Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #35

In Twisted Bac­te­ria, César Sanchez poses the ques­tion: Why don't plants have any chlamy­dial sym­bionts? He pro­poses sev­eral pos­si­ble an­swers and in­vites fur­ther spec­u­la­tion. We sug­gest you go to his web­site and post your com­ments there.

 

Other Posts

  • Retro­viruses, the Pla­centa, and the Ge­nomic Junk Drawer

    by Jamie Henzy — By now, many of us are aware that a con­sid­er­able por­tion (45% or more) of the hu­man genome con­sists of trans­pos­able el­e­ments. These are mo­bile ge­netic se­quences, such as Alu re­peats and long and short in­ter­spersed nu­clear el­e­ments (LINEs and SINEs). A whop­ping 18% of this so-called "dark mat­ter…

  • There is Hope

    by Elio — Through the years, we have not had many op­por­tu­ni­ties to look for­wards, to get a feel­ing for how sci­ence is taught in mid­dle and high schools. But we have had a cou­ple of won­der­ful en­coun­ters, one with the Jef­fer­son Mid­dle School and Mrs. Put­nam, their sixth grade teacher in Jack­son, Mis­sis­sippi…

  • Fine Read­ing: The Life and Times of Paul Buch­ner

    by Roberto — In prepar­ing our re­cent post on ec­tosym­bionts, I dis­cov­ered Jan Sapp's 2002 per­spec­tive: "Paul Buch­ner (1886 –1978) and hered­i­tary sym­bio­sis in in­sects." I sus­pect that many STC read­ers will im­me­di­ately rec­og­nize the name of Paul Buch­ner, af­ter whom Paul Bau­mann named the now well-known aphid en­dosym­biont Buch­n­era. But I also sus­pect most will not know too much about Buchner's sem­i­nal con­tri­bu­tions...

  • Gen­er­a­tion of Di­ver­sity, Phage Style

    by Merry & Elio — We are proud of our adap­tive im­mune sys­tem, and right­fully so. Splen­did is its abil­ity to rec­og­nize and re­spond to for­eign mol­e­cules – even ones never pre­vi­ously en­coun­tered in our evo­lu­tion­ary his­tory. Cen­tral to this is our tal­ent for gen­er­at­ing an­ti­bod­ies and T‑cell anti­gen re­cep­tors with many, many dif­fer­ent speci­fici­ties.

  • Life With­out Sun­shine

    by Merry and Elio — In 1998, a re­spected as­tronomer and physi­cist turned ge­ol­o­gist, Thomas Gold, wrote a highly in­flu­en­tial book, The Deep Hot Bios­phere, in which he ar­gued that there is abun­dant mi­cro­bial life in the wa­ter within the pores, cracks and fis­sures of the rocks be­neath our...

  • A Bug in a Bug in a Bug

    by Elio — Rat­tling around in­side my head for some time has been the re­ported dis­cov­ery that there are bac­te­ria that live within other bac­te­ria. To me, this is an hon­est-to-good­ness gee-whiz piece of mi­cro­bial lore. Made me won­der why the story had not been fol­lowed up on. Could be be­cause you have…

3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
18 years ago

I would tend to sus­pect that it's be­cause Chlamy­dia-type bac­te­ria are sub­stan­tially less en­vi­ron­ment-re­sis­tant that viruses.
As far as I know, all plant viruses re­quire phys­i­cal dam­age to the plant cells to achieve an ini­tial in­fec­tion (though some or all of them can then pass vi­ral ma­te­r­ial from cell to cell once in­fec­tion is es­tab­lished). I sus­pect that due to the cell wall, the same would be true of en­dopar­a­sitic bac­te­ria like Chlamy­dia.
Since es­tab­lish­ing an in­fec­tion means hang­ing around on the sur­face of ei­ther a plant or some­thing that will dam­age a plant (such as in­sects or an­i­mal claws) for ex­tended pe­ri­ods, I'm guess few or none of these types of bac­te­ria pos­sess that kind of har­di­ness. I'd fur­ther guess that this might have some­thing to do with their tiny size — don't they have an es­pe­cially small genome? No room for ex­tra "bonus" genes to pro­vide some kind of adap­ta­tion like spore for­ma­tion.

18 years ago

(And, yes, I've tried post­ing at the "twisted bac­te­ria" blog sev­eral times now. Blog­ger is once again er­ror­ing out on com­ments and los­ing them. Ugh.)

stan zahler
18 years ago

I guess I'm not so sure that chlamy­dia are ten­der. Psit­ta­co­sis gets around from bird to bird (and oc­ca­sion­ally bird to hu­mans) in aerosols, which have to be tough en­vi­ron­ments es­pe­cially as they dry out. Get­ting through plant cell walls is trick­ier. Has any­body ever tried to in­fect scratched Ara­bidop­sis leaves with a lot of chlamy­dia?
— stan zahler