Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #18

A good TQ is one that in­vites an­other ques­tion. We pre­viously asked: In­ver­te­brates are said to have only in­nate im­mu­nity. Why do you sup­pose they have not evolved ac­quired im­mu­nity, as ver­te­brates have done?  Let us now turn it around and ask: Why have ver­te­brates evolved ac­quired im­mu­nity?

 

Other Posts

  • A Mold That Changed the Course of His­tory

    by Mercè Pi­queras — Re­cently, 'Na­ture' pub­lished an ar­ti­cle about the genome se­quence and analy­sis of Phy­toph­thora in­fes­tans, the oomycete that caused the potato blight in the 19th cen­tury that changed the course of his­tory. Phy­toph­thora in­fes­tans is the rea­son that to­day about 11% of the pop­u­la­tion of the United States is of Irish ori­gin and...

  • Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #158

    The ge­nie has re­turned yet again. (He al­ready vis­ited once back in 2007.) On a moon­lit night, you walk on the beach, stub your toe against a bot­tle, which con­ve­niently rolls against a rock and shat­ters. A ge­nie emerges, ea­ger to grant you one wish. You ask for a mi­cro­bi­o­log­i­cal lab­o­ra­tory. The ge­nie grants you that, and tells you that you...

  • Bac­te­ria Ac­ti­vate Fun­gal Gene Clus­ters

    by S. Mar­vin Fried­man — Fungi are no­to­ri­ous for their abil­ity to pro­duce a wide va­ri­ety of sec­ondary metabo­lites, in­clud­ing an­tibi­otics, statins, im­muno­sup­pres­sants, my­co­tox­ins, and oth­ers. A ver­i­ta­ble phar­ma­copeia. In­ter­est­ingly, many of the gene clus­ters in­volved in the biosyn­the­sis of these com­pounds are silent un­der nor­mal lab­o­ra­tory con­di­tions. In some cases, the syn­the­sis of these…

  • No Free Lunch for Cheaters

    by S. Mar­vin Fried­man — Bac­te­ria en­gage in a va­ri­ety of be­hav­iors that re­quire co­or­di­nated gene ex­pres­sion, such as bi­o­lu­mi­nes­cence, biofilm for­ma­tion, pro­duc­tion of vir­u­lence fac­tors, and an­tibi­otic re­sis­tance. In these sit­u­a­tions, gene ex­pres­sion re­quires a crit­i­cal num­ber of cells. In its ab­sence, the ex­er­cise would be in vain, some­thing like...

  • The Mi­crobe That Could Be Seen

    by Elio — Bi­ol­ogy is re­plete with de­f­i­n­i­tions that have ex­cep­tions. A mi­crobe (from the Greek roots mikros and bios for small life) is typ­i­cally de­fined as a mi­cro­scopic liv­ing or­gan­ism in­vis­i­ble to the naked eye. It is clearly in the na­ture of liv­ing things to stretch our de­f­i­n­i­tions, bend the rules. There are bac­te­ria (surely mi­crobes) that...

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Ian
19 years ago

I missed the pre­vi­ous ques­tion, and I dis­agree with the premise that in­verts don't have an ac­quired im­mune sys­tem. There's good ev­i­dence that in­verts do have some­thing con­cep­tu­ally sim­i­lar to an adap­tive im­mune re­sponse; for ex­am­ple, the large num­ber of splice vari­ants of Dscam in in­sects (Sci­ence. 2005;309(5742):1874–8.). Lam­preys, also, were con­sid­ered to not have an adap­tive im­mune re­sponse and don't in fact have a stan­dard ver­te­brate im­mune re­sponse, but do have a quite dif­fer­ent but par­al­lel sys­tem of com­bi­na­to­r­ial com­plex­ity that looks very much like an adap­tive re­sponse (Sci­ence. 2005; 310(5756):1970–3.). The re­cent pa­per on the sea urchin im­mune sys­tem (Sci­ence 2006;314(5801):952 — 956) says:
Re­cent find­ings sug­gest that so­matic mech­a­nisms of re­cep­tor di­ver­si­fi­ca­tion anal­o­gous to those of the ac­quired sys­tem of jawed ver­te­brates may be a more wide­spread fea­ture of an­i­mal im­mu­nity than pre­vi­ously sup­posed. Ex­am­ples of these in­clude a gene conversion–like process that di­ver­si­fies vari­able leucine-rich re­peat (LRR)–containing re­cep­tor (VLR) pro­teins in jaw­less ver­te­brates (9, 10), so­matic mu­ta­tion of fib­rino­gen-re­lated pro­tein (FREP) re­cep­tors in a mol­lusc (11), and ex­ten­sive al­ter­na­tive splic­ing of the Down syn­drome cell ad­he­sion mol­e­cule (DSCAM), a mol­e­cule that prin­ci­pally guides neu­ronal pat­tern­ing, to gen­er­ate im­mune re­ac­tive iso­forms in in­sects (12, 13). On the ba­sis of this nar­row sam­pling, it is likely that a uni­verse of novel and dy­namic im­mune mech­a­nisms ex­ists among the in­ver­te­brates, fur­ther val­i­dat­ing their role as sig­nif­i­cant im­mune mod­els.
Given that, the an­swer to your ques­tion "Why have ver­te­brates evolved ac­quired im­mu­nity?" is that for ver­te­brates, as for in­ver­te­brates, an adap­tive im­mune re­sponse is a use­ful way to re­spond to re­peated in­fec­tion — so use­ful, in fact, that it's been re­dis­cov­ered many times, in many dif­fer­ent forms.
That makes today's ques­tion a less in­ter­est­ing one, I think. The ques­tion be­comes an ex­ten­sion of the pre­vi­ous one, and just fo­cuses on the "as ver­te­brates have done part" — why have ver­te­brates gained the par­tic­u­lar form of adap­tive im­mu­nity that we use? Here the an­swer is very likely, "Chance". Adap­tive im­mu­nity arose pretty much full-fledged in sharks. It's (prob­a­bly) in this form be­cause the re­com­bi­nase genes that sharks and their de­scen­dants use (RAGs) are de­scended from a par­tic­u­lar trans­po­son, and it only hap­pened to jump into the right place and take on the right func­tion in sharks (Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006 Mar 7;103(10):3728–33) — a for­tu­itous ac­ci­dent that hap­pened to work pretty well, but per­haps not as much bet­ter than the al­ter­na­tives as we've been think­ing.

19 years ago

I think this TQ is a very in­ter­est­ing ques­tion (and a sig­nif­i­cant one for the squid-vib­rio sys­tem). I'd an­swer this ques­tion with ANOTHER ques­tion: What is dif­fer­ent about the mi­cro­bial in­ter­ac­tions ver­te­brates ex­pe­ri­ence com­pared to in­ver­te­brates?