To The Bot­tom of the Sea

by Elio

Are there in­stances of wa­ter-con­tain­ing sites on Earth that (par­don the ex­pres­sion) have not yet been metage­nomi­cized? Surely many re­main, but their num­bers must be dwin­dling quite rapidly. Among the last fron­tiers to suc­cumb to ge­nomic analy­sis are the deep­est parts of the ocean. Re­call that the deep­est fur­row on the Earth's sur­face is the Mar­i­ana Trench, lo­cated in the west­ern Pa­cific. (Fig­ure 1 here) It in­cludes a mile-wide gorge called the Chal­lenger Deep that is the deep­est point known, nearly 11 Km from the ocean sur­face. As the Wikipedia tells us: "For com­par­i­son: if Mount Ever­est were dropped into the trench at this point, its peak would still be over 2 kilo­me­ters (1.2 mi) un­der wa­ter." For how it was formed, see here. Not un­ex­pect­edly, this is hardly the most vis­ited nor most of­ten sam­pled site on the globe. It has been vis­ited a few times by both un­manned and manned ve­hi­cles, such as the Deepsea Chal­lenger that in 2012 car­ried the film di­rec­tor James Cameron. Sam­ples from this site have been ob­tained via a lan­der ve­hi­cle or 'un­der­wa­ter el­e­va­tor' and their mi­cro­bio­mes an­a­lyzed. For more about these most re­con­dite places, I rec­om­mend a de­light­ful piece by Jen­nifer Frazer. As she points out, no scary mon­sters like the gi­ant squid Kraken have been seen at these depths.

Fig­ure 1. Mar­i­ana Trench. Source. Fron­tispiece; Source

A re­cent re­port in mSys­tems deals with a metage­nomic study of sam­ples from two Mar­i­ana Trench sites, the Chal­lenger Deep and the Sirena Deep. Sam­ples were col­lected in De­cem­ber,  2014 dur­ing a cruise of the Falkor, a ma­rine re­search ves­sel of the Schmidt Ocean In­sti­tute (see here). These sites are rich in life, es­pe­cially pro­tists, mul­ti­cel­lu­lar in­ver­te­brates, and of course bac­te­ria. Most of these life forms await fur­ther in­ves­ti­ga­tion, es­pe­cially con­cern­ing their genomes. Since so many species are found here, the in­ves­ti­ga­tors had to make choices: they opted for the gut mi­cro­biome of am­phipods, promi­nent mem­bers of the lo­cal biota. Am­phipods are large shrimp-look­ing crea­tures that are the main scav­engers ('de­tri­tovores') at these sites. De­tri­tovory, aka car­rion-feed­ing, refers to the eat­ing of food that falls manna-like from above. This is the main source of nour­ish­ment for or­gan­isms liv­ing at the bot­tom of the oceans.

Fig­ure 2. A Hi­ron­del­lea gi­gas spec­i­men col­lected at a depth of 35,820 feet in the Mar­i­ana Trench's Chal­lenger Deep. Source

The in­ves­ti­ga­tors fo­cused on the gut mi­cro­biota  of the large am­phi­pod, Hi­ron­del­lea gi­gas, a com­mon denizen at depths over 10,000 me­ters. (Fig­ure 2 here) The species name is fit­ting be­cause in­di­vid­u­als can reach a sur­pris­ing 30 cm. in length. (The genus name, btw, refers to that of the 19th cen­tury Monaco ma­rine re­search ves­sel, La Hi­ron­delle – the swal­low.)  The gut mi­cro­biome of H. gi­gas is dom­i­nated by a species of  Psy­chromonas, a cold- and salt-lov­ing mem­ber of the Gammapro­teobac­te­ria. This par­tic­u­lar not yet named species, here des­ig­nated as CDP1, has not been found liv­ing free any­where. It alone ac­counts for 12.5–60.5% if the to­tal gut mi­cro­biome of H. gi­gas (the rest of the mi­cro­biome must wait).

CDP1 has quite a small genome, around 1.6 Mb. It codes for some 1,600 genes, which is less than half those of its kin­dred free-liv­ing Psy­chromonas (al­though this is sim­i­lar in size to some free-liv­ing bac­te­ria, such as the 1.6 Mb genome of Pelag­ibac­ter). Fur­ther ge­nomic econ­omy is seen in the length of the in­ter­genic re­gions, which, again, are about half what is found in other psy­chromon­ads. So, this strain has un­der­gone se­vere ge­nomic re­duc­tion. This is a fas­ci­nat­ing topic that we re­cently dis­cussed in this blog. It is com­mon among sym­bi­otic bac­te­ria, who can achieve econ­omy by shed­ding genes for func­tions that can be sup­plied by their host.

Fig­ure 3. Mi­cro­bial tax­o­nomic struc­tures de­duced from the gut metagenomes. Psy­chromonas is the dom­i­nant genus in most of the sam­ples from the Chal­lenger Deep (CD) and the Sirena Deep (SD). One of the Chal­lenger Deep gut sam­ples was sep­a­rated into midgut (CD1‑M) and hindgut (CD1‑H) sam­ples. Gen­era to­tal­ing >1% of the sam­ples are shown. Source

What kind of genes have been re­tained and what kind are miss­ing? Present are the genes for macro­mol­e­c­u­lar syn­the­sis, anaer­o­bic res­pi­ra­tion, and cen­tral car­bo­hy­drate me­tab­o­lism, to in­clude the uti­liza­tion of a va­ri­ety of car­bon sources such as car­bo­hy­drates, pro­teins, and nu­cleic acids. Tran­scrip­tomic analy­sis of CDP1 shows that many of these genes are ac­tively ex­pressed in two dif­fer­ent in­testi­nal lo­ca­tions of H. gi­gas, the midgut and the hindgut. Thus, the bac­te­ria are alive and well at these sites, which im­plies that their oblig­ing host sup­plies the es­sen­tial func­tion for the genes they lack. This ex­plains why or­gan­isms like CDP‑1 can­not thrive out­side their host and are likely to be trans­mit­ted ver­ti­cally to their host's off­spring.

Of spe­cial in­ter­est is that CDP‑1 lacks the operon for the re­duc­tion of an im­por­tant metabo­lite, trimethy­lamine N-ox­ide (TMAO). In fish, this operon con­verts TMAO into the volatile trimethy­lamine (TMA, which is what makes spoiled fish smelly). In bac­te­ria, TMAO has two known func­tions: it is an im­por­tant elec­tron ac­cep­tor in anaer­o­bic res­pi­ra­tion and, as a piezolyte, it pro­tects pro­teins from the ef­fects of high pres­sure. In fish and in­ver­te­brates, the deeper they live, the more TMAO they con­tain. In the words of the au­thors, 'The ab­sence of the tor­CAD operon in the CDP1 genome sug­gests that the piezolyte func­tion of TMAO (per­haps ben­e­fit­ing both the host and the sym­biont) is more im­por­tant than its func­tion in res­pi­ra­tion. That is, dele­tion of the tor operon leads to the con­se­quence that TMAO can be ac­cu­mu­lated to func­tion as a piezolyte. There­fore, dele­tion of the tor sys­tem in CDP1 could be ex­plained by the hy­dro­sta­tic stress re­sponse of the host and the gut mi­cro­biota.' Here, ge­nomic re­duc­tion is not just an eco­nomic thing to do, it's ben­e­fi­cial in a pos­i­tive sense.

No one has yet fig­ured out what's in this sym­bio­sis for the am­phi­pod host. What ben­e­fit does it de­rive from the Psy­chromonas, as well as from the rest of its in­testi­nal mi­cro­biome? Not easy to study, as the rear­ing of am­phipods in a lab may re­quire some in­tri­cate ma­neu­vers. But what we have learned about the bac­te­ria is that even at the bot­tom of the ocean some of them have evolved a par­si­mo­nious life style. This in­clude re­duc­ing their genome size to what­ever is needed and lit­tle more. This pen­nynch­ing strat­egy, then, is man­i­fested not only near the sur­face of the Earth but also in its far­thest reaches. We can state with ever deeper con­fi­dence that liv­ing things are won­der­ful at adapt­ing to their cir­cum­stances, even in the 'hole at the bot­tom of the sea'.

 

 

Other Posts