When the Mi­crobe Hits the Metal

by Leo Baum­gart

Some heavy met­als share a long his­tory with mi­crobes. Many of the meta­bolic processes that sus­tain life are be­lieved to have orig­i­nated from spon­ta­neous re­ac­tions in­volv­ing met­als present in the early Earth. Our mi­cro­bial an­ces­tors fig­ured out quickly how to use those metal cat­a­lysts to gen­er­ate en­ergy and make cel­lu­lar com­po­nents. And so cat­alytic cen­ters were in­cor­po­rated into pro­teins to make a wide va­ri­ety of metal-con­tain­ing en­zymes and di­ver­sify their ac­tiv­i­ties. Some of those en­zymes were passed down to us and have be­come in­te­gral to our func­tion­ing. They are the rea­son why we, like mi­crobes, re­quire some met­als as mi­cronu­tri­ents in our diet: zinc, cop­per, se­le­nium, molyb­de­num, and cobalt (as vi­t­a­min B12).

Fig­ure 1. The prism shaped green crys­tals of Tor­ber­nite form as sec­ondary de­posits in granitic rocks. They form through a com­plex re­ac­tion be­tween phos­pho­rous, cop­per, wa­ter and ura­nium. Source

There are some heavy met­als, how­ever, that share lit­tle of our an­ces­tral his­tory. There is no known bi­o­log­i­cal role for heavy met­als such as cad­mium, ar­senic, lead, chromium, mer­cury, and ura­nium. Not sur­pris­ingly, they tend to be toxic to hu­mans. These heavy met­als are nat­u­rally present in rocks and min­er­als, but the in­sol­u­ble na­ture of the metal for­ma­tions keeps them tightly bound in the Earth's crust and min­i­mize their bioavail­abil­ity. As a re­sult, we rarely come into con­tact with high con­cen­tra­tions of them. How­ever, an­thro­pogenic ac­tiv­i­ties in the last cen­turies have re­leased these met­als into the en­vi­ron­ment in forms that are more bioavail­able (e.g., sol­u­ble in wa­ter). Dur­ing the in­dus­trial rev­o­lu­tion hu­mans be­gan ex­tract­ing these met­als in large-scale quan­ti­ties, un­aware at the time of the dan­gers of metal ex­po­sure. Min­ing and fac­tory runoffs con­tain­ing high con­cen­tra­tions of these heavy met­als were re­leased di­rectly into the sur­round­ing wa­ter­ways. A sad ex­am­ple of the un­con­trolled re­lease of toxic met­als in the en­vi­ron­ment comes from the lead in­dus­try:  the wide­spread use of tetraethyl lead (TEL) as a gaso­line ad­di­tive for cars from the 1920s to the 1970s re­sulted in the mas­sive re­lease of lead to the at­mos­phere, which can still be de­tected in many air and road­side sam­ples to­day.

Para­dox­i­cally, the acute toxic ef­fects of large amounts of heavy met­als on hu­mans have been doc­u­mented since the time of the Greeks. Ar­senic — lack­ing color, odor or taste — was con­sid­ered the king of poi­sons and was a fa­vorite among the Ro­mans and through­out the Mid­dle Ages! But the toxic ef­fect of heavy met­als on in­di­vid­ual cells was un­known un­til in 1893 Karl Wil­helm von Nägeli ob­served how even rel­a­tively small quan­ti­ties of heavy met­als were poi­so­nous to many mi­crobes. He re­ferred to the microbe's re­sponse to the toxic metal as the oligo­dy­namic ef­fect. These stud­ies had enor­mous im­pli­ca­tion on san­i­ta­tion as they led to the use of heavy met­als as an­timi­cro­bials. Cop­per sur­faces con­tin­u­ously dis­in­fect them­selves and are the ma­te­r­ial of choice in hos­pi­tals to pre­vent the spread of dis­ease. Sil­ver is still used in creams to pre­vent in­fec­tion in the wounds of burn pa­tients, al­though some more re­cent re­search has shown that it may be in­ef­fec­tive and equally toxic to in­di­vid­ual hu­man cells as to bac­te­ria.

Once in­side cells, heavy metal ions bind to the cat­alytic sites of en­zymes and other vi­tal cel­lu­lar com­po­nents such as DNA, RNA, as well as struc­tural pro­teins, which then de­na­ture and ag­gre­gate. They can also cause dam­age from the out­side of the cells, by bind­ing to com­po­nents of the cell en­ve­lope. Al­though the ex­act mech­a­nism of tox­i­c­ity of heavy met­als is still poorly un­der­stood, they are all known to in­ter­fere with cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism at some level. Un­like other en­vi­ron­men­tal pol­lu­tants such as pe­tro­leum, pes­ti­cides, or cyanide, heavy met­als can­not be bro­ken down into less toxic de­riv­a­tives. They are of­ten found in pol­luted en­vi­ron­ments bound to car­bon com­pounds (organometallics), but even when sep­a­rated from the or­ganic mol­e­cules, the met­als re­main toxic in their el­e­men­tal forms.

Un­like us, mi­crobes can re­spond to en­vi­ron­men­tal changes fast and have evolved mech­a­nisms to com­bat the tox­i­c­ity of heavy met­als. Some soil bac­te­ria found deep be­neath the Earth's sur­face have likely been liv­ing along­side heavy met­als for mil­len­nia, and re­sis­tant mi­cro­bial pop­u­la­tions have sprung up even in newly-con­t­a­m­i­nated en­vi­ron­ments. The 250 years that have passed since the be­gin­ning of the in­dus­trial rev­o­lu­tion pro­vides plenty of time for mi­crobes to adapt and de­velop cel­lu­lar de­fenses against heavy met­als. Some mi­crobes have even fig­ured out how to uti­lize these "toxic" heavy met­als as nu­tri­ents or as elec­tron ac­cep­tors. In the Great Lakes, some al­gae use cad­mium in place of zinc when zinc con­cen­tra­tions are low. Sev­eral species of bac­te­ria that can use ar­senic for res­pi­ra­tion have been iden­ti­fied (ar­senic re­duc­ers) and oth­ers have evolved me­tab­o­lism to re-ox­i­dize re­duced ar­senic forms (ar­senic ox­i­diz­ers). Some bac­te­ria can also respire ura­nium, and the re­dox cy­cling of ura­nium has been re­ported for both nat­ural and an­thro­pogenic en­vi­ron­ments con­tain­ing the ra­dionu­clide.

Fig­ure 2. Phy­lo­ge­netic tree of the MerR fam­ily of heavy-metal sen­sor pro­teins, with the col­ors in­di­cat­ing the metal each sub-group of re­lated pro­teins re­sponds to. Source

Metal re­sis­tance by bac­te­ria could of­fer great in­sights into strate­gies to pre­vent or treat metal poi­son­ing in hu­mans. For some met­als, such as ar­senic, cad­mium, and cop­per, the main mode of re­sis­tance is by ac­tive ef­flux in­volv­ing pro­tein trans­porters that pump the met­als out of the cell faster than they can dif­fuse back in. An­other strat­egy is to bind up and se­quester the metal ions be­fore they can cause dam­age in­side the cell. The cyanobac­terium Syne­chococ­cus, for ex­am­ple, se­cretes a met­al­loth­ionein called SmtA in re­sponse to high con­cen­tra­tions of zinc. Each met­al­loth­ionein mol­e­cule can bind up to four zinc ions, ef­fec­tively chelat­ing the metal be­fore it can per­me­ate the cell. Some mi­crobes ex­ploit a unique prop­erty of mer­cury to ef­fec­tively re­move it from their en­vi­ron­ments: in its el­e­men­tal state, Hg(0), mer­cury is not only less toxic, it is also volatile. These bac­te­ria ac­tively scav­enge and im­port mer­cury in its Hg(II) form from their en­vi­ron­ment us­ing a set of mer­cury-bind­ing pro­teins and mer­cury ion im­porters. Once in­side the cell, the toxic Hg(II) is re­duced to Hg(0), which, be­ing a gas, dif­fuses out of the cell freely.

Cupri­avidus met­al­lidu­rans, an es­pe­cially spir­ited bac­terium fea­tured pre­vi­ously in this blog X for its abil­ity to pre­cip­i­tate gold, has man­aged to col­lect at least 25 heavy metal re­sis­tance loci on its genome and plas­mids. Like its name sug­gests ("metal-en­dur­ing ea­ger for cop­per"), this tiny dare­devil can grow in mil­limo­lar con­cen­tra­tions of 20 dif­fer­ent heavy met­als and even uses chemo­taxis to move to­wards cad­mium-rich en­vi­ron­ments, pre­sum­ably to es­cape com­pe­ti­tion of other bac­te­ria. Sounds ideal for biore­me­di­a­tion!

To help reg­u­late the ma­chin­ery in­volved in metal re­sis­tance, bac­te­ria of­ten con­fine the nec­es­sary genes to oper­ons that rely on a metal-sens­ing tran­scrip­tion fac­tor for ex­pres­sion. This al­lows bac­te­ria to ex­pend en­ergy to fight off heavy met­als only when they are around. There are two large fam­i­lies of metal sen­sor pro­teins widely dis­trib­uted through­out bac­te­r­ial genomes, plas­mids, and trans­pos­able el­e­ments: the MerR and ArsR pro­tein fam­i­lies, named for the met­als — mer­cury and ar­senic, re­spec­tively — they sense. Since then, a va­ri­ety of ho­mo­logues have been dis­cov­ered that are able to specif­i­cally bind to a metal and turn on the cor­re­spond­ing cel­lu­lar detox­i­fi­ca­tion ma­chin­ery. Sci­en­tists are ge­net­i­cally en­gi­neer­ing these metal-in­ducible oper­ons to con­struct bac­te­r­ial biosen­sors that emit light in re­sponse to heavy metal pol­lu­tion. A so­phis­ti­cated syn­thetic bi­ol­ogy ap­proach has also been taken to de­tect heavy met­als in wa­ter sup­plies us­ing bac­te­ria im­mo­bi­lized in mi­croflu­idic chips, which was the sub­ject of a re­cent blog post. Biosen­sors have the po­ten­tial to be both cost-ef­fec­tive and sen­si­tive, achiev­ing de­tec­tion lim­its down to nanomo­lar con­cen­tra­tions.

Be­sides mak­ing biosen­sors, bac­te­r­ial heavy metal re­sis­tance sys­tems have found an­other ap­pli­ca­tion in biore­me­di­a­tion. En­vi­ron­ments im­pacted by metal con­t­a­m­i­na­tion are of­ten vast and, as a re­sult, de­con­t­a­m­i­na­tion ap­proaches are of­ten pro­hib­i­tively ex­pen­sive. Sadly, our so­lu­tion has usu­ally been to fence off the area and leave the heavy met­als be­hind. Biore­me­di­a­tion with mi­crobes presents a more re­al­is­tic al­ter­na­tive to con­ven­tional cleanup meth­ods, as it re­lies on the in situ stim­u­la­tion of the ac­tiv­i­ties of the na­tive mi­cro­bial pop­u­la­tion to pre­vent the spread of the most toxic form of the con­t­a­m­i­nant. There have been en­cour­ag­ing lab­o­ra­tory stud­ies on the use of bac­te­ria for mer­cury biore­me­di­a­tion by re­duc­ing it to its volatile and less toxic metal­lic form, Hg(0). How­ever, it is im­por­tant to un­der­stand how the en­vi­ron­men­tal bac­te­ria will re­spond to the stim­u­la­tion. If stim­u­lated, some bac­te­ria can con­vert mer­cury to methylmer­cury, an even more toxic form of mer­cury that spreads rapidly in the food chain. This is the chem­i­cal re­spon­si­ble for Mi­na­mata dis­ease, suf­fered by the in­hab­i­tants of Mi­na­mata Bay, Japan, which was se­verely pol­luted through the mid-1900s as a re­sult of fac­tory runoff. Methylmer­cury be­came con­cen­trated in fish by the process of bioam­pli­fi­ca­tion and as a re­sult killed al­most 2,000 peo­ple and poi­soned many more. Luck­ily, al­though in this case they may be part of the prob­lem, mi­crobes might have the an­swer here too. Ex­press­ing an organomer­cury lyase gene from the mer­cury re­sis­tance operon gives bac­te­ria the abil­ity to cleave car­bon-mer­cury bonds and ex­pands the biore­me­di­a­tion tar­gets to in­clude methylmer­cury. This en­zy­matic re­duc­tion ap­proach to mer­cury de­con­t­a­m­i­na­tion would still re­sult in the re­lease of el­e­men­tal mer­cury into the at­mos­phere, which is why it may be prefer­able to ex­press a trans­genic met­al­loth­ionein to pro­mote se­ques­tra­tion of mer­cury in­side cells.

The pro­duc­tion of nu­clear weapons dur­ing the Cold War re­sulted in mul­ti­ple ar­eas of ura­nium con­t­a­m­i­na­tion in the Unites States. Even among the less ra­dioac­tive iso­topes of ura­nium, ox­i­dized uranium(VI) is of par­tic­u­lar con­cern be­cause of its sol­u­bil­ity in wa­ter and sub­se­quent dis­per­sal. In one study at such a ura­nium-con­t­a­m­i­nated site, ac­etate in­jec­tion into the sub­sur­face stim­u­lated the growth of the nat­ural Geobac­ter bac­te­ria, which re­duced the sol­u­ble uranium(VI) to the less sol­u­ble uranium(IV). For nu­clear waste sites con­t­a­m­i­nated with both ura­nium and mer­cury, Deinococ­cus ra­dio­du­rans was en­gi­neered to ex­press a mer­cury re­sis­tance operon and was able to detox­ify mer­cury even dur­ing ex­po­sure to high lev­els of ra­di­a­tion. Bac­te­r­ial re­moval of heavy met­als from wa­ter by en­zy­matic con­ver­sion to less sol­u­ble forms has also been demon­strated for ar­senic and chromium. In the case of ar­senic, the ox­i­dized As(V) form is less wa­ter sol­u­ble. Ar­senic ox­i­diz­ing bac­te­ria have been em­ployed as part of wa­ter fil­tra­tion sys­tems, be­cause once ar­senic is ox­i­dized, it can eas­ily be fil­tered out. Sim­i­larly, chromium can be ef­fi­ciently fil­tered af­ter re­duc­tion of Cr(VI) to the in­sol­u­ble Cr(III) by sul­fate-re­duc­ing bac­te­ria. These are just some of the many ways in which the mech­a­nisms evolved by mi­crobes to trans­form met­als can be used for our ben­e­fit. For­tu­nately for us, evo­lu­tion has mas­tered di­verse metal-re­sis­tance sys­tems in rel­a­tively short time scales. Now it's up to us to fig­ure out how use these nat­ural sys­tems and re­pro­gram mi­crobes to clean up some of our biggest messes.

 

Leo Baumgart

Leo Baum­gart is a PhD stu­dent in the lab­o­ra­tory of Dr. Jeff Hasty at the Uni­ver­sity of Cal­i­for­nia at San Diego.

 

Other Posts

  • Min­ing the Pro­teome

    by Merry Youle — If you had oo­dles of pro­teomes at your dis­posal, what sorts of ques­tions might you ask? A group of Pol­ish in­ves­ti­ga­tors clas­si­fied the pro­teins in 1784 (!) pro­teomes based on their iso­elec­tric point and found some in­ter­est­ing cor­re­la­tions...

  • Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #13

    Ni­tro­gen-fix­ing bac­te­ria in the root nod­ules of legumes dif­fer­en­ti­ate into bac­teroids, ter­mi­nal cells in­ca­pable of re­pro­duc­tion. The nod­ules con­tain a few dor­mant bac­te­r­ial cells that can pro­lif­er­ate upon re­lease from the plant...

  • One Hun­dred Mil­lion Year Old Polyamines

    Who Would Have Thought? by Elio — Pa­le­on­tol­o­gists are greatly helped in their work by find­ing or­ganic com­pounds that have been pre­served in fos­sils through the ages. Most use­ful among these are the amaz­ingly sta­ble poly­cyclic ter­penoid lipids, in par­tic­u­lar the bac­te­r­ial hopanoids (Click here and here), that are present in fos­sils about 2.4 bil­lion years…

  • SIMPLIFY Sci­ence Writ­ing

    by Roberto — Writ­ing is an es­sen­tial part of all sci­en­tific en­deav­ors. Yet it is rare to find a sci­en­tist that finds it easy, not to men­tion joy­ful. I am not much dif­fer­ent. But af­ter many years at it, I have learned to take cer­tain steps that make the process at least less daunt­ing, even sim­ple.