A Mat­ter of Tim­ing: Yel­low Fever and the Mos­quito Hy­poth­e­sis

by Welkin John­son

Over half a cen­tury ago, ini­ti­a­tion of world­wide vac­ci­na­tion pro­grams dras­ti­cally cur­tailed the spread of yel­low fever. In re­cent years, how­ever, the dis­ease has re-emerged, with Cen­tral and West Africa be­ing hit par­tic­u­larly hard. Last month, the WHO's Yel­low Fever Ini­tia­tive launched a cam­paign aimed at vac­ci­nat­ing 12 mil­lion per­sons in Benin, Liberia and Sierra Leone. In light of these events, it seemed an ap­pro­pri­ate mo­ment to look back on the year 1900 and the role yel­low fever played at the birth of vi­rol­ogy as a sci­en­tific dis­ci­pline.

Telegram from J.R. Kean to Ma­bel Lazear. Cour­tesy of His­tor­i­cal Col­lec­tions Ser­vices, Claude Moore Health Sci­ences Li­brary, Univ. of Vir­ginia. Source

On Sep­tem­ber 26, 1900, Ma­jor Jef­fer­son Ran­dall Kean, an army sur­geon sta­tioned in Cuba, sent a mes­sage by tele­gram to Ma­bel H. Lazear of Bev­erly, Mass­a­chus­sets. Pain­fully brief, his words be­lied a ma­jor dis­cov­ery in the an­nals of mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy: Dr. Lazear died at 8 this morn­ing – Kean.

Jesse Lazear was a mem­ber of the U.S. Army's Yel­low Fever Com­mis­sion in Cuba, a team headed by U.S. Army sur­geon Wal­ter Reed and in­clud­ing, in ad­di­tion to Dr. Lazear, James Car­roll and the Cuban Aris­tides Agra­monte. In the weeks pre­ced­ing his ill­ness, Lazear ex­per­i­men­tally trans­mit­ted yel­low fever to a hand­ful of hu­man sub­jects by ex­pos­ing them to the bites of mos­qui­toes that had pre­vi­ously fed on pa­tients with yel­low fever. Ex­per­i­ments con­ducted by oth­ers had failed and the mos­quito hy­poth­e­sis, cham­pi­oned since 1881 by the Cuban physi­cian Car­los Find­lay, had fallen out of con­tention. Al­though Lazear's notes are un­clear on the point, Reed and oth­ers be­lieve he played a hand in his own death, in­ten­tion­ally in­clud­ing him­self among the ex­per­i­men­tal sub­jects.

Dr. Jesse Lazear (1866–1900). Source

In a let­ter dated Sep­tem­ber 8, 1900, Lazear con­fided to his wife, "I rather think I am on the track of the real germ, but noth­ing must be said as yet, not same a hint [sic] I have not men­tioned it to a soul." Sev­en­teen days later, on Sep­tem­ber 25 (note it was ac­tu­ally the day be­fore the telegram was sent) he suc­cumbed to yel­low fever. Lazear's re­sults and un­timely death en­er­gized the com­mis­sion, and within weeks Reed es­tab­lished a field sta­tion on a farm near Ha­vana. The site was fit­tingly chris­tened as Camp Lazear, and it was here that the de­ci­sive ex­per­i­ments were ini­ti­ated in late No­vem­ber, less than two months af­ter Lazear's death.

In seek­ing to val­i­date the mos­quito hy­poth­e­sis, Reed's team also sought to rule out a pop­u­lar al­ter­na­tive hy­poth­e­sis – that yel­low fever was spread by "fomites" (fomite refer­ing to ob­jects or sur­faces that serve as a pas­sive plat­form for spread­ing germs, such as dirt, dust, clothes, coins, door­knobs). At the camp, the team erected two small wooden struc­tures, one to house sub­jects in the mos­quito bite ex­per­i­ments, and one in which "fomite" sub­jects would be in close phys­i­cal con­tact with (to the point of sleep­ing on) filthy, blood-and-vomit caked cloth­ing and blan­kets ob­tained from yel­low fever pa­tients. In the care­fully san­i­tized mos­quito hut, test sub­jects (those to be in­oc­u­lated by mos­quito bite) and con­trol sub­jects (un­bit­ten) were sep­a­rated from one an­other and from the out­side by wire screens.

Ma­jor Wal­ter Reed (1851–1902). Source

Within days the "mos­quito" sub­jects be­gan de­vel­op­ing ob­vious symp­toms of yel­low fever, whereas not a sin­gle oc­cupant of the "fomite" hut de­vel­oped signs of the dis­ease. As the re­sults be­came clear to the sub­jects in Camp Lazear over the en­su­ing weeks, re­lief within the fomite co­hort was ap­par­ent, as re­marked upon by Reed:

With the oc­cur­rence of these cases of mos­quito in­fec­tion, the coun­te­nances of these men, which had be­fore borne the se­ri­ous as­pect of those who were bravely fac­ing an un­seen foe, sud­denly took on the glad ex­pres­sion of "school­boys let out for a hol­i­day," and from this time their con­tempt for "fomites" could not find suf­fi­cient ex­pres­sion. Thus il­lus­trat­ing once more, gen­tle­men, the old adage that fa­mil­iar­ity, even with fomites, may breed con­tempt.

In very short or­der, the work of the Yel­low Fever Com­mis­sion and its Cuban and Amer­i­can sub­jects es­tab­lished three re­mark­able facts: that yel­low fever was trans­mit­ted by mos­qui­toes, that trans­mis­sion re­quired that the mos­qui­toes had fed on donors dur­ing the first few days fol­low­ing in­fec­tion, and that an in­cu­ba­tion pe­riod of sev­eral days must pass be­fore the mos­quito vec­tor was ca­pa­ble of trans­mit­ting the dis­ease to an­other in­di­vid­ual. While the na­ture of the in­fec­tious agent re­mained a mys­tery, iden­ti­fi­ca­tion of the mode of trans­mis­sion led U.S. Sur­geon Gen­eral William C. Gor­gas to take de­ci­sive ac­tion in Cuba. Gor­gas in­sti­tuted a suc­cess­ful pro­gram of mos­quito erad­i­ca­tion, along with con­tain­ment and quar­an­tine, which im­me­di­ately and dras­ti­cally re­duced the in­ci­dence of the dis­ease on the is­land.

Fill 'er up. Source

In 1900 some­thing new was brew­ing in the field of mi­cro­biology, and here the work of the Yel­low Fever Commis­sion was des­tined to play a ma­jor role. Just two years ear­lier, in 1898, Mar­t­i­nus Bei­jer­inck used a Cham­ber­land-Pas­teur fil­ter (the pores of which were too small for bac­teria to pass through) to demon­strate that a mot­tling dis­ease of to­bacco plants (to­bacco mo­saic dis­ease) was caused by an ul­tra­mi­cro­scopic, fil­ter­able in­fec­tious agent – what he called a con­tag­ium vivum flu­idum (virus in mo­dern par­lance). In 1899, the year be­fore the Camp Lazear ex­per­i­ments, Lo­ef­fler and Frosch (us­ing a Berke­feld fil­ter) re­ported a sim­i­lar prop­erty for the agent of foot-and-mouth dis­ease. Thus it was in Au­gust of 1901, less than a year af­ter the Camp Lazear ex­per­i­ments, that Com­mis­sion mem­ber James Car­roll re­turned to Cuba and, aware of the ex­per­i­ments of Lo­ef­fler and Frosch, pro­ceeded to demon­strate that fil­tered serum from one yel­low fever pa­tient would in­duce yel­low fever when in­jected into a sec­ond. The sub­se­quent fil­tra­tion and pas­sage of serum from the sec­ond sub­ject to a third, with the same re­sult, ruled in fa­vor of a repli­cat­ing, in­fec­tious agent and ar­gued against a toxin (which would pre­sum­ably have suf­fered ex­treme di­lu­tion upon in­jec­tion and cir­cu­la­tion in the body of the sec­ond pa­tient). Yel­low fever thus be­came the first hu­man in­fec­tious dis­ease to be at­trib­uted to a virus.

Type­writ­ten copy of the con­tract be­tween Wal­ter Reed and one of the Camp Lazear vol­un­teers, An­to­nio Be­nigno, in Eng­lish. Cour­tesy of His­tor­i­cal Col­lec­tions & Ser­vices, Claude Moore Health Scien­ces Li­brary, Uni­ver­sity of Vir­ginia. The Span­ish ver­sion, with both Reed's and Benigno's sig­na­tures, can be viewed on­line through the Philip S. Hench Wal­ter Reed Yel­low Fever Col­lec­tion

Yel­low fever virus (YFV) is now con­sid­ered the type virus of the Fla­viviri­dae (flavus = yel­low), a large fam­ily that in­cludes the West Nile and dengue viruses (also mos­quito-borne). Lazear's suc­cess in the sum­mer of 1900 was a mat­ter of good tim­ing, so to speak, and can be ex­plained in terms of the virus' bi­ol­ogy. It was crit­i­cal that, in some ex­per­i­ments, Lazear's mos­qui­toes fed on pa­tients in the ear­li­est days of yel­low fever in­fec­tion while the pa­tients were still viremic. Only then does the mos­quito stand a chance of be­com­ing in­fected. More­over, in some cases, Lazear al­lowed more than a dozen days to in­ter­vene be­tween the time a mos­quito fed on an in­fected pa­tient and when the same mos­quito was ap­plied to a naïve sub­ject. This pro­vided the es­sen­tial in­cu­ba­tion pe­riod dur­ing which virus in the freshly in­gested blood could in­fect the gut ep­ithe­lial cells, repli­cate, and even­tu­ally spread via cir­cu­la­tion to the insect's sali­vary tis­sue. Pro­geny virus shed in the mosquito's saliva can then be trans­mit­ted to the next hu­man host. Prior at­tempts to prove the mos­quito hy­poth­e­sis were in­con­clu­sive largely be­cause these con­di­tions were not met.

We highly rec­om­mend a visit to the Philip S. Hench Wal­ter Reed Yel­low Fever On-line Col­lec­tion. The site is a vo­luminous on­line archive of the his­tory of the 1900 Yel­low Fever Com­mis­sion, stocked with thou­sands of docu­ments, pho­tographs, and high qual­ity im­ages of let­ters (per­sonal and of­fi­cial), telegrams, fever charts, maps, draw­ings and gov­ern­ment files. For the in­ter­ested browser, a help­ful start­ing point is the list of high­lights as­sem­bled by the project staff. In com­pil­ing the per­sonal, the of­fi­cial and the seem­ingly mun­dane, the archive suc­ceeds in putting flesh on the bones of a sci­en­tific tale. Among the many thought pro­vok­ing items gath­ered here can be found the orig­i­nal telegram to Mrs. Lazear an­nounc­ing her husband's death and Jesse Lazear's fever chart record­ing the last few days of his life. One can also view what amounts to a pre­de­ces­sor of the mod­ern "in­formed con­sent" form, the orig­i­nal signed con­tracts (some in Span­ish with ac­com­pa­ny­ing trans­la­tion) ac­knowl­edging the risks to life and limb and of­fer­ing compen­sation of $100 to $200 in gold to study par­tic­i­pants. The Camp Lazear ex­per­i­ments rep­re­sent an al­most im­pos­si­ble con­flict be­tween the use of hu­man vol­un­teers and the need to find out how an im­por­tant dis­ease is trans­mit­ted (which could lead to sav­ing un­told lives, and in this case did). For­tu­nately for us, mod­ern tech­nol­ogy of­ten ob­vi­ates the need to con­tem­plate such a dilemma.

 

Welkin Johnson

Welkin is As­sis­tant Pro­fes­sor of Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy and Mol­e­c­u­lar Ge­net­ics at Har­vard Med­ical School, and an As­so­ciate Blog­ger for Small Things Con­sid­ered.

 

Other Posts

  • Pico Who?

    by Elio — You may have heard that the small­est free-liv­ing eu­kary­ote is Os­tre­o­coc­cus tauri. So they say. O. tauri is in­deed a tiny green alga. It is en­dowed with just one chloro­plast, one mi­to­chon­drion, a Golgi body, and not much cy­to­plasm. Some­times it is only 1.0 μm in di­am­e­ter...

  • The Cold Side Of Mi­cro­bial Life

    by Gemma Reguera — The Cold Side Of The Earth In the midst of one of the worst Michi­gan win­ters on record, I felt in­spired to learn more about how mi­crobes cope with the cold (it is true: mis­ery does in­deed like com­pany). So it hap­pens that the po­lar vor­tex that has vis­ited our north­ern states a few times this sea­son has given us a glimpse at the sub­zero tem­per­a­tures that pre­vail in the north­ern lands of our planet, some­times all year...

  • Cox­iella Es­capes from Cell!

    by Elio — Sur­prise! Cox­iella bur­netii, the agent of Q fever, has been grown in cell-free me­dia. This is news be­cause, along with rick­ettsiae and a few oth­ers, C. bur­netii is the stereo­typ­i­cal ob­lig­ate in­tra­cel­lu­lar bac­te­r­ial par­a­site. Un­til now, cox­iel­lae could only be grown within a host or in host cells in cul­ture. So how did...

  • Gi­a­r­dia: "I Did It My Way"

    by Merry — Even if Gi­a­r­dia lam­blia weren't one of the most com­mon hu­man par­a­sites, it would still gar­ner its share of at­ten­tion. It is one of the ear­li­est di­verg­ing eu­kary­otes, and it has its own way of do­ing things. For starters, it has two ap­par­ently equiv­a­lent diploid nu­clei, both of which are tran­scrip­tion­ally ac­tive. Why does this mat­ter?

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Ms. C.A. Voeffray
16 years ago

A clear and very in­ter­st­ing story of Yel­low Fever ex­per­i­ments and the birth of vi­rol­ogy.

16 years ago

Very nice piece but why was ra­bies not the first in­fec­tious dis­ease iden­ti­fied as caused by an or­gan­ism smaller than a bac­terium ? That's a quib­ble. The ar­ti­cle is ex­cel­lent.

Welkin
16 years ago

My un­der­stand­ing is that ra­bies was not shown to be fil­ter­able un­til 1903 (by P. Rem­linger, I think at the Pas­teur In­sti­tute). If we don't in­clude the cri­te­ria of fil­ter­abil­ity, Ra­bies was cer­tainly known to be due to an in­fec­tious agent, and Pas­teur him­self worked on it. But for that mat­ter, a great many dis­eases were known to be in­fec­tious long be­fore the agents were known to be smaller than a bac­terium. The birth of vi­rol­ogy in the 1890's, de­fined as the re­al­iza­tion that there were agents smaller than bac­te­ria, is usu­ally at­trib­uted ei­ther to Ivanof­sky or to Bei­jer­inck, both work­ing on to­bacco mo­saic virus. Fil­ter­abil­ity was not much to go by how­ever, and Bei­jer­inck ap­par­ently en­vi­sioned the agent as be­ing a liq­uid (thus the flu­idum in con­tag­ium vivum flu­idum).

brandt levitt
16 years ago

Why do we imag­ine that Yel­low Fever is reemerg­ing? Is it merely a lack of pub­lic health mea­sures? Why are we see­ing an in­crease in the coun­tries where it oc­curs? Is it just an in­crease in the host range of the mos­qui­toes? Or per­haps the virus has been evolv­ing all this time. I won­der if the se­quence of to­days yfv genome is iden­ti­cal to that of 1900?

elio
16 years ago

Welkin replies:
From what I've read so far (start­ing with the CDC yel­low fever site http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/yellowfever/index.html ) there does seem to be a re-emer­gence of YF in for­merly en­demic coun­tries in re­cent decades, but I also don't think the virus ever "went away". I think there­fore it prob­a­bly has more to do with lack of pub­lic health in­fra­struc­ture, and/or in­ter­rup­tion of com­mu­nity health mea­sures by war, eco­nom­ics, etc, than a bi­o­log­i­cal change in the virus. In this re­gard, it is sim­i­lar to other vac­cine pre­ventable dis­eases, like measles and po­lio, which still oc­cur with some fre­quency when and where vig­i­lance and ap­pli­ca­tion of vac­cine falls short.