Lim­it­ing Man­ganese to Re­duce E. fae­calis Vir­u­lence

by Made­line Beaulieu

With the re­ported rise in an­tibi­otic-re­sis­tant pathogens, it re­mains im­por­tant to study the ba­sic bi­ol­ogy of these or­gan­isms to un­cover what makes them so durable. Why do they sur­vive so well in cer­tain en­vi­ron­ments, and how might we ef­fec­tively in­ter­fere with that?

Fig­ure 1. False-col­ored mi­cro­graph of E. fae­calis. Source

The Gram-pos­i­tive bac­terium En­te­ro­coc­cus fae­calis  nor­mally lives in the hu­man in­tes­tine. How­ever, it can also cause op­por­tunis­tic dis­ease else­where; it rep­re­sents the third most fre­quent agent of hos­pi­tal ac­quired in­fec­tions. E. fae­calis can cause rel­a­tively mi­nor prob­lems in hu­mans, like uri­nary tract in­fec­tions, or more se­ri­ous con­di­tions such as en­do­cardi­tis or sep­sis. Un­for­tu­nately, the species adapts very quickly to changes it might face within the host, and it has evolved mul­tidrug re­sis­tance, in­clud­ing to β–lactam an­tibi­otics and van­comycin.

Last year, an in­ter­est­ing pa­per de­scribed a char­ac­ter­is­tic of E. fae­calis patho­gen­e­sis that may hold promise for new an­timi­cro­bial de­vel­op­ment. Like all life forms, E. fae­calis re­quires man­ganese (Mn) as a mi­cronu­tri­ent to sur­vive. Mn is a co-fac­tor of en­zymes of cen­tral meta­bolic path­ways, such as DNA biosyn­the­sis and en­ergy gen­er­a­tion. But man­ganese also holds par­tic­u­lar im­por­tance for many bac­te­ria dur­ing patho­gen­e­sis, such as by play­ing an im­per­a­tive role dur­ing re­sponses to ox­ida­tive stress. Dur­ing these path­o­genic in­ter­ac­tions, host and bac­te­r­ial cells com­pete for avail­able pools of es­sen­tial mi­cronu­tri­ents like Mn.

Get­ting That Man­ganese

In their pa­per, Colomer-Win­ter et al. looked at pre­dicted Mn trans­porters in the E. fae­calis genome to de­ter­mine their role in Mn home­osta­sis and their im­por­tance for bac­te­r­ial vir­u­lence, processes not pre­vi­ously ex­plored for this species. The core genome of E. fae­calis en­codes three pu­ta­tive Mn trans­porters: the ABC trans­porter EfaCBA and two Nat­ural-Re­sis­tance-As­so­ci­ated-Macrophage Pro­teins (Nramp-type trans­porters), named MntH1 and MntH2.

The au­thors made mu­tants in which one of the trans­porters (three strains with sin­gle mu­ta­tions: Δefa, ΔmntH1, or ΔmntH2), two of the three (ΔefaΔmntH1, ΔefaΔmntH2, or ΔmntH1ΔmntH2), or all three (ΔefaΔmntH1ΔmntH2) were deleted from the parental OG1RF E. fae­calis strain. In this way, they could elu­ci­date the con­tri­bu­tion of each po­ten­tial trans­porter and re­veal unique or re­dun­dant roles they might play in the bacterium's growth.

Fig­ure 2. Growth of OG1RF and its der­ivatives in Mn-re­plete (left) and Mn-de­pleted (right) con­di­tions. Growth was moni­tored us­ing a Bio­screen growth reader mon­i­tor. Sig­nif­i­cant dif­fer­ences were shown in the growth of the triple mu­tant, and one of the dou­ble mu­tants, be­tween Mn con­cen­tra­tions. Source

Cul­tures of the mu­tant strains and the wild-type par­ent were grown in broth cul­tures sup­ple­mented with or de­pleted of Mn. Upon Mn de­ple­tion (Mn < 90 nM), one dou­ble mu­tant (ΔefaΔmntH2) had a slightly lower over­all growth rate, and an ex­tended lag phase com­pared to the parental con­trol. The triple mu­tant, how­ever, showed a sig­nif­i­cant de­crease in over­all growth. The au­thors con­fi­dently con­cluded that these three trans­porters have a re­dun­dant role in pro­mot­ing E. fae­calis growth in Mn-re­stricted en­vi­ron­ments.

The au­thors also de­ter­mined the cy­to­plas­mic Mn con­cen­tra­tions in the dif­fer­ent mu­tants. Over­all, their re­sults were con­sis­tent with the prior ob­ser­va­tions: the sin­gle dele­tion mu­tants did not dif­fer from the wild-type strain in their cy­to­plas­mic Mn con­cen­tra­tion. Two of the dou­ble mu­tant strains showed a slight (~40%) re­duc­tion in in­tra­cel­lu­lar Mn, but in the triple mu­tant the Mn con­cen­tra­tion lev­els were be­low the de­tectable limit. This sup­ports a model where EfaCBA, MntH1, and MntH2 serve to­gether as the three trans­porters in­volved in E. fae­calis ac­qui­si­tion of Mn

The Im­por­tance of Mn for E. fae­calis Vir­u­lence

Hav­ing es­tab­lished these three trans­porters were re­spon­si­ble for Mn up­take into
E. fae­calis, the au­thors in­ves­ti­gated if Mn ac­qui­si­tion in­flu­enced the vir­u­lence of E. fae­calis. To do this, they in­jected the parental OG1RF strain or the trans­porter dele­tion mu­tants into an in­sect larva model host, Gal­le­ria mel­lonella.

Fig­ure 3. Per­cent sur­vival (av­er­age shown by the hor­i­zon­tal lines) of the G. mel­lonella or­gan­isms in­fected with dif­fer­ent strains of E. fae­calis, mea­sured af­ter 72 hours of in­cu­ba­tion. Source

They found that as long as the in­fec­tive strain of E. fae­calis had at least one func­tion­ing Mn trans­porter, it was ca­pa­ble of killing G. mel­lonella. How­ever, the triple dele­tion strain that can­not main­tain in­tra­cel­lu­lar man­ganese and suf­fers growth de­fects, showed a sig­nif­i­cant de­crease in killing. The  dou­ble mu­tants had a small, though sig­nif­i­cant, in­crease in sur­vivor­ship.

Even with a full reper­toire of func­tional Mn trans­porters, a bac­terium like E. fae­calis can still face Mn de­ple­tion dur­ing patho­gen­e­sis. This is due to the ef­fects of host nu­tri­tional im­mu­nity, a com­po­nent of in­nate im­mu­nity whereby the host helps pro­tect it­self by se­ques­ter­ing es­sen­tial el­e­ments from in­vad­ing species. Cal­pro­tectin is a pro­tein in the blood and tis­sues of ver­te­brates that, when the body senses an in­fec­tion by a bac­terium, is used to bind to spe­cific tran­si­tion met­als in the body, thereby lim­it­ing the es­sen­tial mi­cronu­tri­ent from a competitor's use.

Fig­ure 4. Growth of E. fae­calis strains in the pres­ence of cal­pro­tectin. As­ter­isks mark the de­gree of sig­nif­i­cant dif­fer­ence bet­ween the growth of a given strain com­pared to the con­trol, with four ast­erisks in­di­cat­ing most sig­nif­i­cance. Source

The au­thors as­sessed the abil­ity of their E. fae­calis strains to grow when in the pres­ence of cal­pro­tectin. As pre­dicted, this pro­tein in­hib­ited growth of the sin­gle trans­porter dele­tion mu­tants, with the Δefa strain show­ing the great­est ef­fect. As a con­trol, the au­thors used a cal­pro­tectin vari­ant whose abil­ity to se­quester Mn was specif­i­cally com­pro­mised but with no re­duc­tion in zinc se­ques­tra­tion. The E. fae­calis trans­porter mu­tants showed high growth with this al­tered cal­pro­tectin, demon­strat­ing that the ob­served cal­pro­tectin ac­tiv­ity is spe­cific to Mn se­ques­tra­tion. The au­thors thus con­cluded that EfaCBA is the pri­mary trans­porter of Mn into the bac­te­r­ial cell, and that trans­porter re­dun­dancy might have evolved as a way of over­com­ing host nu­tri­tional im­mu­nity ef­fects.

What Does This Mean for Us?

The au­thors went on to test the vir­u­lence of their trans­porter mu­tant strains in a rab­bit in­fec­tion model, show­ing that with­out an abun­dant amount of Mn, E. fae­calis is com­pletely avir­u­lent. Con­versely, they found that high lev­els of Mn ac­qui­si­tion cor­re­lated with E. fae­calis biofilm for­ma­tion.

These re­sults sug­gest that it may be pos­si­ble to find or de­sign a drug that could in­hibit these spe­cific trans­porters (EfaCBA, MntH1, and MntH2) to com­bat E. fae­calis vir­u­lence. How­ever, some side ef­fects on the host may oc­cur be­cause each of these three trans­porters be­long to highly and broadly con­served pro­tein fam­i­lies, and ver­te­brates sim­i­larly re­quire Mn for a va­ri­ety of cel­lu­lar path­ways in­clud­ing lipid, pro­tein, and car­bo­hy­drate me­tab­o­lism.

Nonethe­less, pur­suit of novel an­tibi­otics that in­hibit mi­cronu­tri­ent ac­qui­si­tion such as this are of on­go­ing in­ter­est. The au­thors of this study in­di­cate in­ter­est in fur­ther study­ing "the sig­nif­i­cance of di­etary Mn in the patho­phys­i­ol­ogy of E. fae­calis, to elu­ci­date the or­gan-de­pen­dent dif­fer­en­tial tran­scrip­tional reg­u­la­tion of each Mn trans­porter, and to un­der­stand the con­tri­bu­tion of Mn-de­pen­dent re­sponses to ox­ida­tive stress sur­vival in the con­text of in­fec­tion." At the very min­i­mum, the knowl­edge ob­tained from this re­search has widened a path to­wards po­ten­tial treat­ment of one of the most com­mon hos­pi­tal ac­quired in­fec­tions in peo­ple.

 

Madeline Beaulieu

Made­line is cur­rently a se­nior at Can­i­sius Col­lege ma­jor­ing in Bi­ol­ogy with a mi­nor in Span­ish. She is prepar­ing for med­ical school and is also a mem­ber of the women's soc­cer team. Her in­ter­est in sci­ence, par­tic­u­larly as it re­lates to hu­man health, de­vel­oped while grow­ing up in Vestal, New York and in­creased af­ter be­com­ing ex­posed to mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy at Can­i­sius!

 

Other Posts

  • Small RNAs Con­sid­ered

    by Janie — With the dis­cov­ery of the 𝘵𝘳𝘱 at­ten­u­a­tor in the 1970s, fol­lowed shortly by the ColE1 plas­mid RNA I, RNA be­came a much more in­ter­est­ing per­son­al­ity. The bio­mol­e­cule wears far more hats than mRNA, rRNA, and tRNA. In all its mul­ti­tudes, RNA seems to boast an in­fi­nite func­tional reper­toire...

  • Some Like It Lin­ear

    by Merry — Last year, a team of Japan­ese re­searchers de­lib­er­ately con­verted the cir­cu­lar chro­mo­some of E. coli into a lin­ear one. To do this, they bor­rowed some tricks from the lamb­doid col­iphage N15, a tem­per­ate ds­DNA phage whose prophage ex­ists and repli­cates as a 46 kb lin­ear plas­mid. When tested in L broth at 37°C, the...

  • Never a Dull En­zyme

    by Roberto — The tri­car­boxylic acid cy­cle en­zyme cit­rate syn­thase from Syne­chococ­cus elon­ga­tus has the re­mark­able fea­ture that it self-as­sem­bles into mul­ti­meric frac­tal shapes, specif­i­cally Sier­piński tri­an­gles. As Arthur Ko­rn­berg would have said: "Never a dull en­zyme!"...

  • Get­ting to grips with the in­tan­gi­ble

    by Christoph — Imag­ine the E. coli nu­cleoid as a swig but of of a high­ly vis­cous tan­gle of a 2 nm thin and ~1.5 mm long DNA poly­mer, de­co­rat­ed with and high­ly com­pact­ed by a ple­tho­ra of pro­teins, and some­how sus­pend­ed in the cy­to­plasm of a cell with a vol­ume of ~1.3 µm³. It's vir­tu­al­ly im­pos­si­ble to "grip" the nu­cleoid, to mea­sure...

  • Mi­cro­bial So­ci­ol­ogy

    by Elio — Few top­ics of re­cent have been as tit­il­lat­ing as com­mu­ni­ca­tion among bac­te­ria. Just like in­sects, bac­te­ria "talk" to each other in a chem­i­cal lan­guage, ask­ing one an­other ques­tions such as: How many of us are there? Is it time to make a biofilm? Do con­di­tions call for mak­ing tox­ins? and (the grand­fa­ther of them all) Should we...

  • In a Hurry?

    by Elio — E. coli may even­tu­ally get de­throned from its lofty po­si­tion as the best stud­ied, best known, and per­haps best ex­ploited or­gan­ism on this planet. The up­start is Vib­rio na­triegens, a marsh-dwelling gram-neg­a­tive bac­terium that grows 1.4 to 3.9 times faster than E. coli in the lab­o­ra­tory, de­pend­ing on the medium (it also de­pends on which strain of the lat­ter you're talk­ing about).