Of Moun­tains and Mi­crobes…

by David Lip­son

As Elio has pointed out re­cently, the sil­ica cy­cle in­deed de­serves re­spect, and it is prob­a­bly respon­sible for ma­jor plan­e­tary events, such as dri­ving the evo­lu­tion of C4 pho­to­syn­the­sis in land plants since the for­ma­tion of the Hi­malayas and the Ti­betan Plateau helped drive down CO2 lev­els to their low, pre-in­dus­­­trial lev­els. Some ex­pla­na­tion:

The first pho­to­syn­thetic path­way to evolve is known as the C3 path­way be­cause the pri­mary pro­duct of pho­to­syn­the­sis by the en­zyme, Ru­BisCO, is a pair of phos­pho­glyc­er­ate mol­e­cules, contain­ing 3 C's each. C3 plants cur­rently rep­re­sent about 4/5th of global plant bio­mass. The early his­tory of land plants took place in a high CO2 world, where at­mos­pheric CO2 con­cen­tra­tions were greater than 1000 ppm, sev­eral times higher than the re­cent epoch, where CO2 has cy­cled be­tween about 200 and 275 ppm with glacial/interglacial cy­cles (un­til, of course, the in­dus­trial pe­riod where CO2 has risen to over 400 ppm, a level not seen for over a mil­lion years). When the ra­tio of CO2 to O2 is low, C3 plants are vulne­rable to pho­tores­pi­ra­tion, in which O2 binds to the ac­tive site of Ru­BisCO, caus­ing the ox­i­da­tion of the sub­strate and a loss of pho­to­syn­thetic ef­fi­ciency (2).

His­tograms com­par­ing δ13C val­ues for fos­sil tooth enamel older than 8 Ma (lower half of charts) with those that are younger than 6 Ma (up­per half of charts) for (a) Pak­istan, (b) East Africa (Kenya), © South Amer­ica, (d) southwes­tern North Ame­ri­ca, (e) north­west­ern Amer­ica, and (f) Eu­rope. All re­gions have a C3-dom­i­na­ted, and per­haps ex­clu­sive C3 diet be­fore 8 Ma. In Pak­istan the younger fauna is al­most exclu­sively C4-graz­ers; in East Af­rica the younger fauna has mam­mals that are gene­rally ei­ther C3-dom­i­nated or C4-dom­i­nated with a few mixed feed­ers; south­west­ern North Amer­ica shows mixed feed­ers, as well as ex­clu­sive C3- and C4-di­ets; in Eu­rope and in the northwest­ern Amer­ica the younger fauna re­tains a C3-diet: in South Amer­ica both C3 and C4 di­ets are ev­i­dent af­ter 6 Ma. For de­tails see Source. Front­page: Leaf cross sec­tion of a C4 Plant (corn) 400× mag­nification Source

C4 pho­to­syn­the­sis is a rel­a­tively re­cent evo­lu­tion­ary mo­di­fication of the C3 path­way. C4 plants have morphologi­cal and bio­chem­i­cal adap­ta­tions that pre­vent photore­spiration by con­cen­trat­ing CO2 into bun­dle sheath cells deep in leaf tis­sues us­ing the en­zyme, PEP car­boxy­lase, which produ­ces ox­aloac­etate, a 4‑C com­pound, hence the name. C4 plants have an ad­van­tage at low CO2 lev­els, as well as hot and dry con­di­tions. Hot and dry con­di­tions were around for a long time be­fore the ap­pear­ance of C4 plants, whereas the de­cline of at­mos­pheric CO2 that has oc­curred over the past 65 mil­lion years or so seems to be the best ex­pla­na­tion for the se­lec­tive pres­sure that led to the suc­cess of this path­way, which now makes up about 18% of the earth's plant bio­mass (1).

One of the ma­jor ge­o­log­i­cal fac­tors that led to the "CO2 star­vation" felt by plants af­ter the Cre­ta­ceous pe­riod was the col­li­sion of the In­dian sub­con­ti­nent into Asia, lead­ing to the up­lift of the Ti­betan plateau and the for­ma­tion of the Himala­yas. These processes ex­posed new sil­i­cate min­er­als to the at­mos­phere, where they re­acted with CO2 to form cal­cite and sil­i­cate: Ca­SiO3 + CO2 → CaCO3 + SiO2

These prod­ucts were car­ried by rivers to the ocean and buried in sed­i­ments, with the net ef­fect of re­mov­ing CO2 from the at­mos­phere. These changes started around 65 mil­lion years ago, and CO2 had dropped pre­cip­i­tously to be­low 500 ppm by the time C4 plants took off, around 8 mil­lion years ago. Be­cause C4 plants have a dis­tinct 13C iso­topic sig­na­ture, their spread can be traced in the tooth enamel of fos­sil her­bi­vores around this time. The iso­tope data show graz­ers of many ecosys­tems shift­ing to­ward a C4 diet from 6 – 8 mil­lion years ago (1).

And while we're on the sub­ject, an in­flux of Si to the ocean from land due to in­creased winds could have fer­til­ized the ocean's di­atoms (and why not Pheo­dar­i­ans?), suck­ing down at­mos­pheric CO2 lev­els and shift­ing the planet into the last glacial max­i­mum about 18,000 years ago (3). But that's a story for an­other time...

 

Ref­er­ences

(1) Cer­ling TE, Ehleringer JR, Har­ris JM. 1998. Car­bon diox­ide star­va­tion, the de­vel­op­ment of C4 eco­sys­tems, and mam­malian evo­lu­tion. Philo­soph­i­cal Trans­ac­tions of the Royal So­ci­ety of Lon­don B: Bio­lo­gical Sci­ences, 353 (1365), 159–171

(2) Ehleringer JR, Mon­son RK. 1993. Evo­lu­tion­ary and eco­log­i­cal as­pects of pho­to­syn­thetic path­way va­ri­ation. An­nual Re­view of Ecol­ogy and Sys­tem­at­ics, 24 (1), 411–439

(3) Har­ri­son KG. 2000. Role of in­creased ma­rine sil­ica in­put on paleo-pCO2 lev­els. Pa­le­o­ceanog­ra­phy, 15 (3), 292–298

 

David Lipson

David Lip­son works on plant-mi­crobe in­ter­ac­tions and teaches mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy as asso­ci­ate pro­fes­sor at USCD, San Diego. He also takes what he's learned as a mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gist and ap­plies it to the de­sign of mi­cro­tonal gui­tars that de­vi­ate from the stan­dard 12-note sys­tem by re­mov­ing the frets from var­i­ous elec­tric and acoustic gui­tars and reposition­ing them to cre­ate novel scales.

 

Other Posts

  • Small Things: First Re­spon­ders to Oil Spills

    by D. Jay Grimes and Ronald M. At­las — On April 20, 2010, an off­shore oil drilling rig in the north­ern Gulf of Mex­ico, the 'Deep­wa­ter Hori­zon' (DH), ex­ploded from un­de­ter­mined causes. The float­ing rig sunk two days later, break­ing off the well pipe and spilling huge amounts of oil. At the low end of the es­ti­mates, the spill has al­ready eclipsed...

  • Fine Read­ing: The Hy­brid Two-En­gine Sys­tem of Myxobac­te­ria

    by Merry — Mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists have been fas­ci­nated by the so­cial swarm­ing of the myxobac­te­ria since they were first iso­lated by Roland Thax­ter in 1892. Trav­el­ing in "wolf packs," these bac­te­ria glide along solid sur­faces, such as agar. En masse they se­crete enough ex­tra­cel­lu­lar en­zymes to lyse and di­gest bac­te­ria...

  • Borgs in Ar­chaea

    by Me­chas — Mi­crobes never cease to sur­prise, as should be ev­i­dent to long-time STC read­ers. Now we are pre­sented with a novel mech­a­nism that al­lows ar­chaea to ex­pand their gene con­tent and meta­bolic ca­pac­ity. This un­fore­seen dis­cov­ery also il­lus­trates the im­por­tance not only of hav­ing the right tools (and fund­ing) but also of be­ing pre­pared to find the un­ex­pected.

  • eDNA every­where for (al­most) every­thing

    by Me­chas — I have re­cently come across sev­eral ar­ti­cles that men­tion work with en­vi­ron­men­tal DNA, ab­bre­vi­ated with the catchy term eDNA. As a mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gist, I am fa­mil­iar with the term metage­nomic DNA, which refers to the ge­netic ma­te­r­ial from a mixed com­mu­nity, and there­fore won­dered, are these terms equiv­a­lent?

  • Your Name and Oc­cu­pa­tion?

    by Jen­nifer Gutier­rez — How would you like to be able to ask this ques­tion of an in­di­vid­ual bac­terium in its nat­ural habi­tat – and get a truth­ful an­swer? It turns out that there is a way to do just that, thanks to a cool and in­no­v­a­tive tech­nique called Sec­ondary Ion Mass Spec­trom­e­try (SIMS). A cur­rent ver­sion, known as...

  • Ice Ice Maybe

    by Janie — The abil­ity to trig­ger ice for­ma­tion is a prop­erty shared by cer­tain par­ti­cles both or­ganic and in­or­ganic, in­clud­ing bac­te­ria, viruses, phy­to­plank­ton, pollen, soot, dust. These lit­tle par­ti­cles help wa­ter mol­e­cules come to­gether and form ice at warmer tem­per­a­tures than freez­ing point...