How Much Does Bi­ol­ogy Weigh?

by Elio

In nature's in­fi­nite book of se­crecy, a lit­tle I can read.
—Shake­speare, An­thony and Cleopa­tra
 

The very last thing that hap­pened to me at the June 2018 ASM's At­lanta meet­ing (Mi­crobe 2018) was a par­tic­u­larly re­ward­ing co­in­ci­dence. As I was ready to step on an esca­lator at the con­ven­tion cen­ter, ready to go to the air­port, a young man stopped me and asked to talk to me. It was Yi­non BarOn, a stu­dent at Israel's Weiz­mann In­sti­tute and one of the three au­thors of a very re­cently pub­lished ar­ticle that presents a com­pre­hen­sive es­ti­mate of the weight of the whole bios­phere − all the liv­ing crea­tures on Earth. He was pleased to hear that I in­dented to write this up for STC, which made for a grat­i­fy­ing if brief con­ver­sa­tion.

Fig­ure 1. Graph­i­cal re­pre­sen­ta­tion of the glo­bal bio­mass dis­tri­b­u­tion by ta­xa. A Abso­lute bio­masses of dif­fer­ent taxa are repre­sen­ted us­ing a Voronoi di­a­gram, with the area of each cell be­ing pro­por­tional to that taxa global bio­mass (the spe­cific shape of each poly­gon car­ries no mean­ing). This type of vi­su­a­li­za­tion is simi­lar to pie charts but has a much high­er dy­namic range. Val­ues are based on the esti­mates pre­sented in Ta­ble 1 and de­tailed in the SI Ap­pendix. A vi­sual de­pic­tion with­out com­po­nents with very slow meta­bolic ac­tiv­ity, such as plant stems and tree trunks, is shown in SI Ap­pendix, Fig. S1. B Ab­solute bio­mass of dif­fer­ent an­i­mal taxa. Re­lated groups such as ver­te­bra­tes are lo­cated next to each other. We es­ti­mate that the con­tri­bu­tion of rep­tiles and amphi­bi­ans to the to­tal an­i­mal bio­mass is negligi­ble, as we dis­cuss in the SI Ap­pendix. Vi­su­al­iza­tion per­formed us­ing the on­line tool bionic-vis. C Bio­mass dis­tributions across dif­fer­ent en­vi­ron­ments and trophic modes. Abso­lute bio­mass is rep­re­sented us­ing a Voro­noi dia­gram, with the area of each cell be­ing propor­tional to the glo­bal bio­mass at each en­vi­ron­ment. Val­ues are based on SI Ap­pen­dix, Ta­ble S23. We de­fine deep sub­sur­face as the ma­rine sub­seafloor se­diment and the oceanic crust, as well as the ter­restrial sub­stratum deeper than 8 m, ex­clud­ing soil. D Frac­tion of the bio­mass of each king­dom con­cen­trated in the ter­res­trial, ma­rine, or deep sub­sur­face en­vi­ron­ment. For fungi and pro­tists, we did not es­ti­mate the bio­mass present in the deep sub­sur­face due to data scarcity. E Dis­tri­bu­tion of bio­mass be­tween pro­duc­ers (au­totrophs, mostly pho­to­syn­thetic) and con­sumers (hetero­trophs with­out deep sub­sur­face) in the ter­res­tri­al and ma­rine en­vi­ron­ments. The size of the bars cor­re­sponds to the quan­tity of bio­mass of each trophic mode. Num­bers are in gi­ga­tons of car­bon. Source. Front­page: Earth from space. Source

The au­thors of this sem­i­nal work based their bio­mass cen­sus of all life on Earth on an analy­sis of hun­dreds of re­cent stud­ies and on gen­er­at­ing es­ti­mates for taxa for which there was no pre­vi­ous rel­e­vant data. There is much in this pa­per for non-mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists and mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists to pon­der upon. First, for the lat­ter, the not so good news. By these es­ti­mates in this pa­per, bac­te­ria do not com­prise half the bios­phere by weight, as per the cher­ished 1998 Whit­man et al. es­ti­mate, but are only about 13% of the to­tal. Plants far out­weigh evey­thing else, com­pris­ing so­me 82% of the to­tal. So much for brag­ging rights… Still, the good news is that al­though bac­te­ria are in sec­ond place by weight, they out­class all the other eu­kary­otes (which are a puny 3% of the to­tal). The weight of all ar­chaea, by the way (why are ar­chaea so of­ten "by the way'd"?) is said to be about one tenth that of the bac­te­ria.

It bears say­ing that the ear­lier es­ti­mate was pretty much on the mark with re­gard to the num­ber and weight of bac­terial cells but un­der­es­ti­mated the cu­mu­la­tive weight of plants. The present au­thors say that their plant cal­cu­la­tions are based on quite ro­bust data. (I guess this may be due in part to the fact that most plants don't move much from place to place.)

There is a for­mi­da­ble amount of work here. It em­braces the mea­sure­ment of the weight (in terms of car­bon) of all prokary­otes, eu­kary­otes, and viruses, in other words, all the en­ti­ties of Bi­ol­ogy. This cen­sus pur­ports that most of the biosphere's mem­bers are found on land, al­though mi­crobes dom­i­nate in the oceans, where about 70% of the bio­mass con­sist of bac­te­ria and pro­tists. The deep sub­sur­face of the oceans, about 15% of the bios­phere, is mainly bac­te­r­ial and ar­chaeal. Keep in mind that this biome is meta­bol­i­cally not very ac­tive, with gen­er­a­tion times of months or pos­si­bly thou­sands of years − not what one usu­ally ex­pects of prokary­otic cells.

Fig­ure 2. The re­la­tion be­tween abun­dance and bio­mass of dif­fer­ent taxa. The to­tal num­ber of in­di­vid­u­als in each taxon is plot­ted against the to­tal bio­mass of the taxon. The er­ror bars re­flect our un­cer­tainty pro­jec­tion of the bio­mass es­ti­mate. Source

The pa­per is rel­a­tively short and highly read­able, the real work to be found in no less than 112 pages of Sup­port­ing In­for­ma­tion. Here are 23 ta­bles of data that pro­vide the method­ol­ogy used to es­ti­mate the global bio­mass of each and es­ti­mates of the un­cer­tain­ties in­volved in the cal­cu­la­tions.

The au­thors point out that more needs to be done. They say: "...for other groups, such as ter­res­trial arthro­pods and pro­tists, quan­ti­ta­tive sam­pling of bio­mass is lim­ited by tech­ni­cal con­straints, and com­pre­hen­sive data are thus lack­ing." Ad­di­tion­ally, they state: "...there are en­tire en­vi­ron­ments for which our knowl­edge is very lim­ited, namely, the deep sub­sur­face en­vi­ron­ments such as deep aquifers and the ocean's crust, which might hold the world largest aquifer. Stud­ies in these en­vi­ron­ments are scarce, mean­ing that our es­ti­mates have par­tic­u­larly high un­cer­tainty ranges and un­known sys­tem­atic bi­ases. Main gaps in our knowl­edge of these en­vi­ron­ments per­tain to the dis­tri­b­u­tion of bio­mass be­tween the aquifer flu­ids and the sur­round­ing rocks and the dis­tri­b­u­tion of bio­mass be­tween dif­fer­ent mi­cro­bial taxa, such as bac­te­ria, ar­chaea, pro­tists, and fungi."

Fig­ure 3. The im­pact of hu­man civ­i­liza­tion on the bio­mass of mam­mals. The bio­mass of wild mam­mals, live­stock (dom­i­nated by cat­tle) and hu­mans be­fore hu­man civ­i­liza­tion and at pre­sent. Val­ues are based on es­ti­mates pre­sented in de­tail in the rel­e­vant sec­tions for hu­mans and live­stock, wild mam­mals and pre-hu­man bio­mass. Source

Op­por­tu­ni­ties for fill­ing gaps and so­lid­i­fy­ing con­clu­sions abound. Thus, the au­thors point out that: "Iden­ti­fy­ing gaps in our knowl­edge could in­di­cate ar­eas for which fur­ther sci­en­tific ex­plo­ration could have the biggest im­pact on our un­der­stand­ing of the bios­phere. As a con­cre­te ex­am­ple, we iden­tify the ra­tio be­tween at­tached to un­attached cells in the deep aquifers as a ma­jor con­trib­u­tor to the un­cer­tain­ties as­so­ci­ated with our es­ti­mate of the bio­mass of bac­te­ria, ar­chaea, and viruses. Im­prov­ing our un­der­stand­ing of this spe­cific pa­ra­me­ter could help us bet­ter con­strain the global bio­masses of en­tire do­mains of life."

The pa­per also at­tempts to as­sess the im­pact of hu­mans on the bios­phere. Hu­mans in toto weight about 3% of all an­i­mals and a bit less than all do­mes­ti­cated an­i­mals (≈0.06 Gt car­bon vs. ≈0.1 Gt car­bon). How­ever, they out­weigh all wild mam­mals by about 10×. The au­thors also at­tempt to eval­u­ate the im­pact of hu­man ac­tiv­i­ties on the bio­mass, but here un­cer­tain­ties in the data tend to cloud the con­clu­sions. How­ever, es­ti­mates sug­gest that hu­man ac­tiv­i­ties have led to a sig­nif­i­cant de­crease in the bio­mass of wild mam­mal, fish, and plants. I would think that this kind of in­for­ma­tion will tran­scend the lim­its of the bi­o­log­i­cal dis­course and be used to ad­dress so­cial and po­lit­i­cal is­sues.

Fig­ure 4. Sum­mary of es­ti­mated to­tal bio­mass and ab­undance of var­i­ous abun­dant tax­o­nomic groups. Val­ues are based on a lit­er­a­ture sur­vey as de­tailed in the SI Ap­pen­dix. Re­ported val­ues have been rounded to the clos­est or­der of mag­nitude in log scale thus re­flect­ing the as­so­ci­ated level of un­cer­tainty. Source

To re­turn to the deeper mean­ing of this com­pre­hen­sive and far-reach­ing ex­plo­ration, I brought up to Yi­non that most of plant bio­mass is made up of in­ac­tive extracellu­lar ma­te­ri­als – think wood in trees, cell walls in the stalks of smaller plants. He agreed but re­minded me that a lot of bac­te­ria are in prac­ti­cally the same meta­bol­i­cally in­ert class (to see how the data stack up with­out such quasi non-liv­ing ma­te­r­ial, go to Fig. S1 in the paper's supple­men­tal ma­te­r­ial). So, it mat­ters how you con­tem­plate the bio­mass and what you mean by its weight. Re­gard­less, these hard-won cal­cu­la­tions will serve as a base­line for fu­ture con­sid­er­a­tions on the im­por­tance of this planet's pas­sen­gers for the well-be­ing of our space­ship.

 

Other Posts