Why Have Lec­tures?

by Elio

Re­cently, I wrote an ar­ti­cle called In De­fense of the Lec­ture (PDF) It ap­peared in Res­o­nance, a sci­ence ed­u­ca­tion jour­nal of the In­dian Acad­emy of Sci­ences. If you care to know what this is about, here is the first para­graph from the ar­ti­cle:

"When it comes to teach­ing, every­one is an ex­pert, so why not me? Any amount of ex­pe­ri­ence, large or small, guar­an­tees that one will hold strong views. I am no ex­cep­tion. In the course of over 50 years, per­haps 20,000 stu­dents have had to lis­ten to me, the ma­jor­ity of whom I prob­a­bly bored, a few whom I may have stim­u­lated. I have no for­mal train­ing in ped­a­gogy. With these du­bi­ous creden­tials, let me make a sin­gle point: Lec­tures are a vi­tal as­pect of uni­ver­sity teach­ing."

Come­nius, Or­bis sen­su­al­ium pic­tus. Source

 

Other Posts

  • That Scary Re­stroom Mi­cro­biota

    by Elio & Joshua Fierer — News­pa­pers and other me­dia are re­port­ing with reg­u­lar fre­quency that re­strooms, ATM ma­chine pads, money bills, and other sites carry many dif­fer­ent mi­crobes upon their sur­faces in­clud­ing po­ten­tially path­o­genic bac­te­ria and viruses. Head­lines call at­ten­tion to such scary-sound­ing news and alarm the gen­eral pub­lic. We can ex­pect that this prac­tice…

  • Hello Again, Me­tab­o­lism!

    by Amy Cheng Vollmer — Years ago, path­ways of in­ter­me­di­ary me­tab­o­lism made up a sig­nif­i­cant por­tion of bio­chem­istry and mi­cro­bi­ol­ogy courses. Therein, stu­dents learned about in­ter­con­ver­sions and con­nec­tions be­tween path­ways, and they could fol­low the car­bons as they moved from ac­etate into the cho­les­terol mol­e­cule...

  • An Ex­cep­tional Vin­tage

    by Roberto — I had a dream. I be­lieve it was greatly influenc­ed by a pa­per I read re­cent­ly. It de­scribes the fun­gal po­pu­la­tions and the me­ta­bo­lo­mics of Cor­vi­na grapes (Vi­tis vi­ni­fe­ra L. cv. Cor­vi­na). For those of you not deep­ly steep­ed in wine­mak­ing, Cor­vi­na grapes serve as the sta­ple for...

  • A Short His­tory of Yo­gurt

    by Roberto — Ru­mor has it that the com­bi­na­tion of yo­gurt and honey is the "food of the gods." I can't vouch for that since I have not had the chance to query the gods about their di­ets. Yet just the other day, while en­joy­ing ar­ti­sanal Greek-style yo­gurt topped with lo­cal raw honey, I closed my eyes and was im­me­di­ately trans­ported...

  • Blog­gers in Boston

    by Elio — On the oc­ca­sion of the ASM Gen­eral Meet­ing in Boston early in June, about a dozen of us in­ter­ested in sci­ence blogs met for a dis­cus­sion of blog-re­lated is­sues. Sev­eral of the peo­ple in at­ten­dance were blog­gers, no­tably...

  • Primo Levi's pe­ri­odic ta­ble, ...

    by Janie — There are lots of fan­tas­tic books that con­vey love of a sci­ence, de­pict the braided lines of logic and in­tu­ition and luck in ex­per­i­men­ta­tion, and de­pict sci­en­tists' lives both in and be­yond the lab. Mem­oir, fic­tion, bi­og­ra­phy. 'Sci­ence' as metaphor for life, these books will fre­quently al­lude to...

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
stanley zahler
18 years ago

I couldn't agree more.
I sus­pect that en­thu­si­asm is the Num­ber One cri­te­rion for a good lec­ture, or lec­turer.
I've al­ways thought that mul­ti­ple-choice ques­tions were rather use­less for test­ing. Gen­er­ally speak­ing, I used take-home ex­ams, pretty much open-ended, with pretty tough ques­tions. I don't know if that would work in a time of In­ter­net, Google, and In­stant Mes­sag­ing, though.

18 years ago

Quite an es­say! Very heart-felt and suc­cinct. I don't have a col­lege ed­u­ca­tion — af­ter high school I ed­u­cated my­self. Per­haps not the best choice, but I do en­joy read­ing ac­counts of the tri­als and tribu­la­tions of those who at­tempt to ed­u­cate young peo­ple!