Mono Lake (A Snip­pet)

by Elio

Travel down the east­ern slope of California's Sierra Nevada and you will run into a num­ber of breath­tak­ing sights. Rank­ing high among them is Mono Lake, a large shal­low lake that sports a col­lec­tion of strange lime­stone columns. Pro­trud­ing some 30 feet above the wa­ter sur­face, these struc­tures, known as chim­neys, con­sist of cal­cium car­bon­ate min­er­als, mainly as cal­cite (CaCO3) called tufa. The columns were formed un­der­wa­ter and the rea­son they are vis­i­ble is that in 1941 the city of Los An­ge­les, in an ef­fort to slake its grow­ing need for wa­ter, started di­vert­ing the wa­ter of Mono Lake. This low­ered the wa­ter level to half, dou­bled its salin­ity, and ex­posed the columns. The process has been stopped and the lake's wa­ter level is now al­lowed to fluc­tu­ate more normal­ly (See here for past and cur­rent lev­els). Mean­while, no ac­tive growth of tufa columns has been re­ported since the 1980s.

Fig­ure 1. Fos­silised bac­te­ria within Mono Lake tu­fa chim­neys. (a) Mul­ti­ple type 1 fil­a­ments. (b) Clus­ter of ap­proximately aligned seg­mented ty­pe 2 fil­a­ments. © Type 1 fil­a­ments aligned per­pendicular to outward-radiating sub­crys­tal bou­n­daries. (d) Sin­gle Type 1 fil­a­ment show­ing puta­tive seg­men­ta­tion. (e) A Type 1 and Type 2 fila­ment side by side. (f) Type 2 fil­a­ment show­ing clear seg­men­ta­tion and po­ten­tially par­tially sur­rounded by a min­er­alised sheath. (g) Type 2 fila­ment show­ing seg­men­ta­tion and po­ten­tial rem­nants of cell con­tents. (h) Typ­i­cal Type 1 empty sheaths. (i) Typ­i­cal coc­coid bac­terium. Scale bars are 50 μm for (a-c) and 10 μm for (d-i). Dashed black lines in­di­cate tran­si­tion be­tween im­ages taken at dif­fer­ent fo­cal depths. Source. Front­page: Tufa in Mono Lake, CA. CC BY-SA 2.0 steve lyon

How were these struc­tures formed? Was the process pu­re­ly ge­o­log­i­cal, abi­otic, or where liv­ing or­gan­isms invol­ved? Not a sim­ple ques­tion, that. A re­cent pa­per in Geo­biology ex­am­ines this ques­tion but as we are short of geo­logists at this blogsite, let us hear from the au­thors of the pa­per: "Dis­tin­guish­ing bi­o­log­i­cally in­flu­enced sedi­men­tary rock struc­tures from abi­otic ones in the field, or when se­lect­ing high pri­or­ity tar­gets from re­mote im­ages, is a key chal­lenge in the search for early and extra­ter­res­trial life. There are few recog­nis­able mil­lime­tre to deci­met­re-scale struc­tures iden­ti­fi­able as de­fin­i­tively "micro­bial" in out­crop.  Free-standing chim­neys com­posed of car­bon­ate, sul­phate or sil­i­cate min­er­als, if re­quir­ing the in­flu­ence of or­gan­isms to de­velop, pro­vide a po­ten­tial set of tar­gets for ter­res­trial ge­o­log­i­cal and as­tro­bi­o­log­i­cal in­ves­ti­ga­tion (e.g., Wal­ter & Des Marais, 1993)."

The au­thors dis­cuss both geo­chem­i­cal and geo­bi­o­log­i­cal mod­els that have been pro­posed and come down on the side of both, with an ap­par­ent pref­er­ence for the lat­ter. In fa­vor of a bi­o­log­i­cal ori­gin is the find­ing of abun­dant mi­crobes and al­gae at the site of ac­tive tufa growth. The study con­cludes that, among other things, biofilms en­cou­raged crys­tal growth by pro­vid­ing sites of cal­cite nu­cleation. They present de­tailed mor­pho­log­i­cal observa­tions of the Mono Lake chim­neys that re­veal a large num­ber of fil­a­men­tous mi­crobes, var­ied in size and shape. Us­ing a bar­rage of tech­niques, in­clud­ing XRD, GC-MS, NanoSIMS, and scan­ning and trans­mis­sion elec­tron mi­croscopy, they found or­ganic bio­mark­ers that are con­sistent with an ori­gin as ex­tra­cel­lu­lar or­ganic ma­te­r­ial (EOM). This pa­per is re­plete with de­tails that speak di­rectly to the ques­tion of the bi­o­log­i­cal ori­gin of the Mono Lake tufa. It should be read care­fully by those in­ter­ested in this un­usual set of events.

 

Other Posts