im­age of shat­ter­ing glass is rem­i­nis­cent of bust­ing open cells to ex­tract their RNA. Tran­scrip­tomics seeks an­swers to life via the death of cells (hence the skull, again); 5. The side view of "Shat­ter­ing Beauty" looks like a pile-up of mapped reads.

I do like the idea of pair­ing art­works with sci­en­tific bod­ies of work. I'd love to know what other pair­ings oth­ers have come across! In the mean­time, I'll be keep­ing an eye out my­self for more.

 

Do you want to com­ment on this post? We would be happy about it! Please send us an email, or com­ment on Mastodon, or on Bluesky.
 

Other Posts

  • An­i­mat­ing the Inan­i­mate

    by Marcelo Bar­ros and Brana Vla­sic — Con­crete is the most widely used build­ing ma­te­r­ial in the world, with un­told amounts be­ing pro­duced yearly. It has al­ways been re­garded as a strong, solid, im­pen­e­tra­ble, al­most in­de­struc­tible ma­te­r­ial yet it can make cracks that are vul­ner­a­ble to pen­e­tra­tion by wa­ter. As the re­sult, struc­tures of great eco­nomic and…

  • Fine Read­ing: Ar­bo­real Mat­ters

    by Elio — The Tree of Life vies with the Ori­gin of Life for a po­si­tion of high­est sig­nif­i­cance among bi­o­log­i­cal con­cerns. Those who write about it (bioar­borists?) have much to say about its anatomy. Does it con­sist of sim­ple branches, as per Darwin's sketch, or is it anas­to­mosed into a bram­ble of con­nected branches? This mat­ters.

  • A Sul­fur For An Oxy­gen

    by Elio — Tam­per­ing with the chem­istry of our holi­est of mol­e­cules may seem sac­ri­le­gious, but it is wide­spread and con­spic­u­ous. In fact, DNA mod­i­fi­ca­tions abound. Think, for starters of DNA methy­la­tion, which is the main tool of epi­ge­net­ics, or an even longer known mod­i­fi­ca­tion, the DNA gly­co­sy­la­tion that in some phages pro­tects their DNA from...

  • C‑Reactive Pro­tein

    Pic­tures Con­sid­ered #49 by Elio — Among the blood tests that your doc­tor may pre­scribes is the one for C‑Reactive Pro­tein (CRP). What is it? CRP is a pro­tein made by the liver in re­sponse to in­flam­ma­tion any­where in the body, so a pos­i­tive re­sult will alert the physi­cian that some­thing along those lines is go­ing on some place within you.

  • SIMPLIFY Sci­ence Writ­ing

    by Roberto — Writ­ing is an es­sen­tial part of all sci­en­tific en­deav­ors. Yet it is rare to find a sci­en­tist that finds it easy, not to men­tion joy­ful. I am not much dif­fer­ent. But af­ter many years at it, I have learned to take cer­tain steps that make the process at least less daunt­ing, even sim­ple.

  • Sign­ing Books in Boston

    by Elio — While at­tend­ing this year's ASM Mi­crobe con­fer­ence in Boston, MA., Elio had a chance to sign copies of his newest books, 'In The Com­pany of Mi­crobes' and 'Mi­crobe, Sec­ond Edi­tion'. And we were there to film it. Watch as Elio and co-au­thor Michele Swan­son de­scribe what you'll find in the pages of these great new books.