A Whiff of Tax­on­omy – Among Vam­pires

by Christoph

Elio wrote A Ta­ble for Two many years ago, about the sur­pris­ing ob­ser­va­tion that the Gram‑nega­tive bac­terium Vib­rio vul­nifi­cus can be preyed upon si­mul­ta­ne­ously by a bac­teriophage and a "bac­te­ri­ovorous" bac­terium. He could hardly have fig­ured that the sin­gle im­age in his piece is a per­fect vi­gnette for the greatly in­creased in­ter­est in phages and "Bdellovib­rio and like or­gan­isms" (BA­LOs) to­day.

Bac­te­rio­phages and preda­tory bac­te­ria ap­pear as promis­ing al­ter­na­tives to an­tibi­otic thera­py at a time when physi­cians dread that bac­te­r­ial in­fectious dis­eases will soon no longer be as de­feat­able as they were for much of the last cen­tury. The spread of re­sis­tances to vir­tu­al­ly all thera­peutically re­le­vant an­tibi­otics in all ma­jor hu­man pathogens, in­clud­ing but not re­stricted to the ESKAPE patho­gens, and the al­most com­plete lack of newly de­vel­oped an­ti­biotics have led to this dire sit­u­a­tion, world­wide. (In Ger­many alone, the num­ber of hos­pital pa­tients who die each year from non-treat­able in­fec­tions al­ready sig­nif­i­cantly ex­ceeds the num­ber of traf­fic fa­tal­i­ties, and the trend is up­ward.)

Fig­ure 1. Elec­tron mi­cro­graphs show­ing preda­tory at­tach­ment of Bdellovib­rio to Es­cherichia coli prey (fron­tispiece) and repli­ca­tion of Bdellovib­rio within prey (here). Source

STC has cov­ered phage ther­apy ear­lier (see here⛓️‍💥 and here⛓️‍💥), and preda­tory bac­te­ria only spuri­ously. Here, now, I will not re­view the ex­ist­ing re­search projects on the thera­peutic use of pre­datory bac­te­ria, but will wrap-up their di­ver­sity across the dif­fer­ent bac­terial and ar­chaeal clades. Here it goes.

Re­cently star­ring in the re­make of Le bal des vam­pires, Bdellovib­rio ex­ovorus JSST (the super­script T stands for "type strain"), was re­named Pseudob­dellovib­rio exo­vorus JSST by Waite et al. (2020) to in­di­cate that its sim­i­lar­ity to the bet­ter known Bdellovib­rio bacterio­vorus (Fig­ure 1) is not suf­fi­cient to place both in the same genus. How­ever, it will take a while for the re­nam­ing to take hold in the lit­er­a­ture.

An aside. The pre­fix "Pseudo..." is of­ten used by taxono­mists to avoid com­plete name changes, and not to de­value the newly bap­tized as "Fake...". For the same rea­son, for ex­am­ple, the genus Al­teromonas was split into Al­teromonas and Pseudoaltero­monas. The his­tory of the genus name Pseudomonas is more com­pli­cated, though, if not ob­scure (if you like de­tec­tive work, dive into the linked pa­per (Open Ac­cess)).

Preda­tory bac­te­ria have been found among many of the known bac­te­r­ial phyla − check the some­what in­tim­i­dat­ing Fig­ure 1 in the re­view by Ka­ma­da et al. (2023) (Open Ac­cess) − but it is not clear in many cases to what ex­tent their "lifestyle" re­sem­bles the vam­pire habits of "Bdellovib­rio and like or­gan­isms" (BA­LOs). For the lat­ter, Waite et al. (2020) sought to bring some or­der into the clut­tered drawer "Delta­pro­teobacteria" and pro­posed the cre­ation of the new phy­lum Bdellovib­ri­onota, which com­prises the (mostly non‑pre­da­tory) class Oli­go­flexia and the preda­tory classes Bac­te­ri­ovo­ra­cia and Bdellovib­ri­o­nia. As you crawl through these new, now tidy draw­ers − al­ready slightly weary, prob­a­bly − you'll even­tually find both species Pseudo­bdel­lovi­brio exo­vorus and Bdellovib­rio bacterio­vorus in the fam­ily Pseudob­dellovib­ri­onaceae, from the or­der Bdellovi­brio­nales in − back to square 1 − the class Bdellovib­ri­o­nia (the usual hi­er­ar­chi­cal stack­ing).

Fig­ure 2. Mi­croscopy ob­ser­va­tion of Vam­piro­coc­cus cells. (d–f) Closer mi­croscopy view of anoxy­genic photo­syn­thetic bac­te­ria in­fected by epibi­otic Vam­piro­coc­cus cells and few-cell fil­a­ments (in­di­cated by yel­low ar­rows). (g) Scan­ning elec­tron mi­croscopy im­age (SEM) of a host cell in­fected by two stack­ing Vam­piro­coc­cus cells (yel­low ar­row). (h) Trans­mis­sion elec­tron mi­croscopy (TEM) im­age of a thin sec­tion of a host cell in­fected by Vampi­rococcus (yel­low ar­row). Scale bars: 0.5 µm. Source

What use is such knowl­edge about tax­o­nomic draw­ers to you any­way? Lit­tle, ex­cept that it gives you a vague qual­i­ta­tive hint on ge­nomic sim­i­lar­ity of the species you study. And it is im­portant in which di­rec­tion you make your com­par­isons and build your hy­pothe­ses. Re­ferring to Le bal des vam­pires, San­tin et al. (2023) could not in­fer the pre­da­tion mech­a­nism of P. exo­vorus from its tax­o­nomic and phy­lo­ge­netic re­la­tion­ship to B. bacterio­vorus, but could, af­ter its elu­ci­da­tion, safely con­clude that mech­a­nis­ti­cal­ly dif­fer­ent pre­da­tion mech­anisms oc­cur in clo­sely re­lated, that is, ge­net­i­cally very sim­i­lar species. I'll spare you and my­self from spec­i­fy­ing ex­actly in which draw­ers you'll find Bac­te­ri­ovo­rax, Peredi­bacter and all the other >50 BA­LOs.

The preda­tory Deltapro­teobac­terium Myx­o­coc­cus xan­thus⛓️‍💥 and its ilk, which stalk Gram-ne­­ga­­tive bac­te­ria by a "wolf-pack hunt­ing" strat­egy rather than vam­pirism are now grouped with other or­ders into a new phy­lum, Myx­o­coc­cota (check out this YouTube clip recorded over se­ven days). There are "hunters" known from other phyla too, but since their preda­tory lifestyle does not in­volve tem­po­rary, in­ti­mate at­tach­ment to their vic­tims as it is the hall­mark of vam­pires, I will omit them here. How­ever, I can't re­sist sug­gest­ing a short video clip for you to watch, by the Dutch pho­tog­ra­pher Wim van Egmond, "(uniden­ti­fied) bac­te­ria en­gulf­ing Spir­ogyra alga", a case of "cross-king­dom hunt­ing".

Since their dis­cov­ery, it has been sus­pected that the ma­jor­ity of CPR bac­te­ria (now Pa­tes­ci­bac­teria) can­not live au­totroph­i­cally be­cause their re­duced genomes, mostly <1 Mb in length, gen­er­ally do not en­code com­plete sets of biosyn­thetic genes. It is cer­tainly pre­ma­ture to sim­ply call the en­tire (super)phylum Patescibac­te­ria an enor­mous bat cave, but a few vam­pires are now known, for ex­am­ple from the Sac­cha­rib­ac­te­ria. Both "Can­di­da­tus Myco­syn­bacter am­a­lyti­cus JR1"⛓️‍💥 and Nanosyn­bac­ter lyti­cus⛓️‍💥 only grow in co‑cultures with their acti­nobac­te­r­ial hosts, which they pre­sumably "poke" with a type IV se­cre­tion (T4SS) ap­pa­ra­tus to suck up leak­ing cell ma­te­r­ial (sim­i­lar to Vam­pirovib­rio, see last para­graph). An­other vam­pire of the Patescibac­te­ria, Vam­piro­coc­cus lu­gosii (class Ab­scon­ditabac­te­ria) has made it into Wikipedia, and you find more de­tails of its lifestyle there. It sur­vives free-float­ing but only grows and repli­cates when firmly at­tached to its host Chro­matium spp. (H2S‑oxidising, photo­autotrophic gammapro­teobacterium) that it sucks empty to pro­duce up to six daugh­ter cells (Fig­ure 2).

Le bal des vam­pires doesn't end here, quite the con­trary! It is not lim­ited to bac­te­ria vam­pir­i­zing among them­selves, as told above, or ar­chaea among them­selves. Think of A Happy Hot Cou­ple⛓️‍💥, Nanoarchae­on equi­tans (DPANN, Nanoar­chaeota) tak­ing a nu­tri­tious ride on Ig­nicoccus hos­pitalis (Ther­mo­pro­teota). This is no ex­cep­tion, as I just learned from a preprint in late Oc­to­ber de­scrib­ing the cul­ti­vated DPANN ar­chaeon Nano­bdella aer­o­bio­phila MJ1T that grows as epibiont on Met­al­losphaera sedula MJ1HA (Ther­mo­pro­teota). To what de­gree this sym­bio­sis leans more on the par­a­sitic or vam­piric side is not clear at this time.

Fig­ure 3. Pro­posed con­juga­tive mech­a­nism. T4SS oper­ons are found on two con­juga­tive plas­mids in V. chlo­rel­­lavorus. The T‑strands of the plas­mids are pre­dicted to be made sin­gle-stranded by plas­mid-en­coded relaxa­ses, nick­ing the DNA at the ori­gin of trans­fer and trans­port­ing the T‑strands to the C. vul­garis cell via the mat­ing pair for­ma­tion. We pre­dict that ef­fec­tor pro­teins (hy­drolytic en­zymes) syn­the­sized in the bacter­ium are also trans­ported via the mat­ing pair for­ma­tion. The T‑strand en­ters the al­gal nu­cleus through a nu­clear po­re com­plex and is in­cor­po­rated into a C. vul­garis chro­mosome. The ef­fec­tor pro­teins de­grade the al­gae con­tents which are trans­ported out of the al­gal cell via T‑strand en­coded trans­porters. The al­gal lysates are im­ported into the V. chlorella­vorus cell pro­vid­ing ener­gy and nu­tri­ents for repli­ca­tion. Source

Mean­while, a few cases of "cross-king­dom dances" have also been found. Kiz­ina et al. (2022) re­port their ob­ser­va­tion of the tiny bac­terium "Can­di­da­tus Ve­la­menic­oc­cus ar­chaeovorus" (Can­di­da­tus Om­ni­troph­ica, pre­vi­ously Can­di­date di­vi­sion OP3/WOR‑2) that thrives as epi­biont on the ar­chaeon Metha­nosaeta sp. (Eu­r­yarchaeota).

A stun­ner among of "cross-king­dom dances", how­ever, is the story of Vam­pirovib­rio chlo­rel­lavorus, a non‑photosynthetic dis­tant rel­a­tive of cyanobac­te­ria that preys on the eu­kary­otic microal­gae Chlorella vul­garis. Stun­ning be­cause it merges a vam­pire story with a zom­bie story. Soo et al. (2015) failed to res­ur­rect Vam­pirovib­rio from 36 year-old lyophilized ma­te­r­ial, but could nev­er­the­less se­quence its genome and con­firm its iden­tity as a mem­ber of the Melai­nabacteria, a non‑photosyn­the­tic sis­ter clade of the Cyanobac­te­ria in the phy­lum Ter­ra­bac­teria. The genome analy­sis sug­gested that V. chlorella­vorus is likely an ob­lig­ate pre­da­tor of the pho­to­syn­thetic mi­croalga Chlorella, and pre­dicts that it uses a con­juga­tive type IV se­cre­tion sys­tem (T4SS) to in­ject DNA in its host (Fig­ure 3). A foot­note: soon af­ter, it was found that a V. chlo­rellavorus strain can ef­fi­ciently "clear" com­mercial 1.000 L Chlorella cul­tures within days. Thus, the lyophilized zom­bie was not "the last of us" and, ap­parently, not all vam­pires shy away from sun­light.

"Vam­pirism" is not a prop­erly de­fined sci­en­tific term − and cer­tainly not a tax­o­nom­i­cally re­le­vant one − but it is fondly used by mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists versed in film his­tory who fol­low the fate of prey bac­te­ria upon in­fes­ta­tion with preda­tory bac­teria in the mi­cro­scope or on cul­ture me­dia (plaque for­ma­tion!). It is cer­tainly use­ful to dis­tin­guish bac­te­r­ial "vam­pires" (and their rel­a­tives among the ar­chaea) from other preda­tory bac­te­ria in that the vam­pires at­tach them­selves firmly to their prey be­fore and while "sip­ping" on them, or even suck them com­pletely (like B. ex­ovorus leav­ing just a "ghost" host cell, or like V. lu­gosii). In con­trast, preda­tory bac­te­ria of the Myxococ­cus‑type tend to kill their prey from a dis­tance be­fore in­gest­ing the de­bris.

An­other char­ac­ter­is­tic of vam­pires is that they grow and re­pro­duce only as long as they are firmly at­tached to their prey (or hang­ing in­side, like B. bac­te­ri­ovorus). This is a rather weak cri­te­rion, how­ever, be­cause all epibionts/ectosymbionts do this, and many of them are com­men­sals or sym­bionts with­out which their host can­not thrive, think Thiosym­bion oneisti that cov­ers its host, a ma­rine ne­ma­tode, with a furry coat⛓️‍💥. It is an easy ob­ser­va­tion to make but cer­tainly not more than a cu­rios­ity: sym­bi­otic epibionts like T. oneisti grow and di­vide lon­gi­tu­di­nally so that daugh­ter cells do not lose in­ti­mate con­tact with the host. Vam­pires like B. ex­ovorus or V. lu­gosii form daugh­ter cells at the pole op­po­site to the attach­ment site, which then have no con­nec­tion to the host; in the case of V. lu­gosii, this looks like a tiny stack per­pen­dic­u­lar to the host at­tach­ment site (Fig­ure 2). Since no sig­nif­i­cant dif­fer­ences are ap­par­ent be­tween the at­tach­ment mech­a­nisms of sym­bi­otic epibionts and vamp­ires, there will be a gray area in the dis­tinc­tion un­til ex­per­i­ments al­low for a de­ci­sion. Not a pleas­ant prospect for or­der-con­scious mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists, but here we are.

 

Do you want to com­ment on this post? We would be happy about it! Please com­ment on Mastodon, Bluesky, or on 𝕏 (for­merly Twit­ter).

Other Posts

  • The Hunger Games

    by Elio — I am not usu­ally drawn to start out an ar­ticle by con­si­der­ing a bac­te­ri­um's name, but when con­front­ed with Ag­gre­ga­ti­bac­ter ac­ti­no­my­ce­tem­co­mit­ans, I had to take a pause. A well-tra­vel­ed Gram-neg­a­tive coc­co­ba­cil­lus, this car­rier of such a con­vo­lut­ed mo­ni­ker start­ed life simp­ly as an Ac­ti­no­ba­cil­lus...

  • Es­cape From the Wall

    by Roberto — Who would have thought it? That the bac­te­r­ial cell wall would turn out to be so read­ily dis­pens­able. Among the first lessons I taught on bac­te­r­ial cell struc­ture was the fact that the ever present cell wall, com­posed pre­dom­i­nantly of pep­ti­do­gly­can, forms a pro­tec­tive shield around the cy­to­plas­mic mem­brane. A shield that pre­vents the bac­te­r­ial cell...

  • Round­ing up the Honey Bees (1)

    by Christoph — Why would I de­vi­ate here from STC's habit to rather not fea­ture the newest re­sults of trendy re­search top­ics? The rea­son comes hid­den in a short no­tice in Sci­ence by War­ren Cornwall:"...The new re­search is cer­tain to make a con­tro­ver­sial her­bi­cide even more of a flash­point." He re­ferred, of course, to a re­cent pa­per pub­lished in PNAS...

  • Un Tour d'Horizon (3/3)

    by Christoph — If bi­ol­ogy would have to rely solely on ho­mol­ogy stud­ies to un­der­stand HGT (as de­scribed in the first two parts of this se­ries) even the most star­tling cases could be dis­missed as just-so sto­ries, as highly im­prob­a­ble 'ac­ci­dents' in the past, or even as flaws of sta­tis­ti­cal analy­ses (for ex­am­ple faulty pa­ra­me­ter set­tings). For­tu­nately, HGT can be...