Talmudic Question #14

Why are so many more phyla of Gram-negative bacteria than of Gram-positives (at least in the more conventionally used phylogenetic schemes)?

Why are so many more phyla of Gram-negative bacteria than of Gram-positives (at least in the more conventionally used phylogenetic schemes)?
by Elio — Bacteria are masters at making multiple uses of their components. Thus, their constituents can serve a variety of dissimilar functions. An example is the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of the Gram negative cell outer membrane. This uniquely bacterial constituent is important stabilizing the structure of the membrane. In addition,...
by Ramy Karam Aziz — Hi friends, every now and then I like to share one of the good student answers. In the last Micro101 final exam, I gave them this question: If you were a bacterium and you would have the choice of...
by Elio & Merry — The now famous announcement by the Venter group is based on their paper in Science entitled Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome. We applaud this work for its impressive technical achievement and we acknowledge its future potential. However, we find the term "creation" to...
by Christoph — El Hierro is the last in a row of islands in the Canary archipelago, Atlantic Ocean: the farthest west and farthest south, the smallest, and youngest. Its geographic coordinates 27°45'N 18°00'W translate to a longitude of ~450 km west of the Moroccan coast, and to the latitude of Tampa, Florida. All Islas Canarias are...
by Elio — Syntrophy or "eating together" is a kind of symbiosis widespread in biology and of great importance for key biochemical transactions on this planet. Indeed, the cycling of carbon in many of its aspects depends on microbial syntrophy. Thus, the breakdown of waste material critically depends on chemical modifications brought about...
by Elio — It is not unexpected that the contemplation of bacteria and archaea should focus so much on the nature and importance of their cell envelopes. Here, after all, is the interface between the cell's interior and the outside world. It is also what a host perceives early on when becoming infected. Plus, as was...
Well, the snarky answer is that many more human pathogens are Gram negative than are Gram positive and so Gram negatives have been studied more (sampling biases).
Resubmitted: The last one got lost.
Gram's stain seems to work by staining the cell membrane. If the membrane is simple, the stain goes throughout. But, if the membrane is surrounded by a lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bilayer, the decolorizer strips it off, leaving an unstained cell to pick up the weaker secondary stain.
The lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bilayer is usually present on more complex, and more adapted organisms. It allows for greater control of electrolyte and fluid concentrations independent of the environment around it. The simpler (Gram positive) organisms usually do not have that capability, at least to that extent.
Therefore, seemingly by definition, Gram negative organisms are more complex and more evolved than Gram positive organisms. If they are more evolved, then there will be more variations, leading to further branching than the relatively stable Gram positive organisms.
Also, the lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bilayer is present on more than just unicellular organisms, all the way up to complex multicellular organisms such as humans and other animals. This commonality stretching from prokaryocytes to mammals shows the prevalence of the lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bilayer across the higher orders of taxonomy, such as kingdom or phyla.
Gram negative organisms are more complex and more evolved than Gram positive organisms.
I would tend to dispute this, at least as stated. This statement seems to be conflating complexity with "evolvedness" (to invoke a neologism.).
In a fit of pedantry, I might argue that, really, all modern bacteria are just as "evolved" from the hypothetical last common ancestor of all prokaryotes as any other.
More practically, I remember running into a couple of papers discussing the evolution of prokaryotes as inferred from molecular data (16s rDNA sequences).[1,2] I got the impression that there was some reasonable evidence that, rather being being an organism that suffered some sort of "arrested evolution" while the "gram-negatives" continued developing, the "Gram-positives" (including the "High G+C Gram Positives" i.e. actinobacteria) may have split off from the "Gram-negative" line. I take that to imply that the simpler cell-wall structure of the firmicutes may easily have resulted from loss of the complexity from the cell wall during evolutionary development, as opposed to having never developed it in the first place.
If I remember correctly, all of the prokaryotes have cell membranes, though the "gram-negative" bacteria have both an inner and outer membrane (with a thin cell wall between them) while the "gram-positive" ("Low G+C Gram positives" i.e. firmicutes) bacteria have only the inner membrane and a thick cell wall...except for the mollicutes (Mycoplasma, for example) which appear to have also lost the cell wall altogether.
What in the name of Carl Woese is happening to me? A few semesters* of college and I find myself engaging in spontaneous "lecturing" to counter a perceived "slur" against a group of bacteria? Does enough college do this to everyone, or am I just a nerd?**...
[1] Sheridan PP, Freeman KH, Brenchley JE: "Estimated minimal divergence times of the major bacterial and archaeal phyla." Geomicrobiol J 2003, 20:1–14.
[2] Battistuzzi1 FU, Feijao A, Hedges SB: "A genomic timescale of prokaryote evolution: insights into the origin of methanogenesis, phototrophy, and the colonization of land." BMC Evolutionary Biology 2004, 4:44
* — well, okay, off and on for 20 years now, but as I'm still technically an undergraduate at least until the end of the summer I still think of it as "a few" semesters.
** — I'm probably just a nerd. I actually recently did a whole blog post, just for fun, on the subject of the firmicutes...which may be found here if anyone's interested (since this blog seems to reject HTML out of hand:
http://www.bigroom.org/wordpress/?p=37
The correct answer to the question, I think, was given by Jonathon Badger: there are more Gram-negative parasites of man than Gram-positive.
The concept of "complexity" in prokaryotes is very slippery. I think the only possible measure of it is genome size. In that case, there are examples of "complex" prokaryotes among Gram-positives (like Streptomyces) as well as among Gram-negatives (like Stigmatella).
On the other hand, when you get to eukaryotes — with two or even three different genomes in a single cell, and with translation physically separated from transcription, and with organelles like nuclei present — "complexity" requires different criteria. Maybe Wallace Arthur's book on evo-devo, Creatures of Accident, gives some good ideas.
An interesting paper in PNAS (104:11889–11894, 2007) describes a new Gram + phylum called TM7, with members found under peoples' tongues; none has ever been grown in culture, but the paper describes techniques and devices for getting their DNA sequences and deriving their characteristics.