The Truth Is In The Out­come

by Elio

Gifts From the Past

Co­pro­lites — fos­sil fe­ces — are noth­ing short of a mar­vel. A mes­sage from the past, they di­vulge im­por­tant in­for­ma­tion about what their mak­ers lived on as well as on how they lived. They were de­posited in eco­log­i­cally rel­e­vant sites and they dis­play rem­nants of undi­gested food such as seeds, bits of plant tis­sue, pollen, starch grains, and, of course, DNA. Co­pro­lites fig­ure promi­nently in pa­le­on­to­log­i­cal stud­ies of all sorts, in­clud­ing of hu­mans. They of­fer ev­i­dence of food predilec­tion, pre­da­tion, can­ni­bal­ism, in­fes­ta­tion by an­i­mal par­a­sites (e.g., tape­worm eggs in 270-mil­lion-year-old sharks), and more. The study of co­pro­lites has been cru­cial in the in­ves­ti­ga­tion of such key ques­tions as the col­o­niz­ing of the Amer­i­cas, the di­ets of Ne­an­derthals, and the do­mes­ti­ca­tion of an­i­mals.

Fig­ure 1. A co­pro­lite. Age: Cre­ta­ceous; For­ma­tion: Ozan; Lo­ca­tion: N. Sul­phur River, TX, USA; Di­men­sions: 36.85mm X 26.64mm; Weight: 13.1g; Fea­tures: Sev­eral ver­te­brae and bones through­out. Source

A Few Facts

The ear­li­est known co­pro­lites stem from the Cam­brian pe­riod, about 500 mil­lion years ago and were likely pro­duced by car­ni­vores. Car­ni­vore dung is more likely to be­come fos­silized be­cause cal­cium-rich bones and teeth de­com­pose slowly. The longest known co­pro­lite mea­sures about 40 cm in length, ob­vi­ously from a large an­i­mal (it was priced at auc­tion at $8,000). Co­pro­lites have also been made into jew­elry.

Fig­ure 2. Moa and hu­man (re­con­struc­tion). Source

How to tell a co­pro­lite from in­or­ganic ob­ject sim­i­lar in shape? Not easy. Not every turd-shaped rock is a co­pro­lite, far from it. Chem­istry helps. Since the early 19th cen­tury, pa­le­on­tol­o­gists have been study­ing co­pro­lites with ap­pro­pri­ate in­ten­sity, more re­cently re­sort­ing to the analy­sis of bio­mark­ers, such as steroids and bile acids, which are not only spe­cific to cer­tain an­i­mal groups but also long last­ing. And, of course, DNA.

Moas and their co­pro­lites

Here is an ex­am­ple in PNAS of what co­pro­li­tol­ogy (a ne­ol­o­gism, if you per­mit) has un­earthed. A group from New Zealand, Aus­tralia, and the US have stud­ied the fe­cal fos­sils of ex­tinct birds of New Zealand, the moas. Sev­eral species of moa lorded it over the land­scape, some be­ing 3.6 me­ters tall (the height of an African ele­phant) and weigh­ing a quar­ter of a ton. Two hun­dred years af­ter the ar­rival of hu­mans, some­time be­fore 1300, all were gone. But lucky for us, moa co­pro­lites, about 7000 years old, are both abun­dant and well pre­served.

The au­thors stud­ied co­pro­lites from 5 kind of moas that had lived in dis­tinct habi­tats of New Zealand's South Is­land. They an­a­lyzed their DNA con­tent by high through­put screen­ing and, rea­son­ably, found that the ones from moas dif­fered from those of mam­mals and mod­ern birds.  A sur­pris­ing fact is that the great­est di­ver­sity of what they ate were fungi, which also rep­re­sent the dom­i­nant taxa in the sam­ples. Most of these were as­comycetes mold and yeasts, prob­a­bly de­rived from the en­vi­ron­ment and there­fore not fur­ther stud­ied. For the rest, ed­i­ble ba­sid­iomycete mush­rooms were abun­dantly rep­re­sented, es­pe­cially in co­pro­lites from the moas that that lived in the my­c­or­rhiza-rich (ergo mush­room-rich) south­ern beech forests.  Ex­am­ples are such com­mon my­c­or­rhizal mush­room gen­era as Corti­nar­ius, In­ocybe, and Armil­laria, as well as some puff­balls. Mush­room DNA was also found in the kakapo,  a New Zealand flight­less par­rot that is known to be a my­cophag­ist. The con­clu­sion, warm to a my­cophilist heart, is that the moas were mush­room eaters.  If the thought oc­curred to you that they may have van­ished be­cause they ate poi­so­nous mush­rooms, for­get it: it's hu­man pres­sure for food that did it. Note that My­cophagy in birds be­sides kakapo and other par­rots is not un­heard of, but it is sat­is­fy­ing to learn that an­cient moas had this taste. It was lost with time, as os­triches and ki­wis do not share this palate.  

Fig­ure 3. Pro­por­tions of reads per sam­ple to tax­o­nomic and eco­log­i­cal groups as de­ter­mined us­ing QIIME. All OTUs present in ex­trac­tion blanks are fil­tered. Note the un­equal to­tal read counts among sam­ples. Source

A Fun­gal Aside

Be­ing eaten by an­i­mals serves mush­rooms to spread their spores, es­pe­cially in species that do not pri­mar­ily rely for it on wind dis­per­sal. Take for in­stance those species in the genus Corti­nar­ius, com­mon in New Zealand, that are 'se­ques­trated.' That is, they don't make fruit­ing bod­ies with open caps (mush­rooms) that al­low spores to be di­rectly lib­er­ate into the air. Rather, their fruit­ing bod­ies are en­closed, and their spores con­tained within sac-like struc­tures. Thus, they re­quire the help of, say, fun­giv­o­rous an­i­mals for their dis­per­sal. This is of course true of ex­tant truf­fles and a num­ber of mush­rooms species. The au­thors point out, with some rea­son, that New Zealand se­ques­trated mush­room species are very col­or­ful, an ap­pro­pri­ate way to at­tract birds. They spec­u­late that moas and the nearly ex­tinct kakapo par­rot can­not be re­placed in this role by the im­ported an­i­mal species, hence the sur­vival of such mush­rooms is threat­ened.  At present much of this is ed­u­cated guess­work. Likely, more se­quenc­ing data down to the species level will shed more light on this topic.

What Else Did the Moas Eat?

Ad­di­tional moa veg­e­tar­ian eat­ing habits are re­vealed by find­ing in their co­pro­lites plant DNA, namely DNA from ferns, mosses, lo­cal shrubs, herbs, and trees. These stud­ies re­veal that the var­i­ous moa species pre­ferred dif­fer­ent foods. That's not all. Pre­vi­ous DNA analy­sis of the co­pro­lites also re­vealed the pres­ence of par­a­sites, to in­clude pro­tists (Eimeri­daea) and worms (Het­erokoidea ne­ma­todes and flukes). This study am­pli­fies such re­sults and adds novel par­a­site species to the list. The au­thors say: "Where dif­fer­ent moa species co-oc­curred (i.e., Dart River Val­ley), lit­tle bush, gi­ant, and up­land moa had sim­i­lar par­a­site com­mu­ni­ties, sug­gest­ing reg­u­lar par­a­site trans­mis­sion across dif­fer­ent moa taxa. Fi­nally, the sin­gle trema­tode OTU de­tected was abun­dant and wide­spread among up­land moa co­pro­lites, but was present in very low counts in some heavy-footed and gi­ant moa co­pro­lites, pos­si­bly re­flect­ing dif­fer­ences in host be­hav­ior in­stead of host-speci­ficity to up­land moa (Fig. 3)."

Fig­ure 4. The 'se­ques­trate' mush­room Wer­aroa no­vae-ze­landiae, a 'sec­o­tioid' form of a blu­ing Psilo­cybe.  Source

In con­clu­sion, we know now that moas ate fungi, mosses, and ferns, and that dif­fer­ent species had dif­fer­ent tastes in plants, de­pend­ing in part on the plant biota of their in­di­vid­ual habi­tats.  Find­ing trema­tode DNA in co­pro­lites of some moas also re­veals their habi­tat predilec­tions be­cause these par­a­sites are usu­ally trans­mit­ted by eat­ing aquatic veg­e­ta­tion or snails. All told, the smaller up­land moas ate dif­fer­ent food than the gi­ant moas. No­tice how much can be learned from the study of co­pro­lites re­gard­ing the phys­i­ol­ogy and even how their cre­ators in­ter­acted with their ecosys­tem. Isn't it re­mark­able how much in­for­ma­tion can be ex­tracted from such down-to-earth re­mains?

 

Elio dis­cusses Co­pro­lites and the Moa, in de­tail, on this episode of This Week in Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy

 

Other Posts

  • Elec­tri­fy­ing Bac­te­ria!

    by a con­sor­tium of In­te­gra­tive Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy grad­u­ate stu­dents — Imag­ine that there is an alien – on some dis­tant planet – who can reach out with a liv­ing ap­pendage of its own and use byprod­ucts of its own me­tab­o­lism to trans­fer an elec­tric cur­rent out­side of its own body. If you think that is bizarre, look no fur­ther than our planet – and think small. Metal-re­duc­ing bac­te­ria do ex­actly that.

  • My Ge­o­log­i­cal Ig­no­rance

    by Elio — Some years ago, I was stand­ing on an over­look of the bad­lands in the Anza-Bor­rego Cal­i­for­nia desert, ex­plain­ing to a friend that the lay­ers of red rocks in front of us were de­rived from the Grand Canyon, some­what proud that I could ex­er­cise some of my ex­tra­or­di­nar­ily lim­ited knowl­edge of…

  • Two Less

    by Elio — Two peo­ple who mat­tered to me and to many other peo­ple have died re­cently. I wish to honor their mem­ory by shar­ing a glimpse of them with you. Manny died on Jan­u­ary 8, 2014, one month shy of his 96th birth­day. A mem­ber of a dis­tin­guished Swiss fam­ily…

  • An­drew Wright (1935−2023)

    by Roberto — This past Oc­to­ber 9th, mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy lost an ex­tra­or­di­nary mem­ber when An­drew Wright died. Those of us for­tu­nate to have in­ter­acted with him over the years lost a very good friend. Even on a first meet­ing it was im­pos­si­ble not to sense his kind­ness and gen­uine in­ter­est in the con­ver­sa­tion, un­der­scored by his gen­tle smile and an en­dear­ing Scot­tish ac­cent.

  • Space Odyssey, Sal­mo­nella Style

    by Elio — It would take a brave per­son to ques­tion a pa­per signed by 41 au­thors, es­pe­cially when they per­formed an amaz­ing ex­per­i­ment on gene ac­ti­va­tion in space. In fact, given the dif­fi­cul­ties of car­ry­ing out such an ex­per­i­ment, any crit­i­cism would be down­right churl­ish. Nev­er­the­less...