Green Sloths and Ro­bots

by Roberto

Last Monday's post de­scribed the "pe­cu­liar plumage pig­ment" of col­or­ful birds like the scar­let macaw. Janie made the case that for an­i­mals, eye-catch­ing col­ors gen­er­ally serve to at­tract mates or de­tract po­ten­tial preda­tors. But, in the case of red par­rot feath­ers the pig­ment has the added ben­e­fit of pro­tect­ing the plumage from bac­te­r­ial degra­da­tion. To­day I stay on the topic of an­i­mal col­oration by de­scrib­ing the "pe­cu­liar pelage pig­ment" of sloths. Ex­actly what con­sti­tutes an eye-catch­ing color is, of course, in the eye of the be­holder (par­don the pun). Take am­phib­ians; green frogs are very much run-of-the-mill, re­mem­ber Kermit's lament. But a mam­mal sport­ing green fur? That's some­thing that catches my eye due to it un­usu­al­ness. So, here's the story of the charis­matic green sloths.

Fig­ure 1. Brady­pus var­ie­ga­tus (brown-throated three-toed sloth) with green fur col­oration. Source

Sloths or pere­zosos (as they are known in Span­ish, mean­ing "lazy ones") are strik­ing mam­mals in many ways. As their name im­plies, they are ex­tremely slow-mov­ing. They spend much of their lives sim­ply hang­ing out in the heights of trees of the trop­i­cal rain forests of Cen­tral and South Ame­rica. There are two gen­era of sloths which di­verged some 40 mil­lion years ago: the two-toed sloths (Choloe­pus) and the three-toed sloths (Brady­pus). Be­cause their diet con­sists mostly of nu­tri­ent-poor leaves, they ex­hibit some of the low­est meta­bolic rates among mam­­mals. And then there is their green col­oration, which is where mi­crobes come in. The pig­ment re­spon­si­ble for the green color is chloro­phyll; in the wild, sloth hair is col­o­nized with mi­croal­gae.

Fig­ure 2. Quan­ti­ta­tion of moths, or­ganic ni­trogen, and al­gal bio­mass in two-toed and three-toed sloths. The more se­den­tary three-toed sloths (black bars) pos­sessed © a greater num­ber of moths, (d) more in­or­ganic ni­tro­gen in the form of NH4+ and (e) greater al­gal bio­mass on their fur com­pared with two-toed sloths (grey bars). Er­ror bars rep­re­sent ±1 s.e.; *p < 0.05, **p < 0.001. Source

Even though they are ar­bo­real mam­mals, the two types of sloths are eco­log­i­cally and physio­logically quite dis­tinct. Two-toed sloths have rel­a­tively large home ranges and sup­ple­ment their leaf diet with fruits and small an­i­mals (mainly in­sects). In con­trast, three-toed sloths have much smaller home ranges and are strict fo­li­vores. They are spe­cial­ists that of­ten live in and con­sume leaves from only a few spe­cies of trees. This nu­tri­tion­ally poor diet leads three-toed sloths to pos­sess the slow­est di­ges­tion and low­est meta­bolic rates among mam­mals.

The mi­croal­gae that colo­nize sloth fur also dif­fer dra­mat­i­cally in the two types of sloths. A study us­ing a se­quenced-based ap­proach found that, while two-toed sloth hair can be colo­nized with quite di­verse species of mi­croal­gae, the three-toed sloth, Brady­pus var­ie­ga­tus, is col­o­nized with only very closely-re­lated strains of the mi­croalga Tri­chophilus. In­ter­est­ingly, these strains of Tri­chophilus have not been found any­where else, sug­gest­ing that they are host-adapted. This led the au­thors to sug­gest that the B. var­ie­ga­tus and its as­so­ci­ated Tri­cho­philus have co-evolved!

This in­ti­mate and long-term as­so­ci­a­tion be­tween sloth and alga sug­gests an adap­tive func­tion. But what role could this be? For a long time, sloth watch­ers have posited that the green col­oration pro­vides cam­ou­flage that pro­tects the slow-mov­ing sloths from pre­da­tion. This makes sense but there is no ev­i­dence sup­port­ing it. Not too long ago, a study pro­vided some expe­rimental ev­i­dence con­sis­tent with an­other pos­si­ble role for the alga, nu­tri­tion. How could this be? It's com­plex. The idea that the al­gae can be a nu­tri­ent arises from look­ing at the sloth ecosys­tem as a mul­ti­par­tite mu­tu­al­is­tic sym­bio­sis. Be­sides the al­gae, sloth fur con­tains a ver­i­ta­ble zoo of or­gan­isms, in­clud­ing many dif­fer­ent bac­teria with the po­ten­tial to pro­duce nu­mer­ous bioac­tive na­tural prod­ucts. The sloth is thus some­times re­ferred to as a model mo­bile ecosys­tem. The key ad­di­tional play­ers in the nu­tri­tion role of alga hy­poth­e­sis are a moth (Cryp­toses cho­loepi) and di­verse de­tri­tiv­o­rous fungi.

The au­thors com­pared the fur ecosys­tem of two-toed and three-toed sloths in terms of moth bio­mass, or­ganic nitro­gen con­tent and al­gal bio­mass. For all three com­po­nents, the more spe­cial­ized three-toed B. var­ie­ga­tus car­ried great­er amounts (Fig. 2). They hy­poth­e­size that in the for­est ca­nopy sun­light is not the fac­tor lim­it­ing al­gal growth. Rather, they sug­gest that ni­tro­gen be­comes lim­it­ing. Hav­ing more moths means more dead moths that can be decom­posed by fungi and thus pro­vide more ni­tro­gen. The ni­tro­gen can then be used by the al­gae to at­tain higher yields. Of course, to be nu­tri­tious, the sloth must then eat the al­gae. In sup­port of this, the au­thors found al­gal re­mains in the stom­achs of some of their sam­pled sloths.

Fig­ure 3. Pos­tu­lated linked mu­tu­alisms (+) among sloths, moths and al­gae: (a) sloths de­scend their tree to defe­cate, and de­liver gravid fe­male sloth moths (+) to ovipo­si­tion sites in their dung; (b) lar­val moths are co­prophagous and as adults seek sloths in the canopy; © moths re­present por­tals for nu­tri­ents, and via de­composition and min­er­al­iza­tion by detri­tivores in­crease in­or­ganic ni­tro­gen lev­els in sloth fur, which fu­els al­gal (+) growth, and (d) sloths (+) then con­sume these al­gae-gar­dens, pre­sum­ably to aug­ment their lim­ited diet. Source

A most in­ter­est­ing as­pect of this hy­poth­e­sis lies in the life cy­cle of the moth. Turns out the moth lar­vae are co­prophagous, so gravid adult moths must de­posit their eggs in fresh sloth dung! To en­sure that the moths find the proper poop, the sloth en­gages in a most dan­ger­ous be­hav­ior putting it­self at great risk of pre­da­tion. Once a week, the lethar­gic three-toed sloth de­scends from the tree and defe­cates in the for­est floor. Gravid moths take ad­van­tage of this mo­ment and de­posit their eggs in the proper lo­ca­tion. The eggs hatch there, lar­vae ma­ture and even­tu­ally the young moths fly into the fur of their host. (It will be fas­ci­nat­ing to deter­mine if sloth poop con­tains mi­crobes that pro­duce spe­cial­ized metabo­lites that aid in egg hatch­ing and lar­val mat­u­ra­tion!)

The au­thors pull all these con­cepts into a model where the sev­eral mu­tu­alisms lead to a more nu­tri­tious diet for the sloth (Fig. 3). They ar­gue that the ben­e­fit of hav­ing more al­gae to eat must be suf­fi­cient to jus­tify the risky be­hav­ior of defe­cat­ing in the for­est floor. In con­trast, the two-toed sloths whose diet in­cludes fruits and in­sects, poop while hang­ing high in the canopy. Over­all, I like this model as an at­tempt to ex­plain the pos­si­ble co-evo­lu­tion of the three-toed sloth B. var­ie­ga­tus with its Tri­chophilus alga. But the model is not with­out its crit­ics. Some sug­gest that the mo­del does not hold wa­ter be­cause sloth pre­da­tion is equally likely in the canopy. Oth­ers ar­gue that, un­like cats and other mam­mals, sloths do not lick them­selves and thus it is not likely that they con­sume the al­gae on their fur. Regard­less of what we'll even­tu­ally come to un­der­stand as the main role of al­gae on sloth fur, I find the com­plex inter­twining of lifestyles in this ecosys­tem amaz­ing.

Fig­ure 4. Three-toed sloth rest­ing on a ca­ble in an agro­ecosystem in Costa Rica, which was the in­spi­ra­tion for ro­boti­cists to de­velop the Sloth­bot, shown tra­versing an in­stalled ca­ble in the At­lanta Botan­i­cal Gar­dens. Source

Ap­par­ently, I am not the only one in awe of the un­usual na­ture of the three-toed sloth. In do­ing my read­ing for this post I came across an ar­ti­cle en­ti­tled "Ro­bot Ecol­ogy: An In­spi­ra­tion for Fu­ture Ecol­o­gists." The au­thors de­scribe how the field of ro­bot­ics is dom­i­nated by de­sign that seeks to max­i­mize ac­cu­racy, re­pro­ducibil­ity, and speed. This makes sense for ro­bots used in such ac­tiv­i­ties as man­u­fac­tur­ing and med­i­cine. But in en­ergy con­strained en­vi­ron­ments, ro­bot de­sign that em­pha­sizes sur­vival and en­ergy ef­fi­ciency be­comes key. So, ro­bot de­sign has taken lessons from the three-toed sloth. The au­thors claim that the Sloth­Bot – not seren­dipitously painted green – "is the first man­i­fes­ta­tion of the sur­vival con­cept in ro­bot­ics and a new con­cep­tu­al­iza­tion of ro­bot ecol­ogy." That the mi­croal­gae on its fur might pro­vide the sloth with some en­ergy, much like the so­lar panel does for Sloth­Bot, I find fas­ci­nat­ing.

 

Other Posts