Mesel­son & Stahl, the Con­ver­sa­tion

by Roberto

Fig­ure 1. Matthew Mesel­son and Frank Stahl, Feb­ru­ary 2020. Source

A few days ago, Christoph sent the rest of us at STC a most up­lift­ing mes­sage. A con­ver­sa­tionbe­tween Matt Mesel­son and Frank Stahl, de­scrib­ing their "most beau­ti­ful ex­per­i­ment," had just pre­miered in iBiology.org. Much has been writ­ten about the land­mark ex­per­i­ment that pro­vided di­rect ev­i­dence for the semi­con­ser­v­a­tivena­ture of DNA repli­ca­tion, in­clud­ing a Pic­tures Con­sid­ered post here at STC. This new video epit­o­mizes some­thing that I find re­mark­able about the prac­tice of sci­ence. When car­ried out by won­der­ful in­di­vid­u­als, the re­sults are not only ad­vances in knowl­edge. Of equal sig­nif­i­cance are the true and last­ing friend­ships that emerge.

I could go on writ­ing about the Mesel­son-Stahl ex­per­i­ment for quite a while, but your time will be bet­ter spent watch­ing the video. I'll limit my­self to re­lat­ing a sel­dom-heard vi­gnette about how the land­mark 1958 pa­per came to be writ­ten. Af­ter ob­tain­ing the re­sults, Matt and Frank wanted to con­tinue do­ing more ex­per­i­ments. To get them to sit down and write the man­u­script, Max Del­brück drove them from Pasadena to Caltech's Corona del Mar ma­rine sta­tion and "forced" them to write while se­cluded away from the lab at a site over­look­ing the beach. I first heard this story as a grad­u­ate stu­dent in the mid-1970s and it re­ally stuck with me. It in­spired me to have my lab go off for a week-long re­treat in Maine every Oc­to­ber. Later in life, I had the good for­tune of in­ter­act­ing per­son­ally with both Matt and Frank. In per­son they proved to be equally in­spir­ing. Their con­ver­sa­tion makes this read­ily ap­par­ent.

 

Other Posts

  • It's a Book!

    by Merry Youle — Well over two years ago, through this blog I had the op­por­tu­nity to edit a re­search pa­per for For­est Ro­hwer. One thing led to an­other, and we then spent the bet­ter part of two years writ­ing a book to­gether — the first book for ei­ther of us. 'Coral Reefs in the Mi­cro­bial Seas' is now pub­lished! It is a...

  • Lost & Found #6

    by Christoph — In this episode, again three book­marks that came to my at­ten­tion while clean­ing up our ac­count on 𝕏 (for­merly Twit­ter) and that are not at all out of date. Give them a brief look and judge for your­self. Here is Lost & Found #6.

  • Med­i­cine Man

    by Manuel Sánchez An­gulo — The mid-80's of the last cen­tury saw the birth of an en­vi­ron­men­tal move­ment di­rected at the con­ser­va­tion of the Ama­zon jun­gle. It reached its cli­max in 1989 when the singer Sting pub­lished a book on the de­struc­tion of the habi­tat and cul­ture of the in­dige­nous com­mu­ni­ties. Al­ready in 1985, British cin­ema de­voted a movie...

  • Fine Read­ing: The Life and Times of Paul Buch­ner

    by Roberto — In prepar­ing our re­cent post on ec­tosym­bionts, I dis­cov­ered Jan Sapp's 2002 per­spec­tive: "Paul Buch­ner (1886 –1978) and hered­i­tary sym­bio­sis in in­sects." I sus­pect that many STC read­ers will im­me­di­ately rec­og­nize the name of Paul Buch­ner, af­ter whom Paul Bau­mann named the now well-known aphid en­dosym­biont Buch­n­era. But I also sus­pect most will not know too much about Buchner's sem­i­nal con­tri­bu­tions...

  • Of Terms in Bi­ol­ogy: Pu­ri­fy­ing Se­lec­tion

    by Elio — To me at least, this is a rel­a­tively un­ac­cus­tomed term for an old phe­nome­non, namely the re­moval of dele­te­ri­ous mu­tants from a pop­u­la­tion. (As Christoph points out, this does not re­fer to clean­ing up your lab bench.) Also known as neg­a­tive se­lec­tion, puri­fy­ing se­lec­tion re­sults in the stabili­zation of the pop­u­la­tion by rid­ding...