Cheap Ex­ports

by Daniel Smith

Evo­lu­tion is of­ten thought of in func­tional terms. Mu­ta­tions that im­prove or di­ver­sify a protein's func­tion are se­lected for, whereas dis­rup­tive mu­ta­tions are se­lected against. How­ever, econ­omy can also play a role in pro­tein evo­lu­tion.

Amino acids used in pro­teins vary in size, com­plex­ity and chem­i­cal char­ac­ter­is­tics, which makes some cheaper to syn­the­size than oth­ers. Con­se­quently, some pro­teins are more eco­nom­i­cal to pro­duce than oth­ers. Pre­vi­ous stud­ies (click here and here) have shown that abun­dant pro­teins are of­ten less ex­pen­sive to make, thus re­duc­ing their cel­lu­lar cost. How­ever, the con­nec­tion be­tween a protein's lo­ca­tion and its ex­pense has not been ap­pre­ci­ated. Re­cently, the ASM on­line jour­nal mBio pub­lished our pa­per, Eco­nom­i­cal Evo­lu­tion: Mi­crobes Re­duce the Syn­thetic Cost of Ex­tra­cel­lu­lar Pro­teins, which demon­strates that pro­teins des­tined for lo­ca­tions out­side the cell cost less to pro­duce than in­tra­cel­lu­lar ones.

Cheap Ex­ports. Source

I be­came in­ter­ested in the idea of pro­tein eco­nom­ics while in Matthew Chapman's lab­o­ra­tory, where they pri­mar­ily study curli (click here and here). Curli are ex­tra­cel­lu­lar fibers pro­duced as struc­tural pro­tein com­po­nents of biofilms by many bac­te­ria, in­clud­ing E. coli. One of my projects was to screen for ad­di­tional genes that af­fect curli pro­duc­tion. One re­sult­ing mu­tant and a re­lated story in­volv­ing the reg­u­la­tion of glyA (which in­ter­con­verts glycine and ser­ine) by the mas­ter curli reg­u­la­tor CsgD sug­gested that glycine me­tab­o­lism and curli pro­duc­tion are in­ter­twined. One pos­si­ble rea­son is found in the com­po­si­tion of the pri­mary curli fiber pro­tein CsgA. CsgA is ex­cep­tion­ally rich in glycine; at 19.2%, it has the sixth high­est glycine con­tent of all pro­teins in E. coli. More­over, glycine, be­ing a sim­ple amino acid, is one of the cheap­est to pro­duce. So the ques­tion arose: is CsgA it­self cheap to pro­duce?

Pro­tein abun­dances and costs of ex­tra­cel­lu­lar fibers. A to C Neg­a­tively stained TEMs of E. coli K12 BW25113 cells show­ing fla­gella, curli, and type 1 fim­briae, re­spec­tively. Bars = 500 nm. D Each pro­tein in E. coli is plot­ted based upon its av­er­age syn­thetic cost (ASC) and cel­lu­lar lo­ca­tion. Dot­ted line: mean ASC of all pro­teins in E. coli; black bars = mean ASC of pro­teins in that lo­ca­tion. Source

To find out, I first looked up pre­vi­ously tal­lied syn­thetic costs for amino acids and then cal­cu­lated the to­tal cost of each E. coli pro­tein. For each pro­tein, I di­vided the to­tal cost by the num­ber of amino acids in the pro­tein to ar­rive at an av­er­age syn­thetic cost per amino acid. I found that CsgA was again quite the out­lier. It was the ninth cheap­est pro­tein out of 4300 for E. coli to pro­duce on a per amino acid ba­sis.

In a way, this makes sense from the bacterium's point of view. As­sem­bling a lot of curli fibers (see fig­ure) out­side the cell is a huge eco­nomic cost. Re­duc­ing cost with­out im­pair­ing func­tion would in­crease the fit­ness of a bac­terium rel­a­tive to its neigh­bors. When we then ex­am­ined other in­ex­pen­sive pro­teins, we no­ticed a star­tling trend. We found that us­ing sev­eral dif­fer­ent mea­sures — chem­i­cal en­ergy, mass, car­bon con­tent — to cal­cu­late pro­tein cost, all of E. coli's ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins are more eco­nom­i­cal than av­er­age. Ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins are in­deed cheaper to make.

E. coli's thrifty ways add up to big sav­ings. Look­ing at just FliC, the ma­jor fiber sub­unit of fla­gella, we cal­cu­lated the en­ergy saved is enough to ro­tate the fla­gel­lum con­stantly for 24 min­utes. Con­sid­er­ing the ex­pected dou­bling time of an E. coli cell, that is like get­ting free fuel for life.

Pro­tein abun­dances and costs of fla­gel­lar pro­teins. Pro­teins with lower av­er­age syn­thetic costs (ASCs)have higher per­centiles and are dark red. * = pro­teins with Sec se­cre­tion se­quences. The num­ber of pro­teins per fla­gel­lum is in­di­cated if known. Source

Not sur­pris­ingly, E. coli is not the only mi­cro­bial miser. We per­formed sim­i­lar pro­tein econ­omy cal­cu­la­tions for a wide range of bac­te­ria, as well as for yeast, and found the same trend: pro­teins se­creted to the ex­tra­cel­lu­lar en­vi­ron­ment are made up of cheaper-to-pro­duce parts than are those found in­side the cell. Could there be some other rea­son for this econ­omy? This eco­nomic bias cor­re­lates with pro­tein lo­ca­tion, but not with cod­ing GC con­tent, pro­tein func­tion, length, struc­ture, or abun­dance.

Many ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins are in­ex­pen­sive but not par­tic­u­larly abun­dant, which led us to ques­tion the rea­son for their econ­omy. Read­ing Small Things Con­sid­ered def­i­nitely helped. In par­tic­u­lar, Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #48 got me think­ing about pro­tein im­port in bac­te­ria: Can you think of an ex­am­ple of an in­tact pro­tein mol­e­cule be­ing taken up by a free-liv­ing bac­terium? For the most part, there are very few ex­am­ples of de­lib­er­ate up­take of for­eign pro­teins by bac­te­ria. The best ex­am­ple I could come up with was P pilus re­trac­tion; in­trigu­ingly, the sub­units of these fibers are less eco­nom­i­cal than those of other ex­tra­cel­lu­lar struc­tures. Who­ever said blogs are a waste of time doesn't read this blog!

Cur­rently, we think the eco­nom­i­cal bias in ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins is due to bac­te­r­ial se­cre­tion of­ten be­ing a one-way street. Be­cause of this, bac­te­ria are not good at re­gain­ing the re­sources in­vested into se­creted pro­teins. Rel­a­tive to cel­lu­lar pro­teins, the amino acids of ex­tra­cel­lu­lar ones are less likely to be re­cy­cled and reused. We think evo­lu­tion has in turn se­lected these ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins for in­creased econ­omy to min­i­mize this loss.

The whole project was an in­trigu­ing tan­gent from the usual fo­cus of our lab. Learn­ing about the many di­verse mi­crobes, their var­ied se­cre­tion sys­tems, and their com­plex cell phys­i­ol­ogy was a lot of fun. We hope our work will im­prove upon cur­rent pre­dic­tion meth­ods for ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins and in­crease our un­der­stand­ing of the se­lec­tive pres­sures shap­ing their com­po­si­tion.

 

Ref­er­ence

Smith DR, Chap­man MR. (2010). Eco­nom­i­cal evo­lu­tion: mi­crobes re­duce the syn­thetic cost of ex­tra­cel­lu­lar pro­teins. mBio, 1 (3). PMID 20824102

 

Daniel Smith

Daniel is a grad­u­ate stu­dent in the De­part­ment of Mol­e­c­u­lar, Cel­lu­lar and De­vel­op­men­tal Bi­ol­ogy, Uni­ver­sity of Michi­gan, Ann Ar­bor.

 

Other Posts

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Philip Ashton
16 years ago

very in­ter­est­ing stuff.
i wouldn't have found out about it if you hadnt blogged about it, might cite your pa­per it in my the­sis. i think that pro­teins which are ex­cep­tional to the rule of ex­ported pro­teins be­ing cheap to make might be very in­ter­est­ing. e.g. my own re­search in­ter­est of bot­u­linum neu­ro­toxin — likely to be ex­pen­sive, se­creted, of prime im­por­tance to the ecol­ogy of the bug and very in­ter­est­ing to re­searchers. BoNT would be an out­lier, what other undis­cov­ered things might be out­liers?
thanks.

15 years ago

I would like to thank every­one in­volved for bring­ing this to my at­ten­tion. Our lab stud­ies Caulobac­ter cres­cen­tus, but more specif­i­cally the se­creted S‑layer pro­tein that it pro­duces.
C. cres­cen­tus was listed in this pa­per as the most eco­nom­i­cal gram-neg­a­tive and RsaA (it's S‑layer monomer) was listed as the sec­ond most eco­nom­i­cal se­creted pro­tein in the study. Caulobac­ters are ex­perts at liv­ing in di­lute, nu­tri­ent-poor en­vi­ron­ments, it makes per­fect sense that they evolved to be stingy with their pro­teins, es­pe­cially their most highly ex­pressed pro­tein, the S‑Layer pro­tein, RsaA. This is a in­cred­i­ble in­sight. We have long know and dis­cussed that RsaA is mostly made of 'small, sim­ple' amino acids but we never clued in to the econ­omy of those amino acids. We of­ten get so in vitro fo­cused that we for­get that our or­gan­isms ex­ists out­side of the lab