Oddly Mi­cro­bial: Pri­ons

Ed­i­tors' Note: This is the fourth in what is ex­pected to be an on­go­ing se­ries about cells that might not come im­me­di­ately to mind when you think "mi­crobe." The first, sec­ond and third links are here—Oddly Mi­cro­bial: Ri­bo­cytes, Oddly Mi­cro­bial: Can­cer Cells, Oddly Mi­cro­bial: 86-Mil­lion Year-Old Deep Seabed Mys­tery Cells. Com­ments and sug­ges­tions for fu­ture posts are en­cour­aged.

by Mar­cia Stone

Left: Elec­tron mi­cro­graph of brain tis­sue from a mon­key in­fected with the prion dis­ease kuru. Be­tween the rounded nu­clei of the nerve cells (green) are tiny vac­uole spaces typ­i­cal of the disease's dark spots. From the cover of the De­cem­ber 2012 is­sue of Mi­crobe, the ASM Mag­a­zine. Im­age PHANIE/Photo Re­searchers, Inc.) Source. Right: Steven Schlozman's book, soon to be a movie.

Pri­ons can turn their vic­tims into zombies—they punch holes in their brains and steal their souls. The in­fected stum­ble about, might take a bite out of some­one if hun­gry, cer­tainly don't think straight and, most im­por­tant, lose their mem­o­ries and with them the very essence of their hu­man­ity or "soul." Zom­bie en­thu­si­ast and Har­vard psy­chi­a­trist Steven Schloz­man made the con­nec­tion and has even writ­ten a sci­ence fic­tion novel, soon to be a film, about a prion-caused apoc­a­lypse called The Zom­bie Au­top­sies. In the book, in­fluenza-like viruses with prion pay­loads, pos­si­bly con­cocted by mad sci­en­tists, cause a zom­bie pan­demic that kill off a goodly por­tion of the planet's hu­mans; but not be­fore the newly minted zom­bies stag­ger about try­ing to eat, and likely in­fect­ing, any­one they man­age to fall into. Schlozman's hy­po­thet­i­cal dis­ease, "ANSD" or Ataxic Neu­rode­gen­er­a­tive Sati­ety De­fi­ciency Syn­drome, is read­ily trans­mit­ted by cough­ing or sneez­ing.

OK. That neu­ro­logic pri­ons turn peo­ple into "zom­bies" is a good anal­ogy; sadly, that's what seems to hap­pen when Alzheimer's and raft of other pro­tein-in­sti­gated neu­rode­gen­er­a­tive dis­eases take hold. How­ever, it's un­likely that any amount of mi­cro­bi­o­log­i­cal savvy could keep a tiny RNA virus schlep­ping around a prion or two afloat. And even if a few over­loaded viruses man­age to ac­ci­dently plum­met into an open nos­tril while strug­gling to stay aerosolized, it isn't in the na­ture of pri­ons to cause im­me­di­ate dis­ease. (More about pri­ons from ASM.)

Path­o­genic pro­teins ac­cepted as in­fec­tious agents … but not with­out a fight

No­tably, be­fore Stan­ley Prusiner, a neu­rol­o­gist, stood his ground in the 1980s in­sist­ing that de­men­tias could be caused by nu­cleic acid-de­fi­cient in­fect­ing agents, vi­rol­o­gists were adamant in their be­lief that these strange dis­eases were caused by "slow viruses." Em­pha­sis was on the "slow." Fur­ther­more, dogma at the time held that "con­vey­ers of trans­mis­si­ble dis­eases re­quired ge­netic ma­te­r­ial com­posed of nu­cleic acid (DNA or RNA) in or­der to es­tab­lish in­fec­tion in a host," Prusiner writes.

Prusiner lost both his pro­mo­tion to tenure at the Uni­ver­sity of Cal­i­for­nia San Fran­cisco and his Howard Hughes Med­ical In­sti­tute (HHMI) grant by stub­bornly de­fend­ing his then hereti­cal be­lief that "pro­teina­ceous in­fec­tious particles"—or "prions"—could un­der­lie in­her­ited, as well as com­mu­ni­ca­ble, dis­eases. Such dual be­hav­ior was un­known and thus un­think­able at the time. "Vi­rol­o­gists were gen­er­ally in­cred­u­lous, and some in­ves­ti­ga­tors work­ing on scrapie and Creutzfeldt-Jakob dis­ease were irate." Prusiner got even at the No­bel Prize cer­e­mony in 1997 and cau­tions in his au­to­bi­og­ra­phy: "While it is quite rea­son­able for sci­en­tists to be skep­ti­cal of new ideas that do not fit within the ac­cepted realm of sci­en­tific knowl­edge, the best sci­ence of­ten emerges from sit­u­a­tions where re­sults care­fully ob­tained do not fit within the ac­cepted par­a­digms." He also got his tenure at UCSF and a much larger grant, but not from HHMI. Now, 30 years af­ter he and his col­leagues iso­lated a rogue pro­tein that could cause dis­ease in healthy an­i­mals, Prusiner says there's enough ev­i­dence to sup­port a uni­fy­ing prion-like mech­a­nism in neu­rode­gen­er­a­tive and, per­haps, other dis­eases.

Alzheimer's pri­ons prove pro­tein-caused dis­ease is trans­mit­table

Prion in­fec­tiv­ity de­pends on a nor­mal cel­lar prion pro­tein (PrPC) mis­fold­ing into what's known as the "scrapie" pro­tein (PrPSC), and then cor­rupt­ing the nor­mal sur­round­ing pro­teins. PrPSC is prone to ag­gre­ga­tion, thus the mis­folded prion pro­teins tan­gle them­selves up as, for ex­am­ple, in Alzheimer's dis­ease, form­ing brain-de­stroy­ing Aβ amy­loid plaques. Alzheimer's has re­cently proved trans­mis­si­ble in mar­mosets, thus prov­ing be­yond a doubt that pri­ons can cause dis­ease. And dis­tress­ingly, grafted fe­tal brain cells can be­come in­fected with α‑synuclein pri­ons af­ter they've been trans­planted into pa­tients with Parkinson's dis­ease. Prusiner con­jec­tures that the dis­ease-caus­ing pri­ons cross from the neu­rons of the re­cip­i­ent and cor­rupt the healthy fe­tal cells.

(miss­ing im­age 6a00d8341c5e1453ef017ee782330b970d X)

Pri­ons can take on two dif­fer­ent con­for­ma­tions. The one on the right, in a he­li­cal con­for­ma­tion, dis­solves eas­ily in wa­ter, and is rel­a­tively be­nign. The one on the left, in a beta-sheet con­for­ma­tion, tends to stick to other sim­i­lar pri­ons and forms plaques. These plaques dis­rupt the struc­ture of healthy tis­sue, re­sult­ing in the "spongy" tex­ture found in the brains of in­fected an­i­mals. Source

Pri­ons are also thought to be in­volved in amy­otrophic lat­eral scle­ro­sis; fa­mil­ial amy­loid polyneu­ropa­thy, fron­totem­po­ral de­men­tias, trans­mis­si­ble spongi­form en­cephalopathies (TSEs) and their hu­man vari­ants, Creutzfeldt-Jakob dis­ease, as well as kuru, a TSE spread by rit­ual can­ni­bal­ism. Type II di­a­betes too is con­sid­ered a prion-in­sti­gated ill­ness, one of the very few non-neu­rode­gen­er­a­tive prion-re­lated dis­eases so far de­scribed. But that's be­cause neu­rol­o­gists have dom­i­nated the field; how­ever, this seems to be chang­ing.

Pro­posed mod­els for PrPC con­ver­sion into PrPSc. (a) PrPSc is the only mol­e­cule re­spon­si­ble for struc­tural con­ver­sion of PrPC into new PrPSc. A third macro­mol­e­cule is re­spon­si­ble for PrPC con­ver­sion into PrPSc with two pos­si­ble courses of ac­tion. (b) The cat­a­lyst mol­e­cule is di­rectly re­spon­si­ble for PrPC con­ver­sion into PrPSc. © The co­fac­tor mol­e­cule acts as a cat­a­lyst, fa­cil­i­tat­ing PrPC con­ver­sion into PrPSc. (d) The con­for­ma­tional tran­si­tion is sep­a­rated by a large en­er­getic bar­rier that is as­so­ci­ated with un­fold­ing and oligomer­iza­tion. (e) A co­fac­tor mol­e­cule acts as a cat­a­lyst, low­er­ing the en­ergy bar­rier be­tween PrPC and PrPSc, fa­cil­i­tat­ing con­ver­sion. Source

On­col­o­gists be­come prion hunters and dis­cover mis­folded p53 may be a cause of can­cer

Can­cer has re­cently been added to the grow­ing list of deadly prion dis­eases by Jer­son Silva and col­leagues in Brazil. When cells are stressed, tu­mor sup­pres­sor pro­tein, p53, trig­gers cell-cy­cle ar­rest or apoptosis—that's as it should be," says Silva. If this doesn't hap­pen cells keep cy­cling in an un­con­trolled man­ner; typ­i­cal can­cer cell be­hav­ior. It doesn't help that p53 is un­sta­ble and mu­tates eas­ily af­ter which, in true prion fash­ion, the mis­folded pro­teins self-per­pet­u­ate by dri­ving nor­mal p53 into cor­rupted, ag­gre­ga­tion-prone con­for­ma­tions. It's a Jekyll and Hyde sce­nario, the nor­mal p53 pre­vents can­cer and its mis­folded ver­sion seems to not only al­low can­cer gen­e­sis but to pos­si­bly even in­sti­gate ma­lig­nant trans­for­ma­tion.

"PrPC and PrPSC share the same amino acid se­quence and are en­coded by the same gene," says Silva who has found ev­i­dence that non-cod­ing RNAs (ncR­NAs), the kind that used to be thought of as "junk," play a role in prion con­ver­sion from nor­mal to dis­ease in­duc­ing. The trans­for­ma­tion prob­a­bly takes place dur­ing tran­scrip­tion. There's a vast amount of ncRNA in the cy­tosol of nor­mal cells and the pri­ons might in­ter­act with it there.

"This [the con­ver­sion] process may be a mol­e­c­u­lar relic of bi­o­log­i­cal prop­a­ga­tion in early evo­lu­tion­ary times," ac­cord­ing to Silva. The abil­ity to al­ter prion fold­ing was likely ac­quired dur­ing evo­lu­tion to en­hance the abil­ity of cells to rapidly di­ver­sify and adapt, adds Aus­tralian sci­en­tist Alan Munn. Munn also notes that "the phe­no­typic shifts in metasta­tic can­cer cells oc­cur in a spon­ta­neous, rapid, and re­versible man­ner that re­sem­bles what hap­pens in yeast dur­ing spon­ta­neous prion in­duc­tion and cur­ing." Ap­par­ently the process is well con­served.

Al­though his work shows that p53 and other pri­ons prob­a­bly don't act alone, ncR­NAs are non-ge­nomic nu­cleic acids and there is still no chal­lenge to Prusiner's "pro­tein-only" sta­tus of pri­ons, says Silva.

A real zom­bie pan­demic may be silently brew­ing in an oth­er­wise healthy pop­u­la­tion

It's highly un­likely that in­fluenza viruses will ever vec­tor neu­ro­log­i­cally path­o­genic pri­ons but don't breathe a sigh of re­lief quite yet. We are fac­ing a po­ten­tial zom­bie pandemic—it just won't be the kind Schloz­man en­vi­sions in his book.

(miss­ing im­age 6a00d8341c5e1453ef017d400dc559970c X)

Trans­genic mice ex­press­ing hu­man (Hu) or sheep (Ov) PrP, in­oc­u­lated, re­spec­tively, with BSE (Bovine Spongi­form En­cephalopa­thy) or CWD (Chronic Wast­ing Dis­ease) pri­ons, do not gen­er­ally de­velop clin­i­cal dis­ease, and were ob­served to end of life or culled for ex­am­i­na­tion. The ma­jor­ity ex­am­ined be­yond 300 days showed ev­i­dence of prion in­fec­tion in the spleen, whereas only a few mice had de­tectable brain in­fec­tion be­yond 500 days af­ter in­oc­u­la­tion. Bo, bovine. Credit: Y. Hammond/Science. Source

Un­til this year, sci­en­tists be­lieved that pri­ons had dif­fi­culty pass­ing from one species to an­other be­cause of the so-called "species bar­rier ef­fect." This was called into doubt last Jan­u­ary by Vin­cent Béringue and col­leagues at France's In­sti­tut Na­tional de la Recherche Agronomique. By im­plant­ing for­eign pri­ons into trans­genic mice ex­press­ing hu­man and sheep prion pro­tein, these sci­en­tists dis­cov­ered that lym­phoid tis­sue (such as spleen and ton­sils) was as much as sev­en­fold "leakier" to pri­ons from other species than brain. So much for the long-es­tab­lished no­tion of an ab­solute species bar­rier. John Collinge at the Uni­ver­sity Col­lege Lon­don In­sti­tute of Neu­rol­ogy says lym­phatic tis­sue is so hos­pitable to pri­ons that "…prop­a­ga­tion in the lym­phoretic­u­lar sys­tem may pre­cede, and in some cases even be nec­es­sary for neu­roin­va­sion."

Very wor­ry­ing was the fact that very few of the prion-in­fected an­i­mals be­came clin­i­cally ill, sug­gest­ing that the per­sis­tent con­cerns of a silent reser­voir of in­fec­tion in the hu­man pop­u­la­tion are jus­ti­fied. Silent in­fec­tion in hu­mans en­dan­gers the safety of the blood sup­ply and be­cause mis­folded prion pro­teins are not de­na­tured by au­to­clav­ing, trans­mis­sion dur­ing sur­gi­cal and med­ical pro­ce­dures is also a risk. Thus prion ex­perts are call­ing for the rou­tine test­ing of lym­phoid tis­sue in ad­di­tion to the cen­tral ner­vous sys­tem in live­stock.

These sci­en­tists are also call­ing for rou­tine prion test­ing of ton­sils and lymph nodes from peo­ple ex­posed to "mad cow dis­ease" (bovine spongi­form en­cephalopa­thy or "BSE") as well as hunters who are at risk for ac­quir­ing chronic wast­ing dis­ease (CWD) from North Amer­i­can cervids in­clud­ing deer and elk. And be­cause prion trans­mis­sion will come from healthy peo­ple, not those who al­ready have the signs and symp­toms of dis­ease, Collinge ar­gues for an in­ten­sive in­ves­ti­ga­tion of our cur­rently used blood-tests to make cer­tain they can ac­cu­rately de­tect med­ically rel­e­vant pri­ons; like mi­crobes, there are a great num­ber of dif­fer­ent pri­ons and they can spe­ci­ate. These pre­cau­tions are be­com­ing in­creas­ingly ur­gent as the list of known prion-as­so­ci­ated ill­nesses ex­pands, he says. Thus a real prion-in­duced zom­bie apoc­a­lypse may ul­ti­mately prove more fact than fic­tion.

Schloz­man, who em­pha­sizes that he was "screw­ing around with med­ical spec­u­la­tion" in his book which is en­tirely fic­tional, com­ments about real po­ten­tial risk of a neu­rode­gen­er­a­tive dis­ease pan­demic thusly: "The good news? We have sci­ence to keep our heads as the story un­folds." He also notes that "Prusiner could have won his No­bel recog­ni­tion for [his] in­creas­ingly rare gifts of in­tel­li­gence and skep­ti­cal per­sis­tence. It al­ways makes sense to pay at­ten­tion to the one or two guys who man­age to think out­side the prover­bial box.

 

Marcia Stone

Mar­cia Stone is a sci­ence writer based in New York City and a fre­quent con­trib­u­tor to ASM's Mi­crobe mag­a­zine.

 

Other Posts

4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Deloince
13 years ago

I, greatly ap­pre­ci­ate "Small things con­sid­ered" and I am very grate­fully to Maria Stone for the pa­per on pri­ons. Her work is very im­por­tant for the trans­mis­sion of knowl­edges in mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy through the world. Yours, sin­cerely. Robert De­loince

13 years ago

Thank you very much Robert De­loince –we need bet­ter test­ing for pri­ons and I hope this ar­ti­cle helps in any way to get that done.
I con­tacted the peo­ple who sell our beef and they still con­tend that re­mov­ing brain and CNS is all they need to do to as­sure beef is safe to eat. Ac­tu­ally, I read that on their site, they de­clined to an­swer my query. I also dis­cov­ered that test­ing deer and elk killed by hunters isn't manda­tory in Col­orado; it's only done on re­quest.
I ap­pre­ci­ate your com­ment.

anne dill
13 years ago

als, Parkinson's, de­men­tia , picks dis­ease, cmt, adrenal hy­per­pla­sia, chronic gran­u­lam­ato­sis dis­ease, Itp, heri­datary neu­ropa­thy, iron def­i­cancy, chronic fa­tigue, lu­pus, all with se­vere skin ab­nor­mal­i­ties have hit my fam­ily within 5 years. I know there is an in­fec­tious process and can not con­vince physi­cians to even con­sider this. My chil­dren are suf­fer­ing. How do I help them...anne dill. Annemariedill@msn.com

13 years ago

Anna Marie –Look through pub med for re­searchers work­ing on prion dis­eases and/or var­i­ous sup­port groups. Per­haps one of our mem­bers will have a sug­ges­tion but it's un­likely (im­pos­si­ble ac­tu­ally) that any­one can help with­out see­ing the pa­tients. I'm a jour­nal­ist and not at all qual­ifed to give you med­ical ad­vice.
Prion dis­eases take so long to ac­tu­ally cause dis­ease it's un­likely they're re­spon­si­ble for any­hing ac­quired within 5 years. How­ever Stan­ley Prusiner runs a prion cen­ter at the U of Cal­i­for­nia S.F. –you might want to con­tact them. They'd also have peo­ple fa­mil­iar with var­i­ous vi­ral and toxin-caused dis­eases and could make a dif­fer­en­tial di­ag­no­sis.
I do hope some­one, some­where can help.