Vi­su­al­iz­ing DNA Repli­ca­tion

by Roberto

Christoph's re­cent post on vi­su­al­iz­ing in­trons brought back won­der­ful mem­o­ries. In mid-1976, I spent the first sev­eral months of my PhD vi­su­al­iz­ing repli­cat­ing plas­mid DNA. I loved it! Here's why. Mol­e­c­u­lar bi­ol­ogy de­vel­oped largely dur­ing the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s. By then ge­net­ics and bio­chem­istry yielded a good pic­ture of how tran­scrip­tion and trans­la­tion oc­curred and how they were reg­u­lated.

Fig. 1. My min­i­mal­ist view of the repli­con hy­poth­e­sis. This draw­ing served as JB cover Au­gust 2014, ac­com­pany­ing the re­view: Fifty years af­ter the repli­con hy­poth­e­sis. (Source: Roberto Kolter)

DNA repli­ca­tion was a bit dif­fer­ent. Though it was ap­par­ent from the dou­ble he­lix model how repli­ca­tion could pro­ceed, and later proven by Mesel­son and Stahl (the most beau­ti­ful experi­ment), a clear un­der­stand­ing of the ge­net­ics, bio­chem­istry and reg­u­la­tion of DNA repli­ca­tion lagged. Nonethe­less, by the 1960s sev­eral lines of mi­cro­scopic ev­i­dence in­di­cated that in bac­teria DNA mol­e­cules were of­ten cir­cles (see for ex­am­ple, STC Pic­tures Con­sid­ered #2) and that repli­ca­tion ap­peared to start from unique sites (ori­gins of repli­cation). In 1963, Ja­cob, Bren­ner and Cuzin pro­posed their "repli­con" hy­poth­e­sis: an "ini­tiator" (pro­tein or nu­cleic acid) would act at an ori­gin to reg­u­late ini­ti­a­tion events. Many in­ves­ti­ga­tors were in­spired by this pro­posal and be­came in­ter­ested in study­ing the re­gulation of rep­lication. Plas­mids, be­cause of their dis­pens­abil­ity and small size seemed ideal model repli­cons to de­ter­mine if the repli­con hypo­thesis was cor­rect. Di­rect ev­i­dence sup­porting it would come, but not for some fif­teen years.

At the out­set, one of the key tools avail­able to study repli­ca­tion was DNA vi­su­al­iza­tion us­ing elec­tron mi­croscopy. This tech­nique was pub­lished in a 1959 pa­per by Al­brecht Klein­schmidt et al., and af­ter­wards was widely known as "Klein­schmidt spread­ing." Through­out the 1960s and early 1970s in­ves­ti­ga­tors used it to "see" DNA repli­ca­tion. A hugely im­por­tant ad­di­tion to this analy­sis was to use it in com­bi­na­tion with re­stric­tion en­zymes, al­low­ing the map­ping of ori­gins rel­a­tive to where re­stric­tion en­zymes cut the DNA (e.g. Fig. 2). Ori­gins could be lo­cal­ized! What great ex­cite­ment that was! I hope you will un­der­stand why, in 1976, I was so en­thralled spend­ing end­less hours an­a­lyz­ing plas­mid replica­tive in­ter­me­di­ates us­ing elec­tron mi­croscopy.

Fig. 2. Elec­tron mi­cro­graphs of plas­mid ColE1 DNA mole­cules with a small loop af­ter treat­ment with re­stric­tion en­donu­cle­ase EcoRl. Source

OK, we could vi­su­al­ize ori­gins... But what were these ori­gins? Were there re­ally ini­tia­tors act­ing on them? Clearly Klein­schmidt spread­ing alone would not suf­fice to fig­ure this out. Many of us turned to us­ing re­stric­tion en­zymes dif­fer­ently. We used them to de­fine ori­gins func­tion­ally, i.e., we cloned them. That meant aban­don­ing my beloved elec­tron mi­croscopy, re­plac­ing it with cloning and, quickly af­ter­wards, DNA se­quenc­ing. In a mat­ter of months, many of us went from sim­ply see­ing ori­gins by Klein­schmidt spread­ing to defin­ing their size, their se­quence, their func­tion­al­ity and iden­ti­fy­ing ini­tia­tors that acted on them (for my per­sonal ex­am­ple, see here). There it was, di­rect ev­i­dence sup­port­ing the repli­con hypo­thesis! The field had taken a quan­tum leap.

There's a take-home mes­sage to this story that still ap­plies to­day. Pow­er­ful method­olo­gies come and go. My rec­om­men­da­tion is that experi­mentalists should al­ways be ready to aban­don their most beloved tech­niques as soon as they per­ceive that they have reached their lim­its. There might be bet­ter ap­proaches to ad­dress the ques­tions un­der in­ves­ti­ga­tion. If you are an ex­per­i­men­tal­ist, you should con­stantly be on the look­out for (or de­vel­op­ing your­self) new tools that might lead you to deeper in­sights. And don't wait for these tools to be handed to you in the form of a ready-made kit!

 

Do you want to com­ment on this post? We would be happy about it! Please com­ment on Mastodon or on Bluesky.

Other Posts

  • Happy Birth­day Elio!

    by Roberto and the STC team — Not long ago, Elio of­fered some mus­ings "On Old Age." As is of­ten the case when read­ing Elio's writ­ings, the first cou­ple of sen­tences al­ready taught me sev­eral lessons. For one, I learned a new word, senec­ti­tude. I sus­pect I will be us­ing it more and more with each pass­ing day. But there was more, Elio re­vealed that his birth­day...

  • Con­ju­ga­tion, and some pair­ing is­sues

    Pic­tures Con­sid­ered #55 by Christoph — If you've ever taken a class on bac­te­ri­al ge­ne­tics, ei­ther re­cent­ly or in the last few de­ca­des, you've no doubt seen this im­age: the con­ju­ga­tion of two bac­te­ri­al cells (Fig­ure 1). And if you found this im­age so self-ex­­pla­­na­­to­ry that you didn't both­er to ask for the source, you're not alone. The in­ter­net is re­plete with it, in vary­ing...

  • Book Re­view: Son of Dou­ble He­lix

    by Elio — This reis­su­ing of The Dou­ble He­lix, now adorned with umpteen pho­tographs, reprints of first pages of ar­ti­cles, per­sonal let­ters (some in scrawled, il­leg­i­ble hand­writ­ing), sketches, etc., is not your usual reprint, but I has­ten to say that it does make sense. The added ma­te­r­ial fleshes out the events of that time, with col­lected…

  • A New Dawn

    by Roberto — Re­freshed af­ter the sum­mer break, STC blog­ging re­turns for the sec­ond half of 2025. by Roberto — De­spite global de­vel­op­ments that raise se­ri­ous con­cerns re­gard­ing the fu­ture of sci­ence, I re­main op­ti­mistic about the long-term fu­ture and there­fore thrilled by STC's plans go­ing for­ward.

  • Genomes by AI

    by Roberto — Two years ago I played, si­mul­ta­ne­ously amused and be­mused, with Chat­GPT. It was clear ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence (AI) had taken a quan­tum leap. While I did not get to play with it, read­ing about Evo last week evoked sim­i­lar feel­ings; it left me both in awe and slightly un­nerved. In case you missed it, Evo does with genome se­quences what Chat­GPT does with words, i.e., al­most every­thing.