Weath­er­ing the Storm …the Ar­chaeal Way

by Mike Manzella

Cum grano salis

Our un­der­stand­ing of mi­cro­bial life is greatly bi­ased by our nar­row fo­cus on mi­crobes as they grow in the lab­o­ra­tory. Yet, as dis­cussed pre­vi­ously in this blog, mi­crobes can per­sist in var­i­ous dor­mant forms for ex­tended pe­ri­ods of time. Sporu­la­tion (from the Greek "spora" or seed) is per­haps the best-known strat­egy for dor­mancy, a tac­tic used by some bac­te­ria to tran­scend un­fa­vor­able con­di­tions. When a brighter day dawns, the spores ger­mi­nate and the lin­eage con­tin­ues. (For more in­for­ma­tion about the mech­a­nism and reg­u­la­tion of sporu­la­tion in the model bac­terium Bacil­lus sub­tilis, check some ear­lier STC blogs here and here.) This is not the only 'rest­ing state' that en­ables mi­crobes to per­sist and then re­vive with the re­turn of fa­vor­able con­di­tions.

Fig­ure 1. Un­der­stand­ing long-term mi­cro­bial sur­vival in an­cient rocks on Earth could help us look for forms of life in other plan­ets such as Mars. Source

Some bac­te­ria, such as species of Azo­to­bac­ter, form cysts to with­stand hard times and also to fa­cil­i­tate their dis­per­sal to new en­vi­ron­ments. Veg­e­ta­tive cells tran­si­tion into cysts by thick­en­ing their cell wall, con­tract­ing their cy­to­plasm, in­hibit­ing their motil­ity, and slow­ing down their me­tab­o­lism. Cysts and spores thus rep­re­sent an ex­am­ple of con­ver­gent evo­lu­tion in which dis­parate processes arise to serve a sim­i­lar pur­pose: long-term sur­vival in an ad­verse en­vi­ron­ment. This is a topic of in­ter­est to many sci­en­tific fields, most es­pe­cially as­tro­bi­ol­ogy. It raises the in­trigu­ing pos­si­bil­ity that some plan­ets that pro­vided hos­pitable con­di­tions for life in the past might still house per­sis­tent forms of mi­cro­bial life. But, more specif­i­cally, what types of life forms would we pre­dict these plan­ets to har­bor in their in­hos­pitable depths?

Be­tween a Rock and a Hard Place

Stud­ies dat­ing as far back as the 1950's re­ported the pres­ence of small spher­i­cal cells within an­cient halite crys­tals. Halites are the min­eral form of the salt sodium chlo­ride (NaCl) and are abun­dantly pro­duced in ter­res­trial sed­i­men­tary en­vi­ron­ments when salty wa­ter evap­o­rates. In­ter­est­ingly, the Mars Ex­plo­ration Rover de­tected halites in Mars and sim­i­lar crys­tals with fluid in­clu­sions were also found in bil­lion-year-old me­te­orites orig­i­nat­ing from other places in the uni­verse. These an­cient crys­tals are thus be­lieved to be wide­spread and may even har­bor alien life! Be­cause the ter­res­trial halite crys­tals are very old, some sci­en­tists pro­posed that the spher­i­cal cells con­tained within were an­cient, dor­mant mi­cro­bial forms. In 1960, Reiser and Tasch suc­cess­fully re­sus­ci­tated halite-en­trapped cells in a lab­o­ra­tory growth medium, sup­port­ing the idea that the mi­crobes caught in these an­cient salt crys­tals were vi­able. How­ever, as­sess­ing the age of these mi­crobes proved more dif­fi­cult. While it is pos­si­ble to de­ter­mine the age of the crys­tals, how can one un­equiv­o­cally es­tab­lish the age and ori­gin of the mi­crobes within? An­other dif­fi­culty is the pos­si­bil­ity of con­t­a­m­i­na­tion of the sam­ples by ex­tant mi­crobes. In­deed many crit­ics ques­tioned the steril­ity of the iso­la­tion pro­ce­dure and ar­gued that these mi­crobes were con­t­a­m­i­nants, thus lend­ing fur­ther frailty to the stud­ies.

Fig­ure 2. A halite crys­tal is the min­eral form of sodium chlo­ride. Source

De­spite the crit­ics, the ex­cite­ment per­sisted, like a spore in an un­fa­vor­able en­vi­ron­ment. In 2010, Schu­bert and col­lab­o­ra­tors ob­served sim­i­lar spher­i­cal cells in 34,000 year-old halite crys­tals and were able to re­sus­ci­tate them in growth me­dia, though at a de­press­ingly low suc­cess rate of 0.6%. Fur­ther­more, growth re­sumed only af­ter ex­tended in­cu­ba­tion pe­ri­ods (60+ days). These an­cient or­gan­isms ap­peared to have awoken grog­gily from a long, long rest. Se­quenc­ing 16S rDNA of the cells in the cul­ture iden­ti­fied sev­eral novel lin­eages within the haloar­chaeal gen­era Halorubrum, Na­tronomonas, and Haloter­ri­gena. Oddly enough, the mi­crobes grow­ing in cul­ture were rod-shaped rather than spher­i­cal. Crit­ics used this to cau­tion, once more, about the po­ten­tial for con­t­a­m­i­na­tion in this work. How­ever, the re­searchers were not dis­mayed by this mor­pho­log­i­cal quandary and were con­fi­dent of their strin­gent cul­ture meth­ods. To prove the crit­ics wrong, they pro­vided the halite sam­ples to an in­de­pen­dent group of in­ves­ti­ga­tors who re­pro­duced the re­sults, thus strength­en­ing the con­vic­tion that the an­cient halite crys­tals har­bored re­silient mi­cro­bial forms. Hur­ray for in­ter-lab re­pro­ducibil­ity!

Mi­cro­bial Shape-shifters

In a re­cent ar­ti­cle pub­lished in Ge­omi­cro­bi­ol­ogy, Fendri­han and col­lab­o­ra­tors added fur­ther cred­i­bil­ity to these stud­ies by re­pro­duc­ing the mor­pho­log­i­cal tran­si­tion from rod to sphere us­ing haloar­chaea en­trapped in halite crys­tals made in the lab­o­ra­tory. The re­searchers evap­o­rated high-salt me­dia and buffers to make the salt crys­tals. Small amounts of hy­per­saline wa­ter of­ten be­came trapped within the crys­tals dur­ing the process, sim­i­lar to the fluid in­clu­sions re­ported in halite min­er­als from ter­res­trial or ex­trater­res­trial sources. By evap­o­rat­ing haloar­chaeal cell sus­pen­sions, the re­searchers trapped the cells in the fluid within the crys­tals. As halite crys­tals are trans­par­ent, they were also able to mon­i­tor the mor­pho­log­i­cal re­sponses of three haloar­chaeal strains (Halobac­terium sali­narum, Halobac­terium nori­cense, and Haloferax mediter­ranei) dur­ing the en­trap­ment process. In all cases, the rod-shaped cells shifted in shape to uni­formly sized, small, spher­i­cal forms.

Fig­ure 3. Halobac­terium sali­narum NRC‑1 cells (in green) trapped in fluid in­clu­sions within a halite crys­tal. Source

The re­searchers then rightly con­sid­ered whether the mor­pho­log­i­cal tran­si­tion was a di­rect re­sponse to the phys­i­cal en­trap­ment or a phys­i­o­log­i­cal adap­ta­tion to the pro­gres­sively lower lev­els of wa­ter ac­tiv­ity en­coun­tered dur­ing the for­ma­tion of the salt crys­tals. As most cel­lu­lar com­po­nents (en­zymes, DNA, etc.) re­quire in­ter­ac­tions with wa­ter mol­e­cules for their ac­tiv­ity, low wa­ter ac­tiv­ity of­ten in­hibits mi­cro­bial growth. Bac­te­ria, for ex­am­ple, re­quire a wa­ter ac­tiv­ity of 0.9 and above. This is the rea­son why honey, which has a very low wa­ter ac­tiv­ity value, i.e., be­tween 0.5 and 0.7, is es­sen­tially ster­ile. Might the shift from rods to spher­i­cal shapes re­flect the tran­si­tion from an ac­tive, veg­e­ta­tive state to a dor­mant form that could with­stand the low wa­ter ac­tiv­ity? The re­searchers used a va­ri­ety of salts to make test so­lu­tions with low wa­ter ac­tiv­ity and ob­served that the ma­jor­ity of the so­lu­tions in­duced the mor­pho­log­i­cal shift from rods to cocci—physical en­trap­ment not re­quired. Fur­ther, as the num­ber of rod cells de­creased, the num­ber of small spheres in­creased in the ra­tio of 3–4 spher­i­cal cells per ini­tial rod cell. This sug­gested that the mor­pho­log­i­cal shift re­sulted from the di­vi­sion of in­di­vid­ual rod cells into sev­eral (3–4) small spheres.

Fig­ure 4. Halobac­terium sali­narum NRC‑1 rod cells (left) be­come spher­i­cal (right) when the wa­ter ac­tiv­ity of the sur­round­ing buffer de­creases. Source

In­ter­est­ingly, the spher­i­cal cells had 50-times less ATP per cell than their rod-shaped an­ces­tors. Such a mas­sive drop in ATP con­tent is typ­i­cal of spores and other dor­mant forms and is con­sis­tent with their re­duced meta­bolic ac­tiv­ity. Fur­ther­more, the spheres showed an in­creased mem­brane lipid con­tent and a re­duced cell pro­tein con­tent, in­clud­ing the jet­ti­son­ing of the now ex­cess S‑layer pro­teins. The changes in the S‑layer, which acts a se­lec­tive per­me­abil­ity bar­rier but also helps main­tain the shape of the cell, and mem­brane lipid con­tent sup­port the no­tion that these spher­i­cal forms are a strate­gic sur­vival re­sponse to low wa­ter ac­tiv­ity con­di­tions. The tac­tic worked: the spheres re­tained their shape and the abil­ity to re­sume growth in solid or liq­uid me­dia even af­ter 6 years of en­trap­ment in the halite crys­tals! Af­ter break­ing the ap­par­ent dor­mancy, the spheres also shifted to their orig­i­nal rod shape. Hence, the spheres re­mained vi­able and re­tained the po­ten­tial to re­vert to their an­ces­tral rod self.

It is im­por­tant to note that al­though the haloar­chaeal spheres are phys­i­o­log­i­cally sim­i­lar to spores, they are not spores in the typ­i­cal sense. The genomes of these haloar­chaeal species do not har­bor ho­mo­logues of known sporu­la­tion genes. Rather, the re­search team pro­poses that these spheres could be akin to bac­te­r­ial cysts. How­ever, ev­i­dence for cyst for­ma­tion in haloar­chaea is lack­ing and the for­ma­tion of the small haloar­chaeal spheres does not fol­low the canon­i­cal en­cyst­ment ob­served in bac­te­ria. It seems more likely that haloar­chaea do it dif­fer­ently and that what we have here is a novel form of dor­mancy, evolved as a spe­cific adap­ta­tion for long-term sur­vival and per­sis­tence in the halite en­vi­ron­ment. Call these spheres what you will, these stud­ies pro­vide yet an­other fas­ci­nat­ing ex­am­ple of the strate­gies that mi­crobes have evolved to weather the storm and per­sist to see a brighter day. And they re­mind us, once more, how much there is yet to learn about life in our planet and be­yond.

 

Ref­er­ences

Reiser R, Tasch P (1960). In­ves­ti­ga­tion of the vi­a­bil­ity of os­mophile bac­te­ria of great ge­o­log­i­cal age. Trans­ac­tions of the Kansas Acad­emy of Sci­ence. Kansas Acad­emy of Sci­ence, 63, 31−34. PMID 13740659

Schu­bert BA, Lowen­stein TK, Tim­o­fe­eff MN, Parker MA (2010). Halophilic Ar­chaea cul­tured from an­cient halite, Death Val­ley, Cal­i­for­nia. En­vi­ron­men­tal Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy, 12 (2), 440−454. PMID 19840101

 

Mike Manzella

Mike is Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy and Mol­e­c­u­lar Ge­net­ics grad­u­ate stu­dent at Michi­gan State Uni­ver­sity work­ing un­der Drs. Reguera and Kashefi.

 

Other Posts

  • How to grow shrubs

    by Christoph — Ex­actly eight years ago to­day, we in­tro­duced you to the 'Hedge­hogs In Your Gar­den'. No, we had not turned our backs on the Small Things and be­came gar­den­ers in­stead. Again to­day, it is not about gar­den­ing ac­tiv­i­ties, namely, 'How to grow shrubs'. Let me ex­plain...

  • Phage DNA: Go­ing with the Flow

    by Merry Youle — We've heard it said so of­ten, it must be true. Af­ter tailed phages ad­sorb to their host and bind se­curely to their spe­cific re­cep­tor on the cell sur­face, they in­ject their DNA into the cell and the in­fec­tion is off and run­ning. This in­jec­tion no­tion arose nat­u­rally from the clas­sic…

  • The Col­ors of the Mi­cro­bial Rain­bow

    by Gemma Reguera — Our ap­pre­ci­a­tion of the col­ors of na­ture is lim­ited by the nar­row wave­lengths of the elec­tro­mag­netic spec­trum that our eyes can de­tect. This por­tion of the elec­tro­mag­netic spec­trum be­tween 390 and 750 nm is what we re­fer to as the vis­i­ble (vis) light or, sim­ply, light. We can­not see be­low…

  • One Hun­dred Mil­lion Year Old Polyamines

    Who Would Have Thought? by Elio — Pa­le­on­tol­o­gists are greatly helped in their work by find­ing or­ganic com­pounds that have been pre­served in fos­sils through the ages. Most use­ful among these are the amaz­ingly sta­ble poly­cyclic ter­penoid lipids, in par­tic­u­lar the bac­te­r­ial hopanoids (Click here and here), that are present in fos­sils about 2.4 bil­lion years…

  • A Pathogen's Swiss Army Knife

    by Maren von Köck­ritz-Blick­wede — Staphy­lo­coc­cus au­reus is an amaz­ingly im­pres­sive bug that end­lessly fas­ci­nates and wor­ries mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists. It has an ex­cep­tional abil­ity to ex­ploit host im­mune func­tions, thereby caus­ing a wide range of life­­­–threatening in­fec­tions. For more than 40 years, new dis­cov­er­ies about its vir­u­lence po­ten­tial have been made at a steadily in­creas­ing pace.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
P. Nart
13 years ago

Nice and clearly writ­ing ar­ti­cle about the non-end­ing won­ders of the mi­cro­bial world. Thanks!