Mi­crobe, En­zyme or Min­eral?

A Rid­dle in the Soil


This piece was first pub­lished on the author's per­sonal blog, The Lonely Spore. (no longer ac­tive in 2023)

by Mad­die Stone

When most peo­ple look at soil, they just see dirt. When I look at soil, I see bil­lions of mi­croor­gan­isms crawl­ing atop one an­other, con­sum­ing the dead in a feast­ing frenzy that stops for noth­ing save a deep freeze. I see mi­crobes and their en­zymes, the di­ges­tive juices that break down, trans­form and re­lease all the en­ergy tied up in our planet's ter­res­trial ecosys­tems.

Fig­ure 1. Soil is the most mi­cro­bially di­verse habi­tat on Earth, and con­tains twice as much car­bon as liv­ing plants and the at­mos­phere com­bined. Source

Through their re­mark­able abil­ity to de­com­pose nearly any­thing that comes their way, soil mi­crobes col­lec­tively rep­re­sent a plan­e­tary re­cy­cling fac­tory, one that takes car­bon from dead or­ganic mat­ter back to the at­mos­phere as CO2. Soils "ex­hale" CO2 for the same rea­son you and I do. We've eaten some­thing, bro­ken down the car­bon bonds that hold it to­gether, and ex­tracted all the en­ergy that we could. CO2 is the generic waste prod­uct of cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism, the last bit of car­bon that our own meta­bolic in­ef­fi­ciency pre­cludes us from us­ing. Ecol­o­gists have coined the term soil res­pi­ra­tion to de­scribe the col­lec­tive ex­hal­ing of mi­cro­bial car­bon de­com­po­si­tion.

Fig­ure 2. Scan­ning elec­tron mi­cro­scope im­age of iron ox­i­diz­ing bac­te­ria Aci­dovo­rax (yel­low) sp. BoFeN1, en­crusted in iron min­er­als. Mi­crobes, en­zymes and min­er­als are of­ten in­ti­mately as­so­ci­ated in soils, mak­ing it dif­fi­cult to sep­a­rate out their con­tri­bu­tions to bio­chem­i­cal re­ac­tions. Source

Breath­ing mat­ters, but in soil, it's com­pli­cated

This earthly ex­hal­ing is an event of pro­found sig­nif­i­cance to the bios­phere. It dic­tates how much car­bon re­mains in soil, and how much re­turns to the at­mos­phere, where it acts as a heat-trap­ping green­house gas that helps reg­u­late Earth's cli­mate. Bio­geo­chemists are work­ing to un­der­stand how mi­crobes con­tribute to the global ex­ha­la­tion of Earth's soils. What makes them breathe slower? Faster? How does this in­flu­ence the dis­tri­b­u­tion of car­bon across a for­est? Across the planet? Over a year's time? A cen­tury? Un­der­stand­ing what makes soil mi­crobes breathe will al­low sci­en­tists to make bet­ter pre­dic­tions about our planet's fu­ture. How will hu­man dis­tur­bances, like those elic­it­ing cli­mate change, ur­ban­iza­tion, or fer­til­iza­tion af­fect this es­sen­tial path­way?

In or­der to pre­dict why soils ex­hale, we need to first un­der­stand who or what is break­ing down car­bon. As read­ers of this blog know, when you re­ally get down into the dirt, things get com­pli­cated. En­zymes me­di­ate nearly every step in soil car­bon de­com­po­si­tion. Some of these en­zymes re­side in­side liv­ing mi­crobes, but many are re­leased out­side the cell, into the en­vi­ron­ment. These ex­oen­zymes act as in­de­pen­dent en­ti­ties from their mi­cro­bial pro­duc­ers. This means that ex­oen­zymes can—and of­ten do—persist in soil long af­ter their mi­cro­bial par­ent dies. By chem­i­cally as­so­ci­at­ing with soil min­er­als, ex­oen­zymes can form sta­ble com­plexes that re­sist drought, pH changes, even at­tack and degra­da­tion by other en­zymes. And fi­nally, to make mat­ters even more com­pli­cated, some car­bon de­com­po­si­tion oc­curs by en­tirely abi­otic processes. Cer­tain soil min­er­als, such as iron ox­ides, strip elec­trons from or­ganic mat­ter by ox­i­da­tion. Ox­i­da­tion is im­por­tant for the break­down of large, com­plex mol­e­cules such as lignin, the pri­mary build­ing block of wood.

Ex­oen­zymes and soil mi­crobes rep­re­sent two dif­fer­ent pieces of the de­com­po­si­tion puz­zle, abi­otic car­bon ox­i­da­tion a third. Since these dif­fer­ent as­pects of de­com­po­si­tion may re­spond dif­fer­ently to en­vi­ron­men­tal change, we'd like a way of sep­a­rately mea­sur­ing their con­tri­bu­tions to the soil car­bon cy­cle. But sep­a­rat­ing ex­oen­zymes, mi­crobes and min­er­als, all of which not only co­ex­ist within nanome­ters of each other, but are of­ten chem­i­cally bonded, is no easy task. Soil mi­cro­bial ecol­o­gists have long rec­og­nized, some­times ac­knowl­edged, but largely ig­nored our in­abil­ity to sep­a­rate the liv­ing from the non-liv­ing in soil car­bon de­com­po­si­tion.

Read­ers who are fa­mil­iar with mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy and bio­chem­istry lab­o­ra­tory re­search may be sur­prised by the sim­ple na­ture of the ques­tions bio­geo­chemists are tack­ling in soils. It is im­por­tant to keep in mind that lab­o­ra­tory stud­ies rep­re­sent a con­trolled and sim­pli­fied en­vi­ron­ment, while soils are one of the most spa­tially and tem­po­rally com­plex en­vi­ron­ments on Earth. Even foun­da­tional as­pects of soils re­search, such as de­ter­min­ing what con­sti­tutes a rep­re­sen­ta­tive soil sam­ple, have no easy an­swer. An­swer­ing these ques­tions at all re­quires a deep un­der­stand­ing of the rel­e­vant bi­o­log­i­cal, chem­i­cal and en­vi­ron­men­tal pa­ra­me­ters, and the mech­a­nisms through which they in­ter­act.

Sep­a­rat­ing the liv­ing and the dead

At last, we may have a roadmap for solv­ing a prob­lem that has eluded mi­cro­bial ecol­o­gists for years. Last month, a group of re­searchers led by Joshua Schimel pub­lished the first study that rig­or­ously at­tempts to sep­a­rate cel­lu­lar car­bon me­tab­o­lism from ex­oen­zyme ac­tiv­ity in soils.

To sep­a­rate cel­lu­lar from ex­tra­cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism in soil, the re­searchers rec­og­nized the need for a method that dis­ables liv­ing cells while leav­ing ex­oen­zymes in­tact. This is no triv­ial prob­lem. Heat can be used to ster­il­ize soil, but it can also dis­rupt ex­oen­zyme ac­tiv­ity and ac­cel­er­ate the break­down of other or­ganic com­pounds. Toxic chem­i­cals like sodium azide can in­hibit most mi­cro­bial ac­tiv­ity, but a small frac­tion of mi­crobes de­velop re­sis­tance to them.

Two po­ten­tially use­ful meth­ods the re­searchers tested are chlo­ro­form fu­mi­ga­tion and gamma ir­ra­di­a­tion. Chlo­ro­form, a non­po­lar and hy­dropho­bic mol­e­cule, is chem­i­cally in­ert but nonethe­less deadly. Chlo­ro­form buries it­self in the lipid bi­layer of cell mem­branes, caus­ing them to be­come dis­or­ga­nized, and even­tu­ally rup­ture. How­ever, some ex­oen­zymes may be af­fected by it. Gamma ra­di­a­tion is pow­er­ful ion­iz­ing ra­di­a­tion that kills cells by caus­ing dou­ble stranded breaks in their DNA and is fre­quently used to ster­il­ize food and med­ical equip­ment. Very few stud­ies have mea­sured the ef­fect of gamma ra­di­a­tion on ex­oen­zymes. The re­searchers com­pared the ef­fi­cacy of these to tech­niques to au­to­clav­ing, the more tra­di­tional ster­il­iza­tion method in which a sam­ple is sub­jected to high heat.

The re­searchers col­lected sam­ples of soils from a Cal­i­for­nia grass­land and ster­il­ized them us­ing each of these three meth­ods. They then tested the re­sponse of cel­lu­lar and ex­tra­cel­lu­lar soil car­bon me­tab­o­lism. They also eval­u­ated vi­able cell counts through cul­tur­ing and us­ing a flu­o­res­cent vi­tal stain to dis­tin­guish liv­ing from dead cells.

To de­ter­mine the ex­tent of ex­tra­cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism, the sci­en­tists mea­sured the ac­tiv­ity of eight ex­oen­zymes pro­duced by a wide range of soil mi­croor­gan­isms. These en­zymes de­grade com­mon com­po­nents of soil or­ganic mat­ter (lignin, cel­lu­lose, chitin and pro­teins). They in­cluded six hy­dro­lases and two ox­i­dases. Hy­dro­lases like beta-glu­cosi­dase are im­por­tant for de­grad­ing mol­e­cules with pre­dictable, re­peat­ing struc­tures, such as cel­lu­lose. Ox­i­dases play a cen­tral role in break­ing down larger, more com­plex struc­tures, sim­i­larly to abi­otic ox­i­da­tion.

To eval­u­ate cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism, the re­searchers used a tech­nique called "sub­strate in­duced res­pi­ra­tion" (SIR). SIR in­volves adding a small mol­e­cule (typ­i­cally an amino acid or glu­cose) that cells can me­tab­o­lize com­pletely, and mea­sur­ing the CO2 re­leased. The CO2 gen­er­ated from an SIR ex­per­i­ment in­di­cates the meta­bolic po­ten­tial of the live cells in a sam­ple.

Fig­ure 3. Re­sponse of soil hy­drolytic en­zymes to soil ster­il­iza­tion tech­niques. Source

They found that chlo­ro­form and gamma ir­ra­di­a­tion both led to a 1,000 fold re­duc­tion in the num­ber of liv­ing cells. Au­to­clav­ing was a more pow­er­ful ster­il­iza­tion tech­nique, re­duc­ing the num­ber of live cells by ap­prox­i­mately 100,000 fold. Most ex­oen­zyme ac­tiv­i­ties were only mod­estly re­duced by chlo­ro­form treat­ment or gamma ir­ra­di­a­tion (Fig­ure 3). How­ever, ster­il­iza­tion did re­duce the ac­tiv­ity of al­pha-glu­cosi­dase and beta-xy­losi­dase by ap­prox­i­mately 75%. Al­pha-glu­cosi­dase and beta-xy­losi­dase also had the low­est ac­tiv­ity in non-ster­il­ized soils. The au­thors ob­served that ster­il­iza­tion elim­i­nated a rel­a­tively con­stant amount of ac­tiv­ity across all en­zymes. They spec­u­late this con­stant re­duc­tion af­fected low-ac­tiv­ity en­zymes pro­por­tion­ally more.

From these ini­tial find­ings, what can we con­clude? Both chlo­ro­form and gamma ra­di­a­tion ef­fec­tively ster­il­izes soils (if we can ac­cept the fact that a few hardy spores prob­a­bly re­sist these treat­ments). Both treat­ments also keep ex­oen­zyme ac­tiv­ity in­tact. A few caveats here and there, but by and large both tech­niques ap­pear promis­ing.

But what about cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism? Did ster­il­iza­tion suc­cess­fully elim­i­nate it as well? Your first re­ac­tion might be that this is a silly ques­tion. If we're killing all liv­ing cells, we must also be killing cel­lu­lar ac­tiv­ity, right? That's at least what the re­searchers ini­tially thought.

Fig­ure 4. Re­sponse of soil ox­ida­tive en­zymes to soil ster­il­iza­tion tech­niques. Source

The SIR re­sults tell a dif­fer­ent story. The in­ves­ti­ga­tors added a num­ber of dif­fer­ent sim­ple car­bon sub­strates, all of which are bro­ken down dur­ing ba­sic cel­lu­lar meta­bolic processes like gly­col­y­sis and the TCA cy­cle. Fol­low­ing ster­il­iza­tion, res­pi­ra­tion from glu­cose and amino acid sub­strates was halted. How­ever, res­pi­ra­tion from TCA-cy­cle sub­strates, in­clud­ing pyru­vate, cit­rate and ke­tog­lu­tarate, was re­duced but not elim­i­nated (Fig­ure 5). How could dead cells con­tinue respir­ing? The au­thors spec­u­late that cer­tain de­hy­dro­ge­nases, en­zymes that break down TCA cy­cle-sub­strates, are able con­tinue func­tion­ing out­side the con­trolled en­vi­ron­ment of the cell. This find­ing was un­ex­pected. The TCA cy­cle is con­sid­ered to be com­pletely cel­lu­lar, re­quir­ing spe­cific elec­tron car­ri­ers such as NAD+ and re­dox gra­di­ents main­tained in the cell. Find­ing ex­tra­cel­lu­lar TCA-cy­cle en­zyme ac­tiv­ity calls this as­sump­tion into ques­tion, fur­ther blur­ring the line be­tween mi­cro­bial me­tab­o­lism and en­vi­ron­men­tal me­tab­o­lism.

An­other sur­prise came from the ox­i­dases. While all hy­drolytic en­zymes were killed by high heat in the au­to­clav­ing treat­ment, ox­ida­tive re­ac­tions per­sisted, and in some cases even in­creased (Fig­ure 4). The au­thors spec­u­late the ox­ida­tive ac­tiv­ity they mea­sured in au­to­claved soil is the re­sult of abi­otic processes, sup­port­ing the no­tion that a large amount of ox­ida­tive de­com­po­si­tion in soils can be caused by min­eral catal­y­sis.

Fig­ure 5. Re­sponses of sub­strate-in­duced res­pi­ra­tion to ster­il­iza­tion tech­niques. Source

Taken as a whole, this study finds both chlo­ro­form fu­mi­ga­tion and gamma ir­ra­di­a­tion to be promis­ing meth­ods for dis­tin­guish­ing be­tween cel­lu­lar and ex­tra­cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism. Some re­fine­ments are cer­tainly needed—finding a way to sep­a­rate liv­ing from non-liv­ing ox­i­da­tion, for in­stance. But both meth­ods al­ready promise to un­ravel new mech­a­nisms for mi­cro­bial car­bon me­tab­o­lism, as high­lighted by the find­ing that some TCA-cy­cle en­zymes can per­sist af­ter cell death. Now in­ves­ti­ga­tors can start us­ing these ster­il­iza­tion treat­ments to mea­sure the life­time of ex­oen­zymes in the en­vi­ron­ment. Right now we can only guess at how long ex­oen­zymes stick around once they're pro­duced. Un­der­stand­ing the long-term per­sis­tence of these en­zymes in the en­vi­ron­ment will help us to bet­ter gauge the ca­pac­ity of soils—even in the ab­sence of liv­ing cells—to con­tinue di­gest­ing the planet's car­bon.

 

Ref­er­ence

Blank­in­ship J, Be­cerra C, Scha­ef­fer S, Schimel J (2014). Sep­a­rat­ing cel­lu­lar me­tab­o­lism from ex­oen­zyme ac­tiv­ity in soil or­ganic mat­ter de­com­po­si­tion Soil Bi­ol­ogy and Bio­chem­istry, 71, 68–75. DOI 10.1016/j.soilbio.2014.01.010

 

Maddie Stone

Mad­die Stone is a PhD can­di­date at the Uni­ver­sity of Penn­syl­va­nia study­ing soil car­bon biogeo­­che­shy;mistry. She is an avid sci­ence blog­ger, cov­er­ing news­wor­thy mi­crobes from across the world at lonelyspore.com. For mi­crobe tweets and more sci­ence news, fol­low her on twit­ter @themadstone.

 

Other Posts

  • Tak­ing Bugs Out For a Spin

    by Linh Truong and Sha­bana Din — Mi­crobes are the most ro­bust of all life forms in­hab­it­ing our planet. Their abil­ity to pro­lif­er­ate in ex­treme tem­per­a­tures, pH, pres­sure, and ra­di­a­tion is well doc­u­mented. They not only with­stand but grow at phys­i­cal ex­tremes, which makes us won­der about the phys­i­cal bounds for life not only on our planet…

  • On Shape

    by Manuel Sánchez — If there is some­thing that draws at­ten­tion to the study of eu­kary­otes it is the enor­mous di­ver­sity of their mor­phol­ogy, from the largest se­quoias to the small­est ra­di­o­laria. Prokary­otes, on the other hand, seem rather sim­ple and bor­ing. If you open page 109 of the 7th edi­tion of Mur­ray, Rosen­thal, and Phaller's "Med­ical Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy" you will find...

  • Ar­chaeal Web

    by Elio — Deep sea hy­drother­mal vents are char­ac­ter­ized by steep phys­i­cal and chem­i­cal gra­di­ents and by the pres­ence of un­usual and fas­ci­nat­ing life forms. Var­ied or­gan­isms grow there: gi­ant tube worms that ex­ploit the me­tab­o­lism of sul­fide-ox­i­diz­ing bac­te­ria, clams, crabs, shrimps, and more. These like their wa­ter tepid. But some ar­chaea pre­fer...

  • Planc­to­mycetes: The Far Out Bugs

    by Jen­nifer Gutier­rez, Sab­rina Per­rino, Ka­lyn Stern, Mark Thever — As first year grad­u­ate stu­dents in mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy, we are ac­cus­tomed to mi­cro­bial sur­prises, learn­ing again and again how dif­fer­ent and ex­cit­ing bac­te­ria can be. How­ever, it is fair to say that we were not en­tirely pre­pared for the Planc­to­mycetes─ bac­te­ria that di­vide by bud­ding, have no pep­ti­do­gly­can, and pos­sess a unique and per­plex­ing body plan.