Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #95

by Barry Gold­man

Al­most all mul­ti­cel­lu­lar crit­ters known (an­i­mals, plants, fungi, al­gae) go through a mi­cro­bial stage in their life cy­cle – ga­mete or spore. Can you think of a mul­ti­cel­lu­lar species or higher taxon that has NEVER been caught go­ing through the mi­cro­bial stage?

 

Other Posts

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
barry
13 years ago

the real ques­tion: why must all cells of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms con­tain the same genome? is it al­ways this way on earth? 'cause i want to know if a mul­ti­celu­lar or­gan­ism can line up with an­other and ex­change genes cell by cell and re­main mul­ti­cel­lu­lar.
i should look at fungi.
i sup­pose bac­te­r­ial biofilms could be con­sid­ered an ex­am­ple of this. sort of.
i got to think­ing of all this while read­ing j.t. bon­ner

13 years ago

Some species of pla­naria are ex­clu­sively asex­ual. At least in a lab set­ting.
The pla­narian de­taches its tail end and each half re­grows the lost parts by re­gen­er­a­tion, al­low­ing adult stem cells to di­vide and dif­fer­en­ti­ate, thus re­sult­ing in two worms.

Zachary Williams
13 years ago

"the real ques­tion: why must all cells of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms con­tain the same genome? is it al­ways this way on earth? 'cause i want to know if a mul­ti­celu­lar or­gan­ism can line up with an­other and ex­change genes cell by cell and re­main mul­ti­cel­lu­lar.
i should look at fungi."
Lichens. Fun­gus + al­gae. No idea whether there's ev­i­dence of gene ex­change, though. I bet some­one has looked into this, won­der if I can find some pa­pers...

13 years ago

Some kinds of pla­naria com­pletely neuter. At least in lab­o­ra­tory Set­tings.
Pla­narian sep­a­ra­tion its end and each half re­grows lost part of the re­gen­er­a­tion, to make the adult stem cell di­vi­sion and dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion, lead­ing to two worms.

peter w.
13 years ago

per­haps the be­del­loid ro­tifers might fit your pro­file? bdel­loid ro­tifers re­pro­duce by partheno­gen­e­sis. oo­ge­n­e­sis pro­ceeds via two mi­totic di­vi­sions. meio­sis is ab­sent, and there­fore there is no stage dur­ing which chro­mo­some re­duc­tion oc­curs; i.e. no hap­loid stage.