Book Re­view: The Gen­e­sis Quest

by Janie

The Gen­e­sis Quest: The Ge­niuses and Ec­centrics on a Jour­ney to Un­cover the Ori­gins of Life on Earth by Michael Mar­shall. Uni­ver­sity of Chicago Press, 2020 (ISBN: 9780226715230)

The Gen­e­sis Quest is a tour-de-force re­count of the eclec­tic ef­fort to under­stand the ori­gins of life on Earth, au­thored by sci­ence writer Michael Mar­shall. Here is a tale that spans from pre­biotic chem­istry to proto­cells, inter­laced with sto­ries of the idiosyn­crasies of the sci­en­tists in­volved. It's a union of the sci­ences – syn­thetic chem­istry, astro­biology, biochem­istry, micro­biology, ecol­ogy. Much like the primord­ial poly­mer blob "coac­er­vates" that co­a­lesce into one, dis­cussed early in the book, fa­mous names in sci­ence quickly be­come as­so­ci­ated with person­ality and foibles, putting more than just a face to the names.

Fig. 1. Amer­i­can book cover. Source. Fron­tispiece

The book is di­vided into four sec­tions. The first be­gins with the early experi­ments: the fa­mous "Primor­dial Soup Hy­poth­e­sis" from Oparin and Hal­dane, the spark­ing of pre­biotic mol­e­cules into test-tube ex­is­tence à la Miller and Urey, and the chem­i­cal synth­esis of ATP un­der pos­si­ble early Earth con­ditions. This his­tor­i­cal pe­riod sees the on­set of the Achilles-heel ques­tion for many a chem­i­cal syn­the­sis be­tween then and now: But is it prebiot­ically plau­si­ble? In this sec­tion are also spot­lights of fig­ures in micro­biology, both well-known names like Pas­teur and Vir­chow as well as the side­lined Robert Re­mak, whose ideas were snatched and popular­ized by Vir­chow in his pithy 'Om­nis cel­lula e cel­lula'…

The next sec­tion over­turns the 1950s' sim­plis­tic fo­cus on iso­lated mole­cules. With the struc­tural and func­tional explor­ations of DNA, from crystallo­graphy to the triplet code, life turned out to be much more com­plex. Here, Mar­shall ac­quaints read­ers with the icono­clastic char­ac­ter Cairns-Smith, who, to the scoffs of his con­tempor­aries, pro­posed that crys­tals di­vide, pass on in­her­ited traits, and evolve. Bio­mole­cules came to­gether in the scaffold­ing pro­vided by clay crys­tals, Cairns-Smith urged, and when these "mother" crys­tals crack, they pass on their phys­i­cal prop­erties to the re­sult­ing "daugh­ter" crys­tals. De­spite the clay hypoth­esis's faults (pun in­tended), here was the first in­stance of the no­tion that "life is about infor­mation that is in­her­ited im­perfectly." A bit of bi­o­log­i­cal po­etry.

The char­ac­ters in this ori­gins-of-life yarn are of course bull-headed sci­en­tists. The third sec­tion moves into a consid­eration of the 1980s' four ma­jor points of con­tention. First, which es­sen­tial func­tion of life came first: repli­cation, compart­mental­ization, or meta­bolism? Sec­ond, which mole­cular build­ing block of life came first: RNA or pro­teins? Third, where on Earth did life arise? And fi­nally, in what orga­nisms were the an­swers to these ques­tions kept un­der ge­nomic lock and key? Pages in this sec­tion dive into a sea­faring story­telling of hydro­thermal vents as the pos­si­ble cra­dle of life (the con­sen­sus now agree­ing that the gen­tler, al­ka­line "white chim­neys" are a more likely can­di­date than the scorch­ingly hot "black smok­ers"; see a re­lated STC post on serpentin­ization here). Here is also a contrast­ing consider­ation of land­mass-based ori­gins of life. Per­haps the well­springs of life were in­stead hot springs and geo­thermal ponds.

Fig. 2. Schematic of a pro­to­cell. Source

The fourth and fi­nal sec­tion is the story of such ideo­logical rifts on the mend. By the early twenty-first cen­tury, the prevail­ing hy­pothe­ses were the "repli­­ca­tion-first camp" with its RNA World, the "com­part­­men­tal­iza­tion-first camp" with its lipid-based pro­to­cells, and the "metabol­ism-first camp" with the pro­ton gra­di­ents of al­ka­line vents. The every­thing-first reconcil­iation came in the form of Szostak's proto­cells. These are RNA-con­tain­ing bi­layer mem­brane vesi­cles that can grow, di­vide, and un­dergo Dar­win­ian se­lec­tion, thereby merg­ing the RNA World with compart­mental­ization. The wall be­tween genes-first ad­her­ents and me­tab­o­lism-first devo­tees crum­bles apart as well: "infor­mation and en­tropy are two sides of the same coin," exem­plified by Maxwell's de­mon.

But Mar­shall writes, the first cell was not alone and was rather part of a commun­ity. The rise of cells can there­fore be bet­ter under­stood through the lens of ecol­ogy and commun­ity dy­nam­ics. The fi­nal pages of the book see a union of seem­ingly far-flung fields like chem­istry and popul­ation ecol­ogy, much like the union of differ­ent ori­gins-of-life hy­pothe­ses. No cell – nor proto­cell – is an is­land.

Over­all, The Gen­e­sis Quest paints the story of Ori­gins re­search as a funky one. Both the traject­ory of sci­ence and of the peo­ple were of­ten full of bizarre contra­dictions and non se­quiturs. "Ge­niuses and Ec­centrics," from the book's sub­ti­tle, is cer­tainly an apt and pithy sum­mary. Al­though I be­gan fa­mil­iar with a num­ber of the land­mark Ori­gins experi­ments, I had known very lit­tle about the peo­ple be­hind them and I de­lighted in these back­stories: from the in­flu­ence of po­lit­i­cal slants on sci­en­tific thought, as in the Oparin and Hal­dane duo and commun­ism and di­alec­ti­cal ma­te­ri­al­ism, to the sci­en­tific heretics who sparked out­rage from the main­stream ori­gins-of-life bigshots (and were of­ten off from re­al­ity by a long shot), but pro­pelled import­ant con­cepts into de­bate. In ad­di­tion to Cairns-Smith, there was Wächter­shäuser and his Iron-Sul­fur World Hy­poth­e­sis, with the key idea that life needed an en­ergy source from the get-go.

These back­sto­ries were of­ten a blend of serendip­ity and sci­ence commun­ication, as in the case of Stan­ley Miller, whose ca­reer be­gan when he stum­bled into a life-chang­ing lec­ture by Harold Urey, and John Suther­land, who years later stum­bled in on Al­bert Eschenmoser's lec­ture. On the note of seren­dipity, also pep­pered through­out is the re­cur­ring mo­tif of mont­moril­lonite clay, a seem­ing cure-all for all ori­gins-of-life experi­mental ills, from speed­ing up RNA syn­thesis to coax­ing the cor­rect nu­cleotide chi­ral­ity to catalyz­ing bi­layer lipid vesi­cle form­ation. Mar­shall high­lights the non-dis­count­able role of chance in dis­cov­ery.

Fi­nally, I es­pe­cially appre­ciated the acknow­ledgments of the less-pretty as­pects of sci­ence. Mar­shall nods at under­currents of ego­tism, pol­i­tics, and im­plicit and ex­plicit bi­ases, and he also makes a point of spot­lighting peo­ple who contrib­uted to land­mark sci­en­tific discov­eries but whose names were smoth­ered out of his­tory by those same ills. Tina Ne­gus, for ex­am­ple, discov­ered the first Pre­cam­brian fos­sil but was brushed aside be­cause she was a girl (the same fos­sil hailed as a bril­liant find when rediscov­ered by school­boy Roger Ma­son a year later). In this story­telling is a wonder­ful para­dox: In dig­ging into the re­motely dis­tant past of life, Mar­shall also writes his way for­ward, hop­ing for an opti­mistic fu­ture so­ci­ety. (Regard­ing his shout-out of An­gela Saini's book In­fe­rior in the intro­duction – here is my enthus­iastic agree­ment that it is a well-re­searched read on gen­der bi­ases!). By trac­ing the messy switch­back path that the sci­ence has taken, the book gen­tly paints sci­ence as flawed and sub­ject to re­vi­sions. I found The Gen­e­sis Quest to be a depic­tion of peo­ple who are tal­ented and dri­ven but also en­tirely hu­man, and I found that up­lift­ing.

A bit po­et­i­cally, the book's first and last chap­ters open and close with im­agery of the "warm lit­tle pond" that Dar­win pro­posed. This story of life comes full-cir­cle!

 

Other Posts