The Paeni­bacil­lus Mov­ing Com­pany

by Elio

Mi­crobes get around. They can be car­ried by the wind, by in­sects, or by wa­ter cur­rents, some­times across large dis­tances, some­times from one grain of soil to the next. Some bac­te­ria con­tribute to their own dis­per­sal by their motil­ity or, rarely, one may think, by the motil­ity of other mi­crobes. It's hard to gen­er­al­ize here be­cause there are just too many vari­ables, too many con­di­tions where mi­crobes are on the move. But this busi­ness can be pure fun. So it's with plea­sure that I read about a de­light­ful ac­count of how bac­te­ria can trans­port fun­gal spores to the ben­e­fit of both.
 

En­light­en­ment, a bac­te­r­ial colony. Dis­played in the Es­her Ben-Ja­cob on­line art gallery. Source

But first a lit­tle back­ground, both mi­cro­bial and per­sonal. Some bac­te­ria, when placed on an agar sur­face, do not stay put but spread out from the point of in­oc­u­la­tion. Cer­tain ones, such as Bacil­lus my­coides, do it sim­ply by ex­tend­ing their long fil­a­ments, but oth­ers do it by mov­ing on the agar sur­face. There are sev­eral ways to move along, ei­ther with fla­gella (a process called swarm­ing) or with­out them (e.g., glid­ing or twitch­ing). Swarm­ing, whether in Gram-pos­i­tives like cer­tain Bacil­lus species or in Gram-neg­a­tives such as Pro­teus, is a com­mu­nal ac­tiv­ity. Sin­gle cells don't swarm, ag­gre­gates of sev­eral cells do. What you see un­der the mi­cro­scope are rafts of bac­te­ria arranged side by side, mov­ing along a path that is some­times reg­u­lar, some­times not. To down­load a movie of a 'raft' of ceils swarm­ing to­gether, click here (or to go to the web page where you can se­lect ad­di­tional file 4, click here). The speed of move­ment across the agar sur­face is pretty amaz­ing, about 180 µm/min or 10 mm/h. This means that if you place such a bac­terium in the cen­ter of a 14 cm Petri dish, it will reach the edge in about seven hours. When such a swarm has cov­ered a cer­tain dis­tance, the cells ei­ther stop mov­ing, as in the case of Pro­teus, or make round disc-like colonies that have the odd abil­ity to ro­tate. For a movie of a 'colony' of cells swarm­ing to­gether, click here (or to go to the web page where you can se­lect ad­di­tional file 2, click here). The speed at which this ro­ta­tion hap­pens is also quite fast, one rev­o­lu­tion in about 10 sec­onds. To­wards the end of my ca­reer, but while I still had a lab, my col­lab­o­ra­tor Dana Boyd and I played around with these or­gan­isms. This was the last time that I worked at the bench, so I quite cher­ish this topic.

A typ­i­cal colo­nial pat­tern gen­er­ated by P. vor­tex when grown on 2.25% (w/v) agar with 2% (w/v) pep­tone in a 9 cm Petri dish. (A) Whole colony view. Each vor­tex (the con­densed group of bac­te­ria, the bright dots) is com­posed of many cells that swarm col­lec­tively around their com­mon cen­ter at about 10 μm/s. (B) An in­di­vid­ual vor­tex. The di­am­e­ter of the vor­tex is 75 μm. Source

Peer­ing at bac­te­ria that are swarm­ing is a game most any­one can play. If you have ac­cess to a Petri dish with agar in it, take a few grains of al­most any soil and place them in the cen­ter. Within six hours or so, you will see that among the many small colonies on the sur­face there will be some that moved away from the in­ocu­lum site. What you will see are tracks with 'colonies' at the end. Most likely, you are now look­ing at Paeni­bacil­lus, the or­gan­ism I'm fea­tur­ing here.

Paeni­bacil­lus, once merely known as Bacil­lus (the cur­rent name means al­most Bacil­lus), of which there are many species, is one of the cham­pion swarm­ers that has puz­zled mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists for over 100 years. So, you ask, why do they swarm? Hmm, it would seem in­tu­itively ob­vi­ous that they must be scav­eng­ing for food. Not so fast. The swarms do not ex­hibit chemo­taxis or any other pref­er­ence for needed nu­tri­ents, as some other bac­te­ria do. We found that our strains could swarm on agar con­tain­ing just phos­phate buffer, pe­riod. For good mea­sure, we added chlo­ram­pheni­col, to which these bugs were sen­si­tive, and that didn't im­pair their trav­els. At no time did we see the swarms move pref­er­en­tially to­wards a place on the plate where we had put any of a va­ri­ety of nu­tri­ents.

In our ef­forts to fig­ure out what this is all about, we con­firmed some­thing that had been known, namely that the bac­te­ria could carry around other bac­te­ria, such as cocci. To take this to the limit, we used 1 µm di­am­e­ter la­tex par­ti­cles and, guess what, they were spread around just like the bac­te­ria them­selves. These par­ti­cles seemed to be pushed along, ei­ther at the head of a raft or trapped within it. So at that point we started to think that swarm­ing could be used for in­ter­ac­tions with other or­gan­isms, pos­si­bly to carry along species that could fur­nish the swarm­ers with food in cer­tain fal­low en­vi­ron­ments. We never demon­strated this, al­though it seems as plau­si­ble to­day as then.

Volga Boat­men, by Ilya Re­pin. Source

How­ever, to my sat­is­fac­tion, oth­ers are hav­ing a longer and more pro­duc­tive look. In par­tic­u­lar, mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gist Colin In­g­ham teamed up with physi­cist Es­her Ben-Ja­cob and col­leagues Oren Kalis­man, and Alin Finkel­stein to ask prob­ing ques­tions of these bac­te­ria. Not only that, but they are hav­ing fun with the pat­terns that bac­te­ria can form on agar as wit­nessed by a gallery of sen­sa­tional pic­tures. In a re­cent pa­per, these in­ves­ti­ga­tors showed that these bac­te­ria are able to move the spores of a fun­gus, As­pergillus fu­mi­ga­tus. This fun­gus is a com­mon soil or­gan­ism known to cause dis­ease in im­muno­com­pro­mised pa­tients. The fun­gal spores are not motile, thus de­pen­dent on wa­ter or air cur­rents for dis­per­sion. It turns out that if you mix these spores with cells of a species of Paeni­bacil­lus called P. vor­tex, the spores are moved along for quite a dis­tance, at the same rate as the bac­te­ria. Af­ter suit­able in­cu­ba­tion, fun­gal colonies ap­pear all over the plate. It's up to you to imag­ine the prac­ti­cal im­pli­ca­tions of these find­ings.

These mi­cro­scopic fer­ry­men can haul quite a cargo. It can con­sist not just of in­di­vid­ual spores but also spore ag­gre­gates 25 µm across (each spore is about 3 µm in length). This re­minds one of ants that can carry up to one hun­dred times their body weight. It gets bet­ter. These bac­te­ria can even im­pel the fun­gal spores across an area on the agar im­preg­nated with an an­ti­fun­gal growth-in­hibitory com­pound, a ver­i­ta­ble mine­field.

Bac­te­ria cross­ing a canyon in the Petri dish along nat­ural bridge of fun­gal mycelia (top, cour­tesy of Colin In­g­ham), much like an­i­mals cross­ing a canyon in Nepal on a man-made bridge (bot­tom, cour­tesy of Aya Ben-Yakov). Source

In search­ing for the mech­a­nism in­volved, the au­thors found that not all fun­gal spores can be so translo­cated. Spores of even some close rel­a­tives of A. fu­mi­ga­tus do not play the game but stay put on the agar. Also, ger­mi­nat­ing spores are not trans­ported ef­fi­ciently. Un­der the elec­tron mi­cro­scope, spores be­ing car­ried are seen sur­rounded by bac­te­r­ial fla­gella. And, sure enough, adding pu­ri­fied fla­gella in­hib­ited their trans­port. This sug­gests the pres­ence of re­cep­tors for fla­gella on the sur­face of cer­tain spores and not oth­ers. So, are there two dif­fer­ent mech­a­nisms in­volved, one for non-spe­cific par­ti­cles such as la­tex beads, an­other spe­cific for cer­tain car­goes? Does this have any­thing to do with the size of the ob­ject be­ing moved, the larger ones re­quir­ing chem­i­cal recog­ni­tion by the bac­te­ria?

It is easy to see what's in it for the fun­gus. It gets translo­cated, and thus is dis­persed to new sites. But what's in it for the bac­te­ria? The in­ves­ti­ga­tors did a sim­ple but clever ex­per­i­ment: they cut a slit in the agar a half mil­lime­ter wide. The bac­te­ria could not­cross it alone, but the fungi had no prob­lem span­ning the gap with their hy­phal threads. And when both bac­te­ria and fungi were present, guess what? On the other side they now found bac­te­ria that had done a high wire act on the fun­gal tightrope. In other sys­tems, it has been shown that bac­te­ria make biofilms on the sur­face of hy­phae so, in a way, this was to be ex­pected.

Not only do these bac­te­ria move on agar at a fine clip, but they do it even un­der con­di­tions of star­va­tion. As I men­tioned al­ready, in my lab we saw swarm­ing tak­ing place at nor­mal speeds on agar that con­tained only phos­phate buffer. No added food. They seem to want to move at all costs, con­sum­ing pre­cious meta­bolic re­serves in the process. Swarm­ing is their top phys­i­o­log­i­cal pri­or­ity. So one would guess that this is a prop­erty that has been se­lected for in a big way dur­ing evo­lu­tion. What­ever the pur­pose, we may have been pre­ma­ture in rul­ing out some kind of chemo­taxis. In the sup­ple­men­tal ma­te­r­ial to one Ben-Ja­cob pa­per (To see the movie, click here, or to go to the web page where you can se­lect ad­di­tional file 5, click here), there is an in­di­ca­tion that swarms of bac­te­ria move to­wards ex­tra­cel­lu­lar ma­te­r­ial left in the trails, al­though this may not be for nu­tri­tional rea­sons.

Dis­tri­b­u­tion of the rel­a­tive So­cial IQ scores of 502 bac­te­ria. Green in­di­cates bac­te­r­ial strains that be­long to the Paeni­bacil­lus genus. Source

Now a fi­nal word about Paeni­bacil­lus and its genome. It turns out that it's one smart bug, in fact, bril­liant by one cri­te­rion. Ben-Ja­cob scored the genomes of many bac­te­r­ial species for the num­ber of genes po­ten­tially in­volved in so­cial be­hav­iors. He pro­posed a bac­te­r­ial So­cial IQ scale, which he de­scribes as: a quan­ti­ta­tive score.… to as­sess the genome po­ten­tial of bac­te­ria to con­duct suc­cess­ful co­op­er­a­tive and adapt­able be­hav­iors (or so­cial be­hav­iors) in com­plex ad­verse en­vi­ron­ments…. The score is based on the num­ber of genes which af­ford bac­te­ria abil­i­ties to com­mu­ni­cate and process en­vi­ron­men­tal in­for­ma­tion (Two-com­po­nent sys­tem and tran­scrip­tion fac­tor genes), to make de­ci­sions and to syn­the­size of­fen­sive (toxic) and de­fen­sive (neu­tral­iz­ing) agents as needed dur­ing chem­i­cal war­fare with other mi­croor­gan­isms. Now for the punch line: Three bac­te­ria species stand out with sig­nif­i­cantly high So­cial-IQ score among all se­quenced bacteria,—over 3 stan­dard de­vi­a­tions higher than av­er­age, in­di­cat­ing a ca­pac­ity for ex­cep­tion­ally bril­liant so­cial skills). No­tably, all these species be­long to the same bac­te­r­ial genus—the Paeni­bacil­lus….

 

Ref­er­ence

In­g­ham CJ, Kalis­man O, Finkelshtein A, Ben-Ja­cob E (2011). Mu­tu­ally fa­cil­i­tated dis­per­sal be­tween the non­motile fun­gus As­pergillus fu­mi­ga­tus and the swarm­ing bac­terium Paeni­bacil­lus vor­tex. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 108(49), 19731–19736. PMID 22106274.

 

Other Posts

  • Of Terms in Bi­ol­ogy: Ace­to­ge­n­e­sis

    by Roberto and Elio — If you are not deeply steeped in mi­cro­bial me­tab­o­lism ter­mi­nol­ogy, your first guess at the mean­ing of ace­to­ge­n­e­sis might be sim­ply the pro­duc­tion of ac­etate. Is vine­gar pro­duc­tion, the ox­i­da­tion of ethanol to ac­etate by acetic acid bac­te­ria, an ex­am­ple of ace­to­ge­n­e­sis? Not quite...

  • Evo­lu­tion? Who Needs It...

    ...Now That We Have CRISPR/Cas9s?
    by Mar­cia Stone — As re­ported on Small Things Con­sid­ered in Sep­tem­ber 12, 2015, the Vo­gons in Dou­glas Adams' Hitch­hik­ers Guide to the Galaxy con­sider evo­lu­tion a waste of time and fix every­thing they think needs fix­ing with surgery. Now hu­mans can do al­most the same thing, al­beit on a much smaller scale, with tiny mol­e­c­u­lar scis­sors called "Cas9s" car­ried to their tar­gets by DNA-seek­ing RNAs known as "CRISPRs."

  • Let Smell Guide You

    by Roberto — Anos­mia: the loss of the sense of smell. Un­til re­cently, I was clue­less about anos­mia. That changed March 22nd when my good friend Hera Vla­makis alerted me to a NYT ar­ti­cle de­scrib­ing anos­mia as a pos­si­ble symp­tom of COVID-19. My self-eval­u­a­tion rou­tine changed hence­forth to in­clude a test of my ca­pac­ity to smell. Now, dur­ing...

  • A Tale of Two Strate­gies

    by S. Mar­vin Fried­man — Bac­te­ria are for the most part gre­gar­i­ous or­gan­isms, liv­ing pre­dom­i­nantly in dense com­mu­ni­ties con­sist­ing of mul­ti­ple strains. In fact, the ma­jor­ity of in­fec­tious bac­te­ria oc­cur as multi-lay­ered struc­tures called biofilms, many of which are com­posed of mul­ti­ple types of bac­te­ria. As one can imag­ine, neigh­bor re­la­tions in such com­plex pop­u­la­tions can be…

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
14 years ago

Elio, I re­ally en­joyed this post—I par­tic­u­larly liked how you in­cor­po­rated your own ex­per­i­ments into the mix. This gives me some great ideas for sim­ple things that fresh­man stu­dents could try! Very, very nice!

14 years ago

I also agree. It's a won­der­ful post! Could I trans­late it to Span­ish and post it in my web?
Re­gards
Elio replies:
Con mu­cho placer,

Kelly Fincher
14 years ago

I can't down­load the movies...thx, Kelly
Elio replies
We're work­ing on it
Merry adds: If your com­puter is not han­dling the down­load link suc­cess­fully, I have now added links to the web page and you can down­load or view the movie from there. The movies are .wmv files.

14 years ago

What a great blog! |It's pretty lucky to find your webblog!|So great!|Nice post|nice to come across your blog||||||

I en­joy read­ing write-up. Hope i can dis­cover a lot more ar­ti­cles like this one. Thanks for post­ing.