Tal­mu­dic Ques­tion #14

Why are so many more phyla of Gram-neg­a­tive bac­te­ria than of Gram-pos­i­tives (at least in the more convention­al­ly used phy­lo­ge­netic schemes)?

 

Other Posts

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
19 years ago

Well, the snarky an­swer is that many more hu­man pathogens are Gram neg­a­tive than are Gram pos­i­tive and so Gram neg­a­tives have been stud­ied more (sam­pling bi­ases).

Neil M.
19 years ago

Re­sub­mit­ted: The last one got lost.
Gram's stain seems to work by stain­ing the cell mem­brane. If the mem­brane is sim­ple, the stain goes through­out. But, if the mem­brane is sur­rounded by a lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bi­layer, the de­col­orizer strips it off, leav­ing an un­stained cell to pick up the weaker sec­ondary stain.
The lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bi­layer is usu­ally present on more com­plex, and more adapted or­gan­isms. It al­lows for greater con­trol of elec­trolyte and fluid con­cen­tra­tions in­de­pen­dent of the en­vi­ron­ment around it. The sim­pler (Gram pos­i­tive) or­gan­isms usu­ally do not have that ca­pa­bil­ity, at least to that ex­tent.
There­fore, seem­ingly by de­f­i­n­i­tion, Gram neg­a­tive or­gan­isms are more com­plex and more evolved than Gram pos­i­tive or­gan­isms. If they are more evolved, then there will be more vari­a­tions, lead­ing to fur­ther branch­ing than the rel­a­tively sta­ble Gram pos­i­tive or­gan­isms.
Also, the lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bi­layer is present on more than just uni­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms, all the way up to com­plex mul­ti­cel­lu­lar or­gan­isms such as hu­mans and other an­i­mals. This com­mon­al­ity stretch­ing from prokary­ocytes to mam­mals shows the preva­lence of the lipopolysaccharide/phospholipid bi­layer across the higher or­ders of tax­on­omy, such as king­dom or phyla.

SMC
19 years ago

Gram neg­a­tive or­gan­isms are more com­plex and more evolved than Gram pos­i­tive or­gan­isms.
I would tend to dis­pute this, at least as stated. This state­ment seems to be con­flat­ing com­plex­ity with "evolved­ness" (to in­voke a ne­ol­o­gism.).
In a fit of pedantry, I might ar­gue that, re­ally, all mod­ern bac­te­ria are just as "evolved" from the hy­po­thet­i­cal last com­mon an­ces­tor of all prokary­otes as any other.
More prac­ti­cally, I re­mem­ber run­ning into a cou­ple of pa­pers dis­cussing the evo­lu­tion of prokary­otes as in­ferred from mol­e­c­u­lar data (16s rDNA sequences).[1,2] I got the im­pres­sion that there was some rea­son­able ev­i­dence that, rather be­ing be­ing an or­gan­ism that suf­fered some sort of "ar­rested evo­lu­tion" while the "gram-neg­a­tives" con­tin­ued de­vel­op­ing, the "Gram-pos­i­tives" (in­clud­ing the "High G+C Gram Pos­i­tives" i.e. acti­nobac­te­ria) may have split off from the "Gram-neg­a­tive" line. I take that to im­ply that the sim­pler cell-wall struc­ture of the fir­mi­cutes may eas­ily have re­sulted from loss of the com­plex­ity from the cell wall dur­ing evo­lu­tion­ary de­vel­op­ment, as op­posed to hav­ing never de­vel­oped it in the first place.
If I re­mem­ber cor­rectly, all of the prokary­otes have cell mem­branes, though the "gram-neg­a­tive" bac­te­ria have both an in­ner and outer mem­brane (with a thin cell wall be­tween them) while the "gram-pos­i­tive" ("Low G+C Gram pos­i­tives" i.e. fir­mi­cutes) bac­te­ria have only the in­ner mem­brane and a thick cell wall...except for the mol­li­cutes (My­coplasma, for ex­am­ple) which ap­pear to have also lost the cell wall al­to­gether.
What in the name of Carl Woese is hap­pen­ing to me? A few se­mes­ters* of col­lege and I find my­self en­gag­ing in spon­ta­neous "lec­tur­ing" to counter a per­ceived "slur" against a group of bac­te­ria? Does enough col­lege do this to every­one, or am I just a nerd?**...
[1] Sheri­dan PP, Free­man KH, Brench­ley JE: "Es­ti­mated min­i­mal di­ver­gence times of the ma­jor bac­te­r­ial and ar­chaeal phyla." Ge­omi­cro­biol J 2003, 20:1–14.
[2] Battistuzzi1 FU, Fei­jao A, Hedges SB: "A ge­nomic timescale of prokary­ote evo­lu­tion: in­sights into the ori­gin of methano­gen­e­sis, pho­totro­phy, and the col­o­niza­tion of land." BMC Evo­lu­tion­ary Bi­ol­ogy 2004, 4:44
* — well, okay, off and on for 20 years now, but as I'm still tech­ni­cally an un­der­grad­u­ate at least un­til the end of the sum­mer I still think of it as "a few" se­mes­ters.
** — I'm prob­a­bly just a nerd. I ac­tu­ally re­cently did a whole blog post, just for fun, on the sub­ject of the firmicutes...which may be found here if anyone's in­ter­ested (since this blog seems to re­ject HTML out of hand:
http://www.bigroom.org/wordpress/?p=37

stan zahler
19 years ago

The cor­rect an­swer to the ques­tion, I think, was given by Jonathon Bad­ger: there are more Gram-neg­a­tive par­a­sites of man than Gram-pos­i­tive.
The con­cept of "com­plex­ity" in prokary­otes is very slip­pery. I think the only pos­si­ble mea­sure of it is genome size. In that case, there are ex­am­ples of "com­plex" prokary­otes among Gram-pos­i­tives (like Strep­to­myces) as well as among Gram-neg­a­tives (like Stig­matella).
On the other hand, when you get to eu­kary­otes — with two or even three dif­fer­ent genomes in a sin­gle cell, and with trans­la­tion phys­i­cally sep­a­rated from tran­scrip­tion, and with or­ganelles like nu­clei present — "com­plex­ity" re­quires dif­fer­ent cri­te­ria. Maybe Wal­lace Arthur's book on evo-devo, Crea­tures of Ac­ci­dent, gives some good ideas.

stan zahler
19 years ago

An in­ter­est­ing pa­per in PNAS (104:11889–11894, 2007) de­scribes a new Gram + phy­lum called TM7, with mem­bers found un­der peo­ples' tongues; none has ever been grown in cul­ture, but the pa­per de­scribes tech­niques and de­vices for get­ting their DNA se­quences and de­riv­ing their char­ac­ter­is­tics.