A Bac­te­r­ial Aphro­disiac

by Elio

Sex is kin­dled by many fac­tors, not all an­tic­i­pated. Here is an un­ex­pected one: bac­te­ria make an aphro­disiac. But hold on, we know that bac­te­ria en­gage in un­told inter­actions with eu­kary­otes whose en­vi­ron­ment they share, so this should not be sur­pris­ing. Fact is, the de­fault mode of mi­crobial ex­is­tence is so­cial, so why not sex?

Fig­ure 1. Scan­ning Elec­tron Mi­crograph (SEM) of a S. ro­set­ta cell. Source. Fron­tispiece: S. rosetta mat­ing swarm. Credit: Arielle Woznica, Uni­ver­sity of Cal­i­for­nia, Berke­ley. Source

Be­fore we get into sex, con­sider read­ing an amaz­ing dis­cussion of the width and depth of bac­te­ria net­work­ing with 'higher' an­i­mals by Mc­Fall-Ngai and col­leagues. Note that in the bac­te­r­ial world, soli­tary ex­is­tence is largely lim­ited to Petri dishes in the lab and in­fec­tions. To illus­trate the sur­feit of par­a­digms in this shared ex­is­tence, I ar­bi­trar­ily choose a few that were pre­vi­ously dis­cussed here, the bob­tail squid and Vib­rio fis­cheri, the Wolbachi­as – those nearly uni­ver­sal in­sect sex ra­tio chang­ers – and Pseudo­al­teromonas a bac­terium that stim­u­lates dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion in ma­rine tube­worms. Yet, for all this va­ri­ety of so­cial skills, in­duc­ing sex in a eu­kary­otic or­gan­ism is not a skill typ­i­cally at­trib­uted to bac­te­ria.

So, it came as a sur­prise to peo­ple in the labs of Nicole King and Jon Clardy (the sum­mary of the pa­per starts with: "We serendip­i­tously dis­cov­ered…") that an oth­er­wise or­di­nary ma­rine bac­terium, Vib­rio fis­cheri, in­duces a strong sex­ual be­hav­ior in a sim­ple or­gan­ism, a choanofla­gel­late called Salp­in­goeca rosetta. Since I'm guess­ing that that you don't know much about choanofla­gel­lates, here is what Wikipedia tells us: "Choanofla­gel­lates are a group of free-liv­ing uni­cel­lu­lar and co­lo­ni­al fla­gel­late eu­kary­otes con­sid­ered to be the clos­est liv­ing rel­a­tives of the an­i­mals. Choanofla­gel­la­tes are col­lared fla­gel­lates hav­ing a fun­nel shaped col­lar of in­ter­con­nected mi­crovilli at the base of a fla­gel­lum." They sub­sist from eat­ing bac­te­ria, thus en­joy a close re­la­tion­ship with them. Choanos have served as a pop­u­lar model for study­ing the evo­lu­tion of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar­ity.

Bac­te­ria as Aphro­disiac Sup­pli­ers

Fig­ure 2. Tran­sk­ing­dom Inter­actions Stim­u­late a Eu­kar­yotic Sex­ual Cy­cle The bac­terium V. fis­cheri se­cretes an aphro­disiac, EroS, which stim­u­lates swarm­ing and sexu­al re­pro­duc­tion of the choanofla­gel­late eu­kary­otic mi­crobe S. rosetta. Nu­clei in the hap­loid phase (deno­ted as 1N) prior to mat­ing are col­ored solid blue and green. The two hap­loid cells fuse, re­sult­ing in a diploid cell (de­noted as 2N) af­ter nu­clear fu­sion. Meio­sis and re­com­bi­na­tion then pro­duces hap­loid prog­eny car­ry­ing a ge­netic mix­ture of the parental hap­loids (de­noted as blue and green). (We thank Shelby Priest for her ef­forts in gen­er­at­ing this il­lus­tra­tion). Source

These choanofla­gel­lates look some­thing like mam­malian sperm cells, hav­ing an ovoid body and a long, al­though rather stiff fla­gel­lum. They usu­ally re­pro­duce asex­u­ally, al­though they can be per­suaded, some­what re­luc­tantly, to mate by plac­ing them un­der star­va­tion con­di­tions. But these re­searchers found that the pres­ence of V. fis­cheri in­duces a fren­zied mat­ing be­hav­ior lead­ing to abun­dant cou­pling. This was en­tirely un­ex­pected be­cause, so far at least, bac­te­ria had not been known to di­rectly in­flu­ence sex­ual be­hav­ior in eu­kary­otes. The change in these cells' com­port­ment re­sults, within 30 min­utes, in swarms of a few dozen cells that soon fuse with each other. In keep­ing with typ­i­cal sex­ual re­pro­duc­tion, this re­sults in cell fu­sion, karyo­gamy, meio­sis, and re­combination, the usual steps in sex­ual re­pro­duc­tion. This be­hav­ior could be turned into an as­say that served to guide frac­tion­a­tion of the V. fis­cheri growth medium. A pos­i­tive swarm­ing re­ac­tion was in­duced by as few as 4 x 102 V. fis­cheri cells, which is com­pa­ra­ble to their con­cen­tra­tion in the ocean. The var­i­ous steps in these processes were stud­ied with par­tic­u­lar care, in keep­ing with the in­ter­est of these in­ves­ti­ga­tors in fur­ther de­vel­op­ing the study of the choanofla­gel­lates. The work de­scribed in this pa­per is dealt par­tic­u­larly well in this com­men­tary.

The ac­tive prod­uct that emerged from the frac­tion­a­tion stud­ies of cul­ture su­per­natants of V. fis­cheri turned out to be a se­creted pro­tein of about 90 kDa. The au­thors ap­pro­pri­ately named it EroS for 'ex­tra­cel­lu­lar reg­u­la­tor of sex.' Alone, EroS is suf­fi­cient to elicit the aphro­disiac ef­fect. Ac­cord­ingly, they ob­served the same ef­fects when us­ing het­erol­o­gously ex­pressed EroS in E. coli or pu­ri­fied EroS pro­tein.

What does EroS do?

It turns out that EroS is an en­zyme that hy­drolyzes chon­droitin sul­fate, the gly­can poly­mer made up of glu­cosamine and glu­curonic acid that is found on cell sur­faces and ex­tra­cel­lu­lar ma­tri­ces of an­i­mal tis­sues and is in­volved in cell pro­lif­er­a­tion and dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion. EroS is a pretty typ­i­cal chon­dri­oti­nase and re­sem­bles that in many other or­gan­isms. Here as else­where, chon­droitin sul­fate is co­va­lently linked to pro­teins.

The au­thors be­lieve that struc­tural mod­i­fi­ca­tions of chon­droitin sul­fate by EroS, rather than prod­ucts of en­zyme di­ges­tion, are re­spon­si­ble for ac­ti­vat­ing swarm­ing and mat­ing in S. rosetta. The rea­son is that prod­ucts of hy­drol­y­sis re­leased from pu­ri­fied chon­droitin sul­fate showed no ac­tiv­ity in this as­say.

Fig­ure 3. Scan­ning Elec­tron Mi­cro­graph of a S. rosetta co­lony. Source

Does this mat­ter in na­ture? Pos­si­bly. S. rosetta in­hab­its the same coastal ma­rine habi­tats as V. fis­cheri, so they may en­counter each other fre­quently. How does EroS work? Does it soften the choanofla­gel­late en­ve­lope to fa­cil­i­tate cell fu­sion? This story ca­su­ally re­minds us of sperm cells, which carry sev­eral hy­drolytic en­zymes in their head that are used to dis­solve the tough en­ve­lope of the egg.

Do the cleav­age prod­ucts of EroS act as sig­nal­ing mo­le­cules? Not known as yet. But what's in it for the bac­te­ria? Do the sug­ars aris­ing from its hy­drol­y­sis act as their food? Peut-être, non? Or, when en­gaged in sex, does S. rosetta lose in­ter­est in in­gest­ing these bac­te­ria? But fur­ther, how do the choano cells be­come so ready to mate? How come the mat­ing switch oc­curs so rapidly? These and many other ques­tions await an­swers.

Is this a wide­spread phe­nom­e­non?

The re­searchers note that the pres­ence of the bac­te­ria may gen­er­ally sig­nal that the con­di­tions are ripe for mat­ing. One would ex­pect that other kinds of bac­te­ria and other mat­ing-ori­ented or­gan­isms may in­ter­act in such man­ner and in­deed, the re­searchers show that cer­tain other vib­rios (but not oth­ers) also have anal­o­gous ac­tiv­ity. Given the im­por­tance of sex in na­ture, such in­ter­ac­tions may in­deed be more fre­quent. It may well turn out that this sys­tem will fa­cil­i­tate the study of sim­i­lar phe­nom­ena in other life forms and that bac­te­ria in­deed fa­cil­i­tate so­cial inter­actions in greater and greater num­bers.

 

This pa­per was dis­cussed in the Sep­tem­ber 14 episode of This Week in Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy. Press play to lis­ten now.

 

Other Posts

  • A Bug in a Bug in a Bug

    by Elio — Rat­tling around in­side my head for some time has been the re­ported dis­cov­ery that there are bac­te­ria that live within other bac­te­ria. To me, this is an hon­est-to-good­ness gee-whiz piece of mi­cro­bial lore. Made me won­der why the story had not been fol­lowed up on. Could be be­cause you have…

  • An En­dosym­biont On Its Way To Be­com­ing An Or­ganelle?

    Pic­tures Con­sid­ered #31 by Elio — In­side, the fresh­wa­ter ameba Paulinella chro­matophora car­ries what may be a miss­ing link in an en­dosym­biont be­com­ing an or­ganelle. We dis­cussed this be­fore in some de­tail. Paulinella car­ries within it one or two large sausage-shaped pho­to­syn­thetic en­dosym­bionts that look like cyanobac­te­ria. This endosymbiont's genome is a re­spectable...

  • Play­ing the Light Or­gan Two Ways

    by Elio — Deep within the oceans, sea an­i­mals and bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent bac­te­ria play sym­bi­otic games. Fish, squid, and other an­i­mals that bring light to the dark­ness use it in their quest for food, their search for mates, or the avoid­ance of preda­tors. This is not merely a cu­rios­ity, as seen by the sim­ple fact that...

  • Six to Tango

    by Elio — One genome at a time can be ex­cit­ing, but two even more so. I'm not en­tirely sure why this is, al­though it may ex­plain our fas­ci­na­tion with sex. And what if more than two en­ti­ties were in­volved? What if the in­ti­macy were not just be­tween two in­di­vid­ual or­gan­isms, but be­tween...

  • In the Com­pany of Bac­te­ria: Amoe­bae

    by Christoph — In times long past, highly evolved eu­karyotes, for ex­ample bio­chemists, oc­ca­sio­nal­ly quip­ped that bac­ter­ia were noth­ing more than a bag of en­zymes. Well, from the per­spec­tive of bac­ter­ia, one could easi­ly re­turn the com­pli­ment: eu­kar­y­o­tes, for ex­ample sin­gle-cel­led amoe­bae, are lit­tle more than a...

  • The Planc­to­mycetes, ...

    ...Tricky Gram-neg­a­tives Await­ing Ge­netic Ma­nip­u­la­tion by Marco Alle­mann — Mem­bers of the bac­te­r­ial phy­lum Planc­to­mycetes (click here and here) in­habit a wide va­ri­ety of en­vi­ron­ments through­out the world. What makes them spe­cial is that in the mind of some in­ves­ti­ga­tors they pos­sess a mix of eu­kary­otic and prokary­otic struc­tural at­trib­utes. Now that is some­thing pretty unique and worth…