The Ecol­ogy of Louis Pas­teur

by Elio

Pas­teur is as close to be­ing the fa­ther of our sci­ence as it gets, with Robert Koch a close con­tender. Both made fun­da­men­tal con­tri­bu­tions, best re­mem­bered for their elu­ci­da­tion of the mi­cro­bial ori­gin of in­fec­tious dis­eases. The two came to it from rather dif­fer­ent points of view and the con­trast be­tween them is il­lu­mi­nat­ing. Pas­teur was a chemist, deeply rooted in crys­tal­log­ra­phy and the im­por­tance of chem­i­cal mol­e­cules in all bi­o­log­i­cal trans­ac­tions. Koch was a physi­cian whose Weltan­schau­ung im­pelled him to pro­vide di­ag­no­sis and treat­ment of in­fec­tious dis­eases. In sim­plis­tic terms, Pasteur's Vi­sion du Monde saw bac­te­ria as mem­bers of the bios­phere, Koch's as agents of dis­ease in hu­mans and other an­i­mals. It fol­lows that Koch de­clared pure cul­tures to be the op­er­a­tional stan­dard, whereas Pasteur's drew him to their nat­ural habi­tats. This led to dif­fi­cult in­ter­ac­tions be­tween the two, ex­ac­er­bated by their na­tional ori­gins. A fair de­scrip­tion of their thorny deal­ings can be found in a fine ar­ti­cle by Ag­nès Ull­mann.

René Du­bos, photo Mau­reen Thorpe. Source

For about the first half of the 20th cen­tury, the study of bac­te­ria was largely car­ried out us­ing lab­o­ra­tory me­dia and on pure cul­tures. One could say that Koch pre­vailed. This de­spite nearly as­ton­ish­ing con­tri­bu­tions to mi­cro­bial ecol­ogy by fig­ures like Wino­grad­sky and Bei­jer­inck, to name just two. But for a long time, the two ap­proaches re­mained quite dis­tinct. Two cul­tures, if you per­mit the pun. How­ever, the last 50 or so years are char­ac­ter­ized by a blend­ing of the two at­ti­tudes. Nowa­days, path­o­genic mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy is con­sid­ered to be a branch of mi­cro­bial ecol­ogy and lab­o­ra­tory cul­tures a use­ful and of­ten es­sen­tial ar­ti­fact, but an ar­ti­fact nev­er­the­less. Mod­ern tech­ni­ques have al­lowed to study pathogens in their hosts and en­vi­ron­men­tal mi­crobes in their en­vi­ron­ment. No­tice how close the two fields have got­ten. Both Pas­teur and Koch won their bat­tles.

In this spirit, it is use­ful to re-visit Pasteur's think­ing. For­tu­nately, we have an il­lu­mi­nat­ing ar­ti­cle by René Du­bos, who car­ried the torch of the en­vi­ron­men­tal ap­proach into the study of in­fec­tion. I found this writ­ing highly en­light­en­ing and hope that you will too.

 

Other Posts