The Two Faces of Pho­torhab­dus

by Merry

Ne­ma­todes – those small, non­de­script round­worms – are among the most nu­mer­ous an­i­mals, found in vir­tu­ally every eco­log­i­cal niche. With an es­ti­mated 400,000 to pos­si­bly 10,000,000 species, their di­ver­sity might match that of the in­sects, but no one knows for sure. Most ne­matodes live quiet lives, un­known even by tax­on­o­mists, but one – Caenorhab­di­tis el­e­gans – has made it big time as a model or­gan­ism. Two fam­i­lies of en­to­mopath­o­genic ne­ma­todes have gar­nered much at­ten­tion due to the com­pany they keep. (More about this be­low.) Some 350 mil­lion years ago, each fam­ily, it is thought, in­de­pen­dently be­gan a mu­tu­al­is­tic as­so­ci­a­tion with a lin­eage of en­teric bac­te­ria – one with the lin­eage lead­ing to the genus Pho­torhab­dus, the other with the Xenorhab­dus lin­eage. These ne­ma­tode-bac­te­r­ial teams are deadly par­a­sitoids that prey on di­verse in­sects. Both teams have evolved ob­lig­ate mu­tu­alisms with sim­i­lar life cy­cles, but the un­der­ly­ing mol­e­c­u­lar mech­a­nisms are dis­tinctly dif­fer­ent. We'll fo­cus on Pho­torhab­dus lumi­nes­cens, the most "il­lu­mi­nat­ing" ex­am­ple. For a re­view ar­ti­cle cov­er­ing Xenorhab­dus, click here.

Het­erorhab­di­tis bac­te­rio­phora. Source

Al­though these are soil-dwelling ne­ma­todes, only one lar­val stage, called the in­fec­tive ju­ve­nile (IJ), is found free in the soil. The name is ap­pro­pri­ate, as the IJ is ar­rested at this lar­val stage (it is in di­a­pause) and its sole task is to find and en­ter an in­sect host. The rest of the life cy­cle, in­clud­ing re­pro­duc­tion, takes place within a host.

The life cy­cle of Pho­torhab­dus. Source

Each IJ car­ries qui­es­cent Pho­torhab­dus in its gut. Once in­side a new host, the ne­ma­tode IJ mi­grates to the he­molymph and re­gur­gi­tates the Pho­torhab­dus. The bac­teria quickly launch into a phase path­o­genic to the in­sect, se­cret­ing tox­ins, en­zymes, and anti­bio­tics. Tox­ins ef­fec­tively dis­able the insect's in­nate im­mune de­fenses; en­zymes con­vert host tis­sues into a nu­tri­ent soup; an­tibi­otics pre­serve the ca­daver and, be­ing ef­fec­tive against Xenorhab­dus, limit com­pe­ti­tion from Xenorhab­dus-as­so­ci­ated ne­ma­todes. Ex­per­i­men­tal in­jec­tion of less than 5 bac­te­ria into an insect's he­molymph kills within 48–72 hours. In con­trast, the insect's in­nate im­mune re­sponse can han­dle sim­i­lar in­fec­tion by >106 E. coli.

Pho­torhab­dus lu­mi­nescens strain W14 on an in­sect midgut un­der the col­la­gen sheath. Source

The Pho­torhab­dus grow ex­po­nen­tially for the first 48 hours, reach­ing pop­u­la­tions of 109 per host. By then, all of the host tis­sue has been con­verted into bac­te­r­ial bio­mass – es­sen­tially a mono­cul­ture of Pho­torhab­dus. Mean­while, the IJ ex­its from di­a­pause, be­gins to feed, and con­tin­ues de­vel­op­ment into an adult hermaphro­dite. Pho­torhab­dus then stops grow­ing, and its patho­genic phase gives way to the mu­tu­al­is­tic phase. The ac­cu­mu­lated bac­te­r­ial bio­mass lit­er­ally nour­ishes the ne­ma­todes, pro­vid­ing most, if not all, of their nu­tri­tional re­quire­ments. The picky ne­ma­todes will feed on parti­cular strains only.

The ne­ma­todes re­pro­duce for sev­eral gen­er­a­tions in­side the ca­daver. Then, in re­sponse to envi­ronmental sig­nals, a fi­nal gen­er­a­tion of eggs de­vel­ops into IJs within the body of their mother ne­matode. They re­ceive a vi­tal bac­te­r­ial in­ocu­lum by ma­ter­nal trans­mis­sion, not hap­haz­ardly from the pop­u­la­tion free in the ca­daver. Thus armed, the IJs emerge from the ca­daver and go forth in search of a new host, to re­peat the cy­cle yet once again. Un­der op­ti­mal con­di­tions in the lab, the en­tire cy­cle takes 10–20 days and 100,000 IJs can be pro­duced from in­fec­tion of one in­sect by a sin­gle IJ. Def­i­nitely a well-run op­er­a­tion.

Pho­torhab­dus and Xenorhab­dus have aroused con­sid­er­able in­ter­est as sources of new an­tibi­otics and broad-spec­trum in­sect tox­ins for agri­cul­tural use. They are also po­ten­tial model sys­tems. Con­sider the pos­si­bil­i­ties. First you could com­pare the mech­a­nisms used for patho­gen­e­sis and mutu­alism, and in­ves­ti­gate what it takes to quickly switch from one to the other. Then there are the two sim­i­lar, but dis­tinctly dif­fer­ent, strate­gies evolved by Xenorhab­dus and Pho­torhab­dus. What might they tell us about the mech­a­nisms used by the nu­mer­ous closely-re­lated and well-stud­ied hu­man en­teric pathogens? (Click here for a re­cent re­view dis­cussing these pos­si­bil­i­ties.)

Around the time of in­sect death, the in­sect corpse ap­pears bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent due to the P. lu­mi­nescens within. Source

Pho­torhab­dus, as the name sug­gests, car­ries out biolu­mi­nescence. It also in­fects wounds. This is the stuff of leg­ends, with sto­ries go­ing back to the Amer­i­can Civil War. It seemed that sol­diers with wounds that glowed in the dark were more likely to re­cover. Their im­proved prog­no­sis has been at­trib­uted to the an­tibi­otics pro­duced by Pho­torhab­dus, but this has not been expe­rimentally con­firmed. Pho­torhab­dus is the only ter­res­trial bac­te­ria known to ex­hibit bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence. They lu­mi­nesce only dur­ing their mu­tu­al­is­tic phase, in­side the in­sect ca­daver. What use is this? There is ev­i­dence sug­gesting that this may be a non-func­tional trait, re­cently ac­quired by hor­i­zon­tal gene trans­fer from Vib­rio, and in the process of be­ing lost. And be­sides, Xenorhab­dus gets along just fine in the dark. Makes you won­der if Photo­rhabdus lu­mi­nescens re­ally needs to be lu­mi­nescens.

 

Other Posts

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
17 years ago

Any chance the lu­mi­nes­cent in­sect corpses at­tract dusk-feed­ing or noc­tur­nal an­i­mals, im­prov­ing ge­o­graphic spread of the ready-to-emerge IJs? Maybe there's some in­di­rect se­lec­tion here...
Com­ment on Com­ment
Hi Bob,
My friend Merry is bet­ter qual­i­fied to com­ment but your idea seems very rea­son­able. Look for the light.
Elio
Com­ment on Com­ment on Com­ment...
In­ter­est­ing pos­si­bil­ity, Bob. The in­for­ma­tion that I have on this point comes from a 2008 pa­per by Peat & Adams, avail­able here:
http://mmbio.byu.edu/faculty/bja43/papers/products/adams/Peat2008Symbiosis.pdf
They write: "Pho­torhab­dus, the bac­te­r­ial sym­biont of the ne­ma­tode Het­erorhab­di­tis is typ­i­cally con­fined to the gut of its host and the he­mo­coel of lar­val in­sects, with both hosts in­hab­it­ing soil en­vi­ron­ments. As the phase of Pho­torhab­dus that glows is typ­i­cally only found in in­sect ca­dav­ers, there is no in­tu­itive ben­e­fit of glow­ing to at­tract prey or dis­tract a preda­tor, as all nec­es­sary re­sources for sur­vival and re­pro­duc­tion are present in the in­sect ca­daver."
Thus, they do not con­sider the fac­tor that you sug­gested, i.e., im­prov­ing ge­o­graphic spread. How­ever, as­sum­ing the glow­ing ca­daver is buried within the soil, even that use­ful­ness seems less likely. But who knows...
Merry

17 years ago

I have heard that hy­poth­e­sis, about hor­i­zon­tal trans­mis­sion via pre­da­tion.
Many years ago, I worked a bit in bac­te­r­ial bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence with Vib­rio har­veyi. This won­der­ful lit­tle crit­ter did not have a spe­cific sym­bio­sis, as seen with Vib­rio fis­cheri with squid or the flash­light fish. V. har­veyi, in fact, is com­monly found in the gut of ma­rine crea­tures (as well as plank­ton­i­cally). What is the func­tion of bac­te­r­ial bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence in bac­te­ria that col­o­nize the gut of fish? Pretty dark in there, right? There was ev­i­dence that (sorry about this) fe­cal pel­lets pro­duced by the fish were bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent. And fish tend to like to eat "glow­ing items." Hence the hor­i­zon­tal trans­fer of these gut in­hab­i­tants from fish to fish. Or so we all thought.
I would not be at all sur­prised that glow­ing in­sect car­casses at­tract preda­tors. Yet the level of lu­mi­nes­cence caused by Pho­torhab­dus is quite low!
This brings us all back to the true func­tion of bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence, as Elio has ex­plored ear­lier in this blog. Is it meta­bolic? Dis­play only? It's a fas­ci­nat­ing if vex­ing topic.
It is in­ter­est­ing to note that Pho­torhab­dus is the only ter­res­trial bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent bac­terium de­scribed. My guess is that, as with bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent ma­rine bac­te­ria, it would be pos­si­ble to find iso­lates pro­duc­ing VERY lit­tle light.
Merry, that was a lovely es­say. I love this topic!
And see? I avoided the ob­vi­ous puns through­out!

Paul Orwin
17 years ago

I'm re­ally glad that you've brought this up, since ne­ma­tode-bac­te­ria in­ter­ac­tions have be­come an in­ter­est of mine re­cently (and no, I'm pretty much com­pletely ig­no­rant about them, but I've never let that stop me). The lit­er­a­ture on C. el­e­gans as a model of in­fec­tion is very in­ter­est­ing, al­though still very new. I've been think­ing about how these in­ter­ac­tions ac­tu­ally oc­cur in the en­vi­ron­ment, and how that re­lates to the emer­gence of vir­u­lence (I think of le­gionella and my­cobac­te­ria in amoeba, and how that re­lates to their growth in macrophages). The added layer of com­plex­ity with in­sect-worm-bac­te­ria in this com­plex dance makes my head spin!
Lu­mi­nes­cence is in­ter­est­ing for many rea­sons too, of course, and I'm glad Mark re­minded me that it was right here that I read about the pos­si­ble role(s) of that phe­no­type be­sides the ma­rine sym­biont sce­nario. I'm not sure why there has to be a sin­gle rea­son for hav­ing a gene, though...I don't see why it can't be dif­fer­ent things to dif­fer­ent bac­te­ria (a meta­bolic shunt, a tool for help­ing out fish/squid, a way to im­prove trans­mis­sion, or maybe just some­thing they picked up). I'd say that if we think about it, though, there are ways to ap­proach the prob­lem, es­pe­cially now that strain geno­typ­ing can be done very rapidly and pre­cisely.
For ex­am­ple, we know that there is a non-lu­min­scent sym­biont, but are there non-lu­mi­nes­cent vari­ants of Pho­torhab­dus? what is their ge­o­graphic range? I find it even odder that you can't find them out­side the worm or the in­sect? Am I read­ing too much into the last bit?

17 years ago

Bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence is a fas­ci­nat­ing and vex­ing topic. We know of sev­eral dif­fer­ent and un­re­lated groups of fungi that do it, but why? Of course, at­tract­ing in­sects for spore dessem­i­na­tion is al­ways sug­gested but it's not likely the rea­son, at least not for all sit­u­a­tions. Plus, with the in­cred­i­bly acute sen­sories of in­sects (tac­tile, ol­fac­tory, chemo‑, etc), it seems un­likely that that they "need" to rely on vi­sion. I know that sounds tele­o­log­i­cal, but no more so that hav­ing to find a rea­son for glow­ing in the dark. Maybe it is a shunt system...or maybe it just is. Who knows?
In fungi, some pro­duce sporophores (mush­rooms) that glow, but in oth­ers it's the mycelium that glows...while buried some­where. Some ar­gue that it at­tracts wood in­gest­ing insects...I say that if you have to get that close to see the stuff, you likely al­ready knew it was there via some other method.
Af­ter about a 10 sec­ond search, I couldn't find any pre­vi­ous writ­ings on the topic by Elio...can some­one hook me up with a link?
Also, the jour­nal I edit, Fungi mag­a­zine, will pub­lish an ar­ti­cle on the topic in the near fu­ture. If any reader out there has info on the topic to share, I would GREATLY ap­pre­ci­ate it, as I'm al­ways try­ing to learn more. Thanks!

12 years ago

It is in­ter­est­ing to note that Pho­torhab­dus is the only ter­res­trial bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent bac­terium de­scribed. My guess is that, as with bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cent ma­rine bac­te­ria, it would be pos­si­ble to find iso­lates pro­duc­ing VERY lit­tle light.