Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #46

by Daniel Port­noy

Why don't mam­mals make an­tibi­otics of the type so read­ily made by bac­te­ria and fungi?

 

 

 

 

Other Posts

  • Retro­viruses, the Pla­centa, and the Ge­nomic Junk Drawer

    by Jamie Henzy — By now, many of us are aware that a con­sid­er­able por­tion (45% or more) of the hu­man genome con­sists of trans­pos­able el­e­ments. These are mo­bile ge­netic se­quences, such as Alu re­peats and long and short in­ter­spersed nu­clear el­e­ments (LINEs and SINEs). A whop­ping 18% of this so-called "dark mat­ter…

  • Of Terms in Bi­ol­ogy: Cy­tokines

    by Elio — Cy­tokines are small pro­teins (~5−20 kDa) that play a large role in our de­fenses against in­fec­tion. They stim­u­late both the in­nate and the ac­quired im­mu­nity and co­or­di­nate the in­ter­play be­tween the two, thus can be prop­erly called im­munomod­u­la­tors. There are lots of them, in­clud­ing in­ter­fer­ons, in­ter­leukins, tu­mor necro­sis fac­tors, chemokines...

  • Are Phages the An­swer?

    by S. Mar­vin Fried­man — The emer­gence of mul­ti­ple drug-re­sis­tant bac­te­r­ial strains, the preva­lence of re­cal­ci­trant biofilm con­fig­u­ra­tions, and the re­luc­tance of the phar­ma­ceu­ti­cal in­dus­try to ini­ti­ate new an­tibi­otic dis­cov­ery pro­grams have led to the de­vel­op­ment of a for­mi­da­ble pop­u­la­tion of bac­te­r­ial pathogens that is in­creas­ingly dif­fi­cult to con­trol. Af­ter a long but suc­cess­ful era of re­search…

  • Beget­ting the Eu­karya: An Un­ex­pected Light

    by Franklin M. Harold — Con­cern­ing the ori­gin of eu­kary­otic cells, much has been writ­ten but al­most every­thing re­mains to be set­tled. No one dis­putes that mi­to­chon­dria de­rive from free-liv­ing bac­te­ria that es­tab­lished an in­ti­mate sym­bi­otic re­la­tion­ship with a host of some kind and pro­gres­sively turned into or­ganelles, work­horses of me­tab­o­lism, and a hall­mark of eu­kary­otic…

  • A Sym­bi­otic Is­sue

    by Elio — The Au­gust 2016 is­sue of En­vi­ron­men­tal Mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy is a trea­sure trove of ar­ti­cles on sym­bi­otic re­la­tion­ships. I hap­pen to have a soft spot for the sub­ject (am I sym­bi­otic with sym­bioses?), so this is­sue is a hand­some gift. I will com­ment on just a few of the ar­ti­cles, cho­sen with some ef­fort from all this wealth.

9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
17 years ago

Dr. Port­noy, I have long ad­mired your work. Great ques­tion for dis­cus­sion.
I'm with Ju­lian Davies, that bac­te­r­ial an­tibi­otics may be as much sig­nal­ing mol­e­cules as an­timi­cro­bial agents. I have never seen any ev­i­dence of soil bac­te­ria-syn­the­sized an­tibi­otics in­hibit­ing the growth of other bac­te­ria in mi­cro­cosms. I could be wrong, of course. Dr. Davies sug­gests that we are look­ing at vast over­doses of these agents that have med­ical rel­e­vance.
I don't know about the whole Xenorhabdus/Photorhabdus sit­u­a­tion in­side in­sect car­casses, how­ever. Those bac­te­ria make an­timi­cro­bials, and per­haps they do ex­clude other bac­te­ria af­ter all. It seems like an ex­clu­sive niche.
I haven't heard about eu­kary­otic de­fensins that tar­get trans­la­tion, tran­scrip­tion, or repli­ca­tion di­rectly. They can go af­ter mem­brane in­tegrity. But it is a field far from my own ex­per­tise.
Eu­kary­otes cer­tainly make a wide va­ri­ety of an­timi­cro­bial pro­teins that ap­pear to rec­og­nize as­pects of in­vad­ing prokary­otes. The in­nate and adap­tive im­mune sys­tems are beau­ti­ful things! Hmmm. Do pro­tists make an­timi­cro­bial agents?

17 years ago

You do write pithy com­ments, Mark! Now I have to go look up the word "de­fensin"; I in­tuit what it prob­a­bly means, but I've never en­coun­tered the word be­fore.

Paul Orwin
17 years ago

Ever since I saw Mark's re­ply, I've been think­ing about this (I should have been work­ing). I am go­ing to slightly dis­sent from the sig­nal­ing hy­poth­e­sis ‑that isn't to say that there is no sig­nal­ing role, but that the de­fault as­sump­tion should be that the an­tibi­otics do what we ob­serve them to do, not some­thing else. They are pro­duced at high enough lev­els to have lo­cal strong in­hibitory ef­fects — how­ever, the med­ical rel­e­vance point re­mains. I think there have been some eco­log­i­cal stud­ies show­ing that in some rudi­men­tary mod­els, the pro­duc­tion of an­tibi­otics pre­vented in­va­sion of the pro­duc­ers ter­ri­tory by com­peti­tors — it was late, so I didn't take down the cite, un­for­tu­nately.
Rather than ar­gue against Mark (a bad idea!) I think an in­ter­est­ing pos­si­bil­ity is that fungi and bac­te­ria adopted col­o­niz­ing lifestyles (start­ing from a cell/spore, ex­pand­ing out­ward) whereas pro­to­zoa and later meta­zoans adopted highly motile lifestyles and rel­a­tive au­ton­omy (this leaves out plants ‑sorry for the pun). So one strat­egy is to pro­tect your ter­ri­tory, the other is to leave when the go­ing gets tough? De­fensins would then be ex­plained as a later adap­ta­tion on top of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar­ity.
By the way, while pro­to­zoa may or may not make se­creted an­timi­cro­bials, they cer­tainly have lysosomes...which is where le­gionella and my­cobac­te­ria learned their tricks, right?

17 years ago

Be­cause hu­mans don't com­pete for the same eco­log­i­cal niche as bac­te­ria.
We ben­e­fit from the vast ma­jor­ity of bac­te­ria in our nor­mal flora. It is only in im­muno­com­pro­mised sit­u­a­tions or in­fec­tions that bac­te­ria are not help­ful in our life cy­cle.

17 years ago

Paul, you are very civil, as al­ways. Back atcha, as the say­ing goes.
I am in­ter­ested in those ci­ta­tions show­ing that, say, an­tibi­otic pro­duc­ing Strep­to­myces do "bet­ter" (in terms of niche uti­liza­tion) than non-an­tibi­otic pro­duc­ing Strep­to­myces in meso­cosms. So if you find them, send 'em my way.
I could cer­tainly be wrong (I don't mean to go all So­cratic on you; I am painfully aware of my lim­i­ta­tions, how­ever). We mi­cro­bi­ol­o­gists tend to suf­fer from both co­l­i­cen­tric­ity and even eukaryocentricity—we don't of­ten "look" at things from a "mi­cro­bial per­spec­tive," where (as you sug­gest) the con­cen­tra­tion of a given sig­nal mol­e­cule might be quite high lo­cally. And the Xenorhabdus/Photorhabdus ex­am­ple might be quite apt.
Plants in­deed use many "sta­tion­ary tricks" to ex­clude com­peti­tors (al­lelopa­thy comes to mind), and there is even ev­i­dence that plants un­der­go­ing in­sect at­tack pro­duce volatile sig­nal mol­e­cules that "warn" nearby plants to pre­pare for arthro­pod mandibles!
But Paul's ideas give me plenty to think about...
As for Brandt Levitt's com­ment, we *are* a com­plex col­lec­tion of niches for which hu­man as­so­ci­ated mi­crobes com­pete. What is the say­ing (some­one from UC River­side, I think)?: hu­mans are noth­ing but a bunch of ecosys­tems, walk­ing around.

17 years ago

An­other com­par­a­tively pro­saic rea­son might be the com­men­sal na­ture of our own mi­cro­biota — how many gen­er­a­tions would it take to go from the first crude an­tibi­otic ex­cre­tion to some­thing that some­how only tar­gets "harm­ful" mi­crobes?
Yet an­other, re­lated to this, is the fact that fast-re­pro­duc­ing bac­te­ria and fungi can evolve de­fenses to an­tibi­otics much, much faster than any mam­mal pop­u­la­tion could keep up with, so even as­sum­ing by some amaz­ing co­in­ci­dence that some mam­mal be­gan pro­duc­ing an an­tibi­otic that tar­geted only a com­mon harm­ful mi­crobe, re­sis­tant strains of that same mi­crobe would be likely to show up in the pop­u­la­tion be­fore the next gen­er­a­tion could even get started...

Mehmet Berkmen
17 years ago

does bile acid in the gut, lysozyme in tears and an­timi­cro­bial prop­er­ties of the Rhino sweat (I just read that) con­sti­tute as mam­malian an­tibi­otics? these se­cre­tions tar­get cer­tain bac­te­ria and reach a bal­ance be­tween killing harm­ful bac­te­ria and se­lect­ing for use­ful ones.
no?

17 years ago

I have my own an­swers about is­sues in­volv­ing the lack of se­lec­tive pres­sure due to be­ing a highly mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­ism...
,,,BUT...
...the in­sight­ful re­sponses that are ALWAYS of­fered for these 'Tal­mundic Ques­tions' are...for lack of bet­ter words....inspiring. Thanks com­menters for ALWAYS push­ing my brain....

Tom Atherholt
17 years ago

Maybe be­cause (with some ex­cep­tions) their role in na­ture is not to kill other mi­crobes but to com­mu­ni­cate and in­ter­act with other mi­crobes (Mlot, C. 2009, Sci­ence, 324: 1637–1639). In­ter­cel­lu­lar com­mu­ni­ca­tion mech­a­nisms be­tween cells of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms might be dif­fer­ent be­cause the cells are not sep­a­rated in space? That is, the types of sig­nalling mol­e­cules (pro­teins, nu­cleic acids, etc.) used by cells of mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms can be more "frag­ile" be­cause they do not have to en­ter the "en­vi­ron­ment" be­fore reach­ing their "tar­get" cells? Maybe.