Nail­ing the twists of a twisted nails puz­zle, part 2|2

by Christoph

I had al­most solved the twisted nails puz­zle in the first part. I had un­twisted the func­tion of the first nail, spot 42 RNA, as well as the func­tion of the sec­ond nail, the open read­ing frame con­tained within this 'dual‑function RNA' that is trans­lated as the SpfP pro­tein. Here now are two more twists…

Fig­ure 1. Spot 42 and SpfP have dif­fer­ent ef­fects at dif­fer­ent tem­per­a­tures. A Im­munoblotting analy­sis of GalK-HA-His6 lev­els in a Δspf galK-HA-His6::kan strain (GSO1060) trans­formed with pRI (empty vec­tor con­trol), pRI-Spot 42 ('SpfR·SpfP'), or pRI-Spot 42STOP ('SpfR·SpfP'),  grown in LB at 30°C, 37°C, and 42°C. B Immuno­blotting analy­sis of GalK-HA-His6 lev­els in a Δspf galK-HA-His6::kan strain (GSO1060) trans­formed with pKK (empty vec­tor con­trol), pKK-SpfP-re­coded ('SpfR·SpfP'), or pKK-SpfP-re­codedSTOP('SpfR·SpfP'), grown in LB at 30°C, 37°C, and 42°C. For A and B, sam­ples were col­lected at an OD600 of ∼0.5. Anti-His an­ti­body was used to de­tect the HA-His6 tag. The Pon­ceau S‑stain­ed mem­brane doc­u­ments ap­prox­i­mately equal load­ing of the sam­ples. Source. Fron­tispiece: twisted nails puz­zle. Bor­row­ed from puzzlesolver.com

One more twist   Aoyama et al. (2022) had ob­served some­what higher lev­els of SpfP at 42°C and 45°C as com­pared to lower growth tem­per­a­tures, and won­dered if the im­por­tance of the sRNA ver­sus the mRNA ac­tiv­i­ties of spf var­ied de­pend­ing on the growth tem­per­a­ture. This was an ob­vi­ous thing to check, since it is known that RNA‑RNA in­ter­ac­tions via base pair­ing are highly tem­per­a­ture de­pendent (see our re­cent, that is, pre‑pandemic post Of Terms in Bi­ol­ogy: RNA Ther­mome­ter.)

They ex­am­ined by im­munoblot­ting how their overexpres­sed spf vari­ants af­fected the expres­sion lev­els of a tagged fu­sion pro­tein, GalKtag (chro­mo­so­ma­lly, un­der con­trol of the gal pro­moter), at 30°C, 37°C, and 42°C. They ob­served that 'SpfR·SfP' was less ef­fec­tive at re­duc­ing GalKtag lev­els at 42 °C, while 'SpfR·SpfP' over­ex­pres­sion led to strong repres­sion at all tempe­ra­tures. Over­ex­pres­sion of 'SpfR·SpfP' led to sim­i­lar but slightly less GalKtag re­pres­sion at all tempe­ratures, while 'SpfR·SpfP' had no ef­fect on GalK­tag lev­els (Fig­ure 1). The au­thors inter­pret these re­sults to mean that base pair­ing is more ef­fec­tive at re­pres­sion at lower tem­pera­tures and that trans­la­tion of spf can in­ter­fere with base-pair­ing ac­tiv­ity at higher tempera­tures. It strains the imag­i­na­tion how such an in­tri­cate multi-lay­ered reg­u­la­tion could evolve, but it did, ap­par­ently.

Fig­ure 2. The small pro­tein SpfP rein­for­ces the multi­output feed­for­ward loop be­tween CRP and Spot 42. For cells grown in the ab­sence of glu­cose, CRP di­rectly in­creases tran­scrip­tion of tar­gets and re­pres­ses Spot 42. When glu­cose is avail­able (shown here), the Spot 42 RNA re­presses CRP-ac­ti­vated tar­gets through base pair­ing, particu­larly at lower tempe­ratures (Left), and the small pro­tein SpfP blocks CRP-de­pen­dent ac­ti­va­tion, parti­cu­larly at higher tem­per­a­ture (Right). The im­paired stem­loop struc­ture of Spot 42 at higher tem­per­a­ture pro­mot­ing SpfP trans­la­tion is in­di­cated by lack­ing hydro­gen bonds. Mod­i­fied from Source

I will not miss to men­tion that shortly be­fore the pub­li­ca­tion of Aoyama et al. (2022), a pa­per was pub­lished by the lab of Kai Pa­pen­fort at Friedrich-Schiller-Uni­ver­sität in Jena, Ger­ma­ny that char­ac­ter­ized a dual-func­tion sRNA from Vib­rio chole­rae, Vc­dRP (see this post.) Like Spot 42, VcdR RNA plays a role in the con­trol of cAMP·CRP re­gulated genes while VcdP pro­tein re­gulates the ac­tiv­ity of GltA, the first en­zyme of the cit­ric acid cy­cle. Sure enough, Vib­rio chole­rae also has a Spot 42 or­tholog as have nu­mer­ous other Gammapro­teobac­te­ria. Alas, so many more twisted nails puz­zles!

A fi­nal twist   Aoyama et al. (2022) state at the end of their pa­per: "Given how ex­ten­sively CRP has been stud­ied, it is in­triguing that SpfP was not de­tected pre­vi­ously, al­though it is worth no­ting that a re­pres­sive, low‑molecular‑weight ca­ta­bolite mod­u­la­tor fac­tor was de­scribed de­cades ago (33)." In the cited pa­per, Ull­mann et al. (1976) de­scribe the par­tial pu­rifi­ca­tion of a 'catabo­lite mod­u­la­tor fac­tor' (CMF) that was achieved by (1.) re-sus­pend­ing E. coli cell pel­lets in wa­ter (pH 8.0), (2.) boil­ing the sus­pen­sion (25 mg dry weight /mL) for 12 min, (3.) high‑speed cen­trifu­ga­tion for the re­moval of cell de­bris, de­na­tured chromo­so­mal DNA and RNA, and (larger) pro­teins, and (4.) pass­ing the su­per­natant over a cation ex­change col­umn. Only small RNAs like tRNA, some RNases, and oligopeptides/small pro­teins are likely to re­sist such 'phys­i­cal abuse' (an ex­pres­sion from the 1st Ed. of "the Ma­ni­atis", p. 189.) Ad­di­tion of CMF to a cul­ture of glu­cose-grown and IPTG-in­duced E. coli did not af­fect the growth of the cells but re­sulted in a re­duc­tion of β‑galactosidase syn­the­sis by up to 90%. Old ob­ser­va­tions can have sur­pris­ing reper­cus­sions, and it would have been neat if Aoyama et al. (2022) had re­peated these ex­per­i­ments to see if their SpfP is in­deed CMF. Yet grants and their terms usu­ally don't al­low for such 'ar­chae­o­log­i­cal ex­cur­sions.'

Fig­ure 3. Nat­u­ral­i­sa­tion d'Agnès Ull­mann, Jan­vier 1967 (C. Burstein, G. Buttin, A. Ull­mann, D. Per­rin). Source In­sti­tut Pas­teur Archives

The first au­thor of the CMF pa­per was Ag­nès Ull­mann (1927 – 2019) who, fol­low­ing her secre­tive and ad­ven­tur­ous flight from Hun­gary af­ter the "in­ter­ven­tion" of the USSR in 1956, worked be­yond her re­tire­ment in Paris at the In­sti­tut Pas­teur, es­pe­cially on the role of cAMP and CRP in catabo­lite re­pres­sion. In most text­books, Jacques Monod and François Ja­cob are cel­e­brated for their lac operon model of gene re­gulation and the spe­cial role of the repres­sor, LacI. Right­ly so, but the whole thing only makes sense if one in­cludes ac­tivation of lac tran­scrip­tion by cAMP·CRP. Monod, Ja­cob and Ull­mann were well aware of that.

A teeny bit more ar­chae­ol­ogy? If you have done cloning ex­per­i­ments with E. coli in the lab your­self, you are cer­tainly fa­mil­iar with the blue-white se­lec­tion of trans­for­mants. Did you know that this goes back to a pa­per by Ag­nès Ull­mann et al. (1967), the 'et al.' be­ing François Ja­cob and Jacques Monod ? They found that dele­tion of the N‑terminus of LacZ (ω‑peptide) re­sults in in­ac­tive β‑galactosidase, but sup­ply­ing the LacZα N‑terminus (α‑peptide) in trans re­stores full β‑galactosidase ac­tiv­ity (as you might have guessed al­ready, Ag­nès Ull­mann was one of my sci­en­tific hero­ines.)

 

Other Posts

  • Vi­su­al­iz­ing Cou­pled Tran­scrip­tion and Trans­la­tion in E. coli

    Pic­tures Con­sid­ered #1 by Elio — In 1970, be­fore this im­age was pub­lished, there was in­di­rect ev­i­dence that trans­la­tion in bac­te­ria is cou­pled to tran­scrip­tion – a pro­nounced de­par­ture from the eu­kary­ote way in which one process takes place in the nu­cleus while, the other is rel­e­gated to the cy­to­plasm. This clas­sic elec­tron mi­cro­graph by…

  • Life on a Pig's Skin

    by Sean Kear­ney — How fre­quently do mi­crobes ex­change genes when liv­ing on a host? This ques­tion has been on my mind lately. Broadly speak­ing, the dis­cov­ery of hor­i­zon­tal gene trans­fer (HGT) rev­o­lu­tion­ized the way we think about prokary­otic evo­lu­tion. No more could we think only of in­her­i­tance via ver­ti­cal de­scent — HGT made pos­si­ble the trans­mis­sion of traits even be­tween dis­tantly re­lated species.

  • How To Turn An E. coli  Into An Ar­chaeon (Sort Of)

    by Elio — Things pop up in mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy that are truly as­tound­ing. The claim that one can par­tially turn a bac­terium into an ar­chaeon rates high on this list. Ar­chaea and Bac­te­ria be­long to dif­fer­ent main branches of the tree of life and have many dis­tinc­tive bio­chem­i­cal and struc­tural dif­fer­ences.

  • Tri­choplax & Com­pany I.

    by Christoph — Take a few thou­sand small eu­kary­otic cells, al­low for a few dif­fer­ent cell types, and sea­son the cells gen­er­ously with en­dosym­bionts (no, not mi­to­chon­dria, they al­ready have these!). Let the cells self-or­ga­nize into a patty – or a potato chip, if you're more into a ve­gan lifestyle – with a di­am­e­ter of ap­prox­i­mately 0.5–1.0 mm, and a mere 25 µm thick.

  • Sym­biont Ex­change in the Aphid·Buchnera Sym­bio­sis (2|2)

    by Christoph — What's pos­si­ble in the wild – sym­biont ex­change, see last week's part 1 – should also be pos­si­ble to achieve in the lab. Less for com­pet­ing with nature's in­ge­nu­ity but more with the aim to study the sep­a­rate con­tri­bu­tions of sym­bi­otic part­ners, of course. So, af­ter be­ing suc­cess­ful ear­lier in trans­fer­ring sec­ondary, fac­ul­ta­tive en­dosym­bionts be­tween aphid hosts, the Moran lab de­vel­oped...

  • Fine Read­ing: No Growth!

    by Roberto — One of my most mem­o­rable early lessons in mi­cro­bial phys­i­ol­ogy (and one that I still love to chal­lenge gen­eral au­di­ences with) was be­ing asked how long would it take E. coli cells to reach the mass of the Earth (un­der con­di­tions of un­re­stricted growth). It was and re­mains a won­der­ful ex­er­cise that al­lows...